SYSTEM WARS VOTES: The Greatest RPG of This Generation (Final Tally)

Are we allowed to change votes?

I originally voted:

1. Tales of Vesperia

2. The Witcher 2

3. Mass Effect 3

But I can see there's no way in hell Mass Effect 3 is going to top all the love Mass Effect 1 and 2 are receiving despite being the better game.

I'd like to change my votes to:

1. Tales of Vesperia

2. The Witcher 2

3. Fallout: New Vegas

I've honestly played so many RPGs that I find it hard to vote for just three and many are interchangeable. I feel like ME3 deserves some love, but with the way the other two games are near the top, I feel like I'm wasting my vote on it when the first two games are so far ahead of it. Please change my #3 vote to Fallout: New Vegas.

NeonNinja

Are we allowed to change votes?

I originally voted:

1. Tales of Vesperia

2. The Witcher 2

3. Mass Effect 3

But I can see there's no way in hell Mass Effect 3 is going to top all the love Mass Effect 1 and 2 are receiving despite being the better game.

I'd like to change my votes to:

1. Tales of Vesperia

2. The Witcher 2

3. Fallout: New Vegas

I've honestly played so many RPGs that I find it hard to vote for just three and many are interchangeable. I feel like ME3 deserves some love, but with the way the other two games are near the top, I feel like I'm wasting my vote on it when the first two games are so far ahead of it. Please change my #3 vote to Fallout: New Vegas.

NeonNinja

Wrong, wrong, WRONG! You're supposed to change your ME3 vote to ME2, to keep that series at the top of the charts :x

Charizard, so if we do change our votes, you want us to make a new post (like Neon did) listing our changes? Not editing our original post with also showing our changes?

1. The Witcher 1

2. Dragon Age : Origins

3. Mass Effect 1

Depressing list of rpgs if you were around in the 'golden era'....

anab0lic

Couldn't agree more

[QUOTE="NeonNinja"]

Are we allowed to change votes?

I originally voted:

1. Tales of Vesperia

2. The Witcher 2

3. Mass Effect 3

But I can see there's no way in hell Mass Effect 3 is going to top all the love Mass Effect 1 and 2 are receiving despite being the better game.

I'd like to change my votes to:

1. Tales of Vesperia

2. The Witcher 2

3. Fallout: New Vegas

I've honestly played so many RPGs that I find it hard to vote for just three and many are interchangeable. I feel like ME3 deserves some love, but with the way the other two games are near the top, I feel like I'm wasting my vote on it when the first two games are so far ahead of it. Please change my #3 vote to Fallout: New Vegas.

AdobeArtist

Wrong, wrong, WRONG! You're supposed to change your ME3 vote to ME2, to keep that series at the top of the charts :x

Charizard, so if we do change our votes, you want us to make a new post (like Neon did) listing our changes? Not editing our original post with also showing our changes?

1 Xenoblade

2 Fallout 3

3 Demons Souls

Dunno why Mass Effect 2 is listed on there, it aint no rpg

There's still time to get your votes in. And give Charizard even more to count :P

1) Skyrim

2) Mass Effect 2

3) Fallout 3

Are we allowed to change votes?

I originally voted:

1. Tales of Vesperia

2. The Witcher 2

3. Mass Effect 3

But I can see there's no way in hell Mass Effect 3 is going to top all the love Mass Effect 1 and 2 are receiving despite being the better game.

I'd like to change my votes to:

1. Tales of Vesperia

2. The Witcher 2

3. Fallout: New Vegas

I've honestly played so many RPGs that I find it hard to vote for just three and many are interchangeable. I feel like ME3 deserves some love, but with the way the other two games are near the top, I feel like I'm wasting my vote on it when the first two games are so far ahead of it. Please change my #3 vote to Fallout: New Vegas.

NeonNinja

1. The Burning Crusade (Because I'm the only one here who likes MMOs apparently)

2. Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords

3. Mass Effect 2

I haven't played many RPGs this gen.

1. The Burning Crusade (Because I'm the only one here who likes MMOs apparently)

2. Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords

3. Mass Effect 2

I haven't played many RPGs this gen.

DarkLink77

I love that game too (belive that), but ONLY current gen games are eligible.

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

1. The Burning Crusade (Because I'm the only one here who likes MMOs apparently)

2. Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords

3. Mass Effect 2

I haven't played many RPGs this gen.

AdobeArtist

I love that game too (belive that), but ONLY current gen games are eligible.

It is current gen on PC. February 8th, 2005.

Also, I thought for sure you were gonna flip when I listed ME2 as an RPG. :P

[QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

1. The Burning Crusade (Because I'm the only one here who likes MMOs apparently)

2. Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords

3. Mass Effect 2

I haven't played many RPGs this gen.

DarkLink77

I love that game too (belive that), but ONLY current gen games are eligible.

It is current gen on PC. February 8th, 2005.

Also, I thought for sure you were gonna flip when I listed ME2 as an RPG. :P

well aaaaaaaaaalrighty then :)

Oh and not flippin, but rather proud of you son ;)

1. The Burning Crusade (Because I'm the only one here who likes MMOs apparently)

DarkLink77

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

[QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

I love that game too (belive that), but ONLY current gen games are eligible.

AdobeArtist

It is current gen on PC. February 8th, 2005.

Also, I thought for sure you were gonna flip when I listed ME2 as an RPG. :P

well aaaaaaaaaalrighty then :)

Oh and not flippin, but rather proud of you son ;)

[QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

It is current gen on PC. February 8th, 2005.

Also, I thought for sure you were gonna flip when I listed ME2 as an RPG. :P

DarkLink77

well aaaaaaaaaalrighty then :)

Oh and not flippin, but rather proud of you son ;)

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"][QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

well aaaaaaaaaalrighty then :)

Oh and not flippin, but rather proud of you son ;)

BrunoBRS

1. Fallout 3

2. Skyrim

3. Demon's Souls

Stop voting for New Vegas, it's such an awful game.

1. Mass Effect (first one)

2. Dragon Age: Origins

3. Alpha Protocol

1. The Witcher 2

2. Fallout: New Vegas

3. World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King (come at me hardcore brethern)

1. Mass Effect

2. Dragon Age Origins

3. Skyrim

The Witcher 2 Enhanced Ed (PC)

Demon Souls Prepare to Die Ed (PC)

Valkyria Chronicles (PS3)

Stop voting for New Vegas and games that I don't like.

StealthMonkey4

Fix'd.

World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King (come at me hardcore brethern)

ChubbyGuy40

I am so disappointed in you.

Disgaea 4

Disgaea 3

Pokemon black/while

(The world ends with you as honorable mention on place 4 and Resonance of Fate on place 5)

Disgaea 4

Disgaea 3

Pokemon black/while

(The world ends with you as honorable mention on place 4 and Resonance of Fate on place 5)

ArchoNils2

Can't be two games from the same series.

Stop voting for New Vegas, it's such an awful game.

StealthMonkey4

I am so disappointed in you.

DarkLink77

I would say vanilla WoW, but that was before this gen. I would say TBC, except it has the worst quests of any expansion. I would say Cataclysm, but the 81-85 content sucked and it went forever without any new content. I would say MoP, but it hasn't run it's course yet. Still things to do and stuff unreleased.

WOTLK had the quests, the end game (and anyone saying it was too easy played after nerfs or only played the casual content,) and the pvp. I know WoW's story is considered sh*t, but the Arthas/Lich King storyline and ending were amazing. Such a shame it didn't play out how Blizzard originally planned it with the 7 chapters though.

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

I am so disappointed in you.

ChubbyGuy40

I would say vanilla WoW, but that was before this gen. I would say TBC, except it has the worst quests of any expansion. I would say Cataclysm, but the 81-85 content sucked and it went forever without any new content. I would say MoP, but it hasn't run it's course yet. Still things to do and stuff unreleased.

WOTLK had the quests, the end game (and anyone saying it was too easy played after nerfs or only played the casual content,) and the pvp. I know WoW's story is considered sh*t, but the Arthas/Lich King storyline and ending were amazing. Such a shame it didn't play out how Blizzard originally planned it with the 7 chapters though.

1. Guild Wars 2

2. Torchlight 2

3. The Witcher

Why is Mass Effect considered an RPG? I thought it is an Action (third person shooter) game. :shock:

1. Guild Wars 2

2. Torchlight 2

3. The Witcher

Why is Mass Effect considered an RPG? I thought it is an Action (third person shooter) game. :shock:

dr_jashugan

Did he just start this up? With ME around? Did he? DID HE??? :x

TBC has the worst quests out of any expansion? Get out of here. Wrath's was a lot better, but TBC is the worst? Please. And :lol: at Wrath having "the endgame." Wrath had an endgame for babbies. It was a step down in every way. The only endgame that's ever been worse is Cataclysms, and that's only because of a lack of content.DarkLink77

The only ones worse than TBC would've been in vanilla, but even vanilla at least had some really awesome questlines. Sadly some of those no longer exist cause Cataclysm. Got my druid to Outland yesterday and remembered why I hated it. There's far, far too much backtracking and the drop rates are still crap. I hated it back then, and I hate it even more now.

Having 10 and 25 versions was definitely a better choice, though having different loot wasn't. Rather run ez-mode new raids than be stuck in 10-man only raids or run Karazhan for the 200th time because a few core members didn't make it. Wrath had baby endgame, and it also had endgame for the hardcore. Sadly, many don't remember that because they assumed normal mode was everything. Agreed that Cataclysm had the worst, but at least it had a few great heroic fights. Still doesn't make up for all the bad it did.

Did he just start this up? With ME around? Did he? DID HE??? :x

AdobeArtist

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]TBC has the worst quests out of any expansion? Get out of here. Wrath's was a lot better, but TBC is the worst? Please. And :lol: at Wrath having "the endgame." Wrath had an endgame for babbies. It was a step down in every way. The only endgame that's ever been worse is Cataclysms, and that's only because of a lack of content.ChubbyGuy40

The only ones worse than TBC would've been in vanilla, but even vanilla at least had some really awesome questlines. Sadly some of those no longer exist cause Cataclysm. Got my druid to Outland yesterday and remembered why I hated it. There's far, far too much backtracking and the drop rates are still crap. I hated it back then, and I hate it even more now.

Having 10 and 25 versions was definitely a better choice, though having different loot wasn't. Rather run ez-mode new raids than be stuck in 10-man only raids or run Karazhan for the 200th time because a few core members didn't make it. Wrath had baby endgame, and it also had endgame for the hardcore. Sadly, many don't remember that because they assumed normal mode was everything. Agreed that Cataclysm had the worst, but at least it had a few great heroic fights. Still doesn't make up for all the bad it did.

[QUOTE="dr_jashugan"]

1. Guild Wars 2

2. Torchlight 2

3. The Witcher

Why is Mass Effect considered an RPG? I thought it is an Action (third person shooter) game. :shock:

AdobeArtist

Did he just start this up? With ME around? Did he? DID HE??? :x

The Witcher 2 Enhanced Ed (PC)

Demon Souls Prepare to Die Ed (PC)

Valkyria Chronicles (PS3)

lpjazzman220

1. Mother 3

2. Dark Souls

3. The Witcher 2

If only Bloodlines had come out two months later.

[QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

[QUOTE="dr_jashugan"]

1. Guild Wars 2

2. Torchlight 2

3. The Witcher

Why is Mass Effect considered an RPG? I thought it is an Action (third person shooter) game. :shock:

BrunoBRS

Did he just start this up? With ME around? Did he? DID HE??? :x

Well...what IS an RPG, then?