SW Choice for Best NEW IP of the Gen - FINAL ROUND - voting now closed

I vote for Mass effect out of the final 3 out of this list. Batman would get runner up and I honestly never felt anything for portal.Even after beating 1 and playing some of 2.

[QUOTE="padaporra"]

[QUOTE="Another48hours"]Portal, I would have voted Mass Effect but they decided to ruin SP by maing you play MP to get certain things. So Valve will win as usual. How is Arkam Asylum a new Ip? Bad man games have been around forever.Another48hours

[QUOTE="Slashless"][QUOTE="kuraimen"]kuraimen

[QUOTE="mystic_knight"][QUOTE="kuraimen"] I did but I didn't know if people wanted it :P The count is pretty close, I didn't go back to recheck vote edits if there were any so it might not be completely accurate. [spoiler] ME - 45 Portal - 48 Batman - 13 [/spoiler] kuraimen

I don't think any of those 3 are the best ip....but I guess I'll go with: 1. Portal it seems like the most consistent..Some-Mist

That's because all three of them are boring games.

[QUOTE="Slashless"][QUOTE="kuraimen"]kuraimen

You seem to have 3 extra votes on Portal. I actually have a complete tie between Mass Effect and Portal. This bing before your post and not including the more recent posts that followed.

By chance did you count the votes of some users under level 10?

I still want an explanation on how Batman Arkham _____ is a new IP.

[QUOTE="kuraimen"][QUOTE="Slashless"] KURAIMEN Make yourself useful and do a vote count so far :xAdobeArtist

You seem to have 3 extra votes on Portal. I actually have a complete tie between Mass Effect and Portal. This bing before your post and not including the more recent posts that followed.

By chance did you count the votes of some users under level 10?

OK, and I just uploaded my spreadsheet for how I did the count. It even lists the page for each user entered (going by 20 ppp) and how many edits in their vote post. I'm sure I didn't miss anybody for either game.

** gamespot linking doesn't seem to work for a googledoc :x
Just copy and paste the URL to view. Also updated to the most recent vote by dr_jashugan

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Amk5NKiDaHO0dEtSSGFDZDd0WlllYWhQMjl0cHRwWnc#gid=3

Portal

...just doing my part :)

Mass Effect, BUT without DLC. :cool:

Portal 2 won best game at Bafta's today, so there you go add that as 10 votes for it.

Portal 2 won best game at Bafta's today, so there you go add that as 10 votes for it.

Swift_Boss_A

[QUOTE="Swift_Boss_A"]

Portal 2 won best game at Bafta's today, so there you go add that as 10 votes for it.

padaporra

[QUOTE="padaporra"]

[QUOTE="Swift_Boss_A"]

Portal 2 won best game at Bafta's today, so there you go add that as 10 votes for it.

themajormayor

I've had enough of your disingenuous assertions!! :P:P

[QUOTE="themajormayor"]

[QUOTE="padaporra"]
.
ME2 won last year, so 10 votes for it too!

AdobeArtist

I've had enough of your disingenuous assertions!! :P:P

I still want an explanation on how Batman Arkham _____ is a new IP.

Aljosa23

Portal.

[QUOTE="Aljosa23"]

I still want an explanation on how Batman Arkham _____ is a new IP.

FrozenLiquid

With this logic Super Mario Galaxy is a new IP.

I still want an explanation on how Batman Arkham _____ is a new IP.

Aljosa23

It's not. Which makes its inclusion dumb. But whatever, not my list.

[QUOTE="FrozenLiquid"][QUOTE="Aljosa23"]

I still want an explanation on how Batman Arkham _____ is a new IP.

Aljosa23

With this logic Super Mario Galaxy is a new IP.

[QUOTE="Aljosa23"]

[QUOTE="FrozenLiquid"] It's got certain gameplay functions exclusive to its series. While there's a huge umbrella IP (DC's Batman), there are things it does that no other Batman outing can lay claim to. It's the same situation for Christopher Nolan's new Batman trilogy.Cherokee_Jack

With this logic Super Mario Galaxy is a new IP.

Just because there hasn't been a Batman game like Arkham doesn't mean it's a new IP. The Batman IP was created by DC Comics over 70 years and the Arkham series is just a new set of games within that IP.

Of course I'm not sure why I expected System Wars to know anything about Law. Adobe won't even give me an answer to my question, lol.

[QUOTE="Aljosa23"]

[QUOTE="FrozenLiquid"] It's got certain gameplay functions exclusive to its series. While there's a huge umbrella IP (DC's Batman), there are things it does that no other Batman outing can lay claim to. It's the same situation for Christopher Nolan's new Batman trilogy.Cherokee_Jack

With this logic Super Mario Galaxy is a new IP.

Just because you like a game doesn't mean you get to change the definition of New Intellectual Property.

uncharted

Mass Effect

uncharted

Pikachu69er

I think I speak for everyone when I say, "shut up!"

[QUOTE="Cherokee_Jack"][QUOTE="Aljosa23"]But...that's still based off an old IP. It's just a new series of games. :P

With this logic Super Mario Galaxy is a new IP.

jechtshot78

Just because you like a game doesn't mean you get to change the definition of New Intellectual Property.

[QUOTE="kuraimen"][QUOTE="Slashless"] KURAIMEN Make yourself useful and do a vote count so far :xAdobeArtist

You seem to have 3 extra votes on Portal. I actually have a complete tie between Mass Effect and Portal. This bing before your post and not including the more recent posts that followed.

By chance did you count the votes of some users under level 10?

[QUOTE="Pikachu69er"]

uncharted

lundy86_4

I think I speak for everyone when I say, "shut up!"

You shut up. He has his opinion. A opinion shared by many on this board including myself......

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

[QUOTE="Pikachu69er"]

uncharted

Storm_Marine

I think I speak for everyone when I say, "shut up!"

You shut up. He has his opinion. A opinion shared by many on this board including myself......

You just upset that you have to see Kaz's perfect body every time Pikachu69er posts.

uncharted

Pikachu69er

This but since I'm late to this party I'll vote for Mass Effect.

I see gameplay is in third place :(. SW for shame!Sushiglutton

[QUOTE="Sushiglutton"]I see gameplay is in third place :(. SW for shame!themajormayor

What what what? :|

[QUOTE="themajormayor"][QUOTE="Sushiglutton"]I see gameplay is in third place :(. SW for shame!AdobeArtist

What what what? :|

actually i'll change it to portal since i hate mass effect

[QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

[QUOTE="themajormayor"] lol according to your sig and avy you shouldn't be talking about gameplaythemajormayor

What what what? :|

[QUOTE="themajormayor"][QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

What what what? :|

TheEroica

At least Uncharted's facial animation isn't embarrassing to see.

[QUOTE="themajormayor"][QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

What what what? :|

TheEroica

:lol::lol::lol::lol:

B*tch please! In Uncharted at least you have to AIM! In Assassin's Creed all you have to do is lock on and click one button! It's like a point and click game without the pointing lmao!

actually i'll change it to portal since i hate mass effect

Pikachu69er

[QUOTE="TheEroica"][QUOTE="themajormayor"] Assassin's creed and gameplay are mutually exclusive.Storm_Marine

At least Uncharted's facial animation isn't embarrassing to see.

[QUOTE="Sushiglutton"]I see gameplay is in third place :(. SW for shame!themajormayor

[QUOTE="TheEroica"][QUOTE="themajormayor"] Assassin's creed and gameplay are mutually exclusive.Storm_Marine

At least Uncharted's facial animation isn't embarrassing to see.

[QUOTE="TheEroica"][QUOTE="themajormayor"] Assassin's creed and gameplay are mutually exclusive.themajormayor

:lol::lol::lol::lol:

B*tch please! In Uncharted at least you have to AIM! In Assassin's Creed all you have to do is lock on and click one button! It's like a point and click game without the pointing lmao!

[QUOTE="themajormayor"][QUOTE="Sushiglutton"]I see gameplay is in third place :(. SW for shame!Sushiglutton

[QUOTE="Storm_Marine"]

[QUOTE="TheEroica"] Assassins creed has fantastic gameplay.... actually its one of the big reasons i always buy them... its not half assed like uncharted.Frostbite24

At least Uncharted's facial animation isn't embarrassing to see.

[QUOTE="themajormayor"]

[QUOTE="TheEroica"] Assassins creed has fantastic gameplay.... actually its one of the big reasons i always buy them... its not half assed like uncharted.TheEroica

:lol::lol::lol::lol:

B*tch please! In Uncharted at least you have to AIM! In Assassin's Creed all you have to do is lock on and click one button! It's like a point and click game without the pointing lmao!

Ok and can you now explain to my explain to my actual post?? Cause all I see now is "herpie derpie derp butthurt derpie herp". My point still stands, at least you AIM. In AC you do NOTHING. Uncharted is A, Portal is A+ and Mass Effect is C+(also really crappy gameplay, like a really clunky version of Uncharted). AC is F-. And don't compare with Gears lol. As you saw Uncharted slaughtered the sh't out of it. For one Gears is pretty much 2 dimensional(only moving on the X and Z axises) whereas Uncharted is 3 dimensional.