Which will sell more?
And state which you think will be better.
This topic is locked from further discussion.
I'm thinking GTAIV.
It's not gonna sell as well as the past entries but it'll still beat SSBB I think.
It's a toss up, every single Wii owner in existance is waiting for SSBB
But most 360 owners and PS3 owners are waiting for GTA 4
And userbase of 360+PS3 is a bit larger than Wii
But for those 12 year old kids wanting GTA, most parents now know what GTA is, and many will probably block the purchase.
Definitely GTA
Why? It is multiplatform. And you can pretty much guarantee that a lot of PS3 and 360 owners will buy GTA.
For sales... that's a tough choice....
For quality, I know that I would much rather play SSBB than GTA4, mainly because GTA4 isn't my kind of game. I'm sure GTA4 will be reviewed better though.
perfect on famitsu, 7th game ever to do that, what better reviews do u want?For sales... that's a tough choice....
For quality, I know that I would much rather play SSBB than GTA4, mainly because GTA4 isn't my kind of game. I'm sure GTA4 will be reviewed better though.
nintendofreak_2
perfect on famitsu, 7th game ever to do that, what better reviews do u want?MasterfubuThe Japanese have *very* different tastes than the Americans and Europeans.
I'm not saying I don't trust Famitsu, they're held in high esteem for me, but one review does not necessarily reflect all other reviews.
The Japanese have *very* different tastes than the Americans and Europeans.[QUOTE="Masterfubu"]perfect on famitsu, 7th game ever to do that, what better reviews do u want?nintendofreak_2
I'm not saying I don't trust Famitsu, they're held in high esteem for me, but one review does not necessarily reflect all other reviews.
only review so far[QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"]perfect on famitsu, 7th game ever to do that, what better reviews do u want?For sales... that's a tough choice....
For quality, I know that I would much rather play SSBB than GTA4, mainly because GTA4 isn't my kind of game. I'm sure GTA4 will be reviewed better though.
Masterfubu
That's one review. Remember, it's only hyped AA here because SSB has never scored AAA at GS before. And GTA, well... In their podcast, IGN sounds pretty pissed about the SSE and I wouldn't be extremely shocked if it scored an 8.9 there.
[QUOTE="Masterfubu"][QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"]perfect on famitsu, 7th game ever to do that, what better reviews do u want?For sales... that's a tough choice....
For quality, I know that I would much rather play SSBB than GTA4, mainly because GTA4 isn't my kind of game. I'm sure GTA4 will be reviewed better though.
Jimmi323
That's one review. Remember, it's only hyped AA here because SSB has never scored AAA at GS before. And GTA, well... In their podcast, IGN sounds pretty pissed about the SSE and I wouldn't be extremely shocked if it scored an 8.9 there.
What does SSE mean?[QUOTE="Masterfubu"][QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"]perfect on famitsu, 7th game ever to do that, what better reviews do u want?For sales... that's a tough choice....
For quality, I know that I would much rather play SSBB than GTA4, mainly because GTA4 isn't my kind of game. I'm sure GTA4 will be reviewed better though.
Jimmi323
That's one review. Remember, it's only hyped AA here because SSB has never scored AAA at GS before. And GTA, well... In their podcast, IGN sounds pretty pissed about the SSE and I wouldn't be extremely shocked if it scored an 8.9 there.
what did they not like about the SSE?
[QUOTE="Jimmi323"][QUOTE="Masterfubu"][QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"]perfect on famitsu, 7th game ever to do that, what better reviews do u want?For sales... that's a tough choice....
For quality, I know that I would much rather play SSBB than GTA4, mainly because GTA4 isn't my kind of game. I'm sure GTA4 will be reviewed better though.
haris12121212
That's one review. Remember, it's only hyped AA here because SSB has never scored AAA at GS before. And GTA, well... In their podcast, IGN sounds pretty pissed about the SSE and I wouldn't be extremely shocked if it scored an 8.9 there.
What does SSE mean?subspace emissary, the adventure mode.MasterfubuOhh okay, I though he talked about something SSE in GTA got confused..
[QUOTE="Masterfubu"][QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"]perfect on famitsu, 7th game ever to do that, what better reviews do u want?For sales... that's a tough choice....
For quality, I know that I would much rather play SSBB than GTA4, mainly because GTA4 isn't my kind of game. I'm sure GTA4 will be reviewed better though.
Jimmi323
That's one review. Remember, it's only hyped AA here because SSB has never scored AAA at GS before. And GTA, well... In their podcast, IGN sounds pretty pissed about the SSE and I wouldn't be extremely shocked if it scored an 8.9 there.
IGN really disappointed me in their podcast. Saying stuff like "Olimir isn't the kind of character you use to win a game, he's more of a novelty". Because they have only clocked in maybe 30 minutes with him and you suck with him (big S said he would be very hard to master) doesn't mean the character sucks.
there are loads of games like gta on the market.
smash bros is one of the most unique games in the gaming industry. no other game is similar to it.
SSB has a much larger fanbase around the world and I would argue that if 90% of every Wii owner on the planet bought SSB (which will probably happen) it would outsell GTA worldwide. Its a toss up for the US alone though.Broc_Samson
umm... GTA games have sold way more than the SSB games. and SSBM had about a 1/3 attach rate not a 90% attach rate.
[QUOTE="Broc_Samson"]SSB has a much larger fanbase around the world and I would argue that if 90% of every Wii owner on the planet bought SSB (which will probably happen) it would outsell GTA worldwide. Its a toss up for the US alone though.laughingman42
umm... GTA games have sold way more than the SSB games. and SSBM had about a 1/3 attach rate not a 90% attach rate.
[QUOTE="laughingman42"][QUOTE="Broc_Samson"]SSB has a much larger fanbase around the world and I would argue that if 90% of every Wii owner on the planet bought SSB (which will probably happen) it would outsell GTA worldwide. Its a toss up for the US alone though.Broc_Samson
umm... GTA games have sold way more than the SSB games. and SSBM had about a 1/3 attach rate not a 90% attach rate.
That's possible, even probable, but a 90% attach rate is just ridiculous, not even Halo can do that.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment