This topic is locked from further discussion.
i hope not. that movie suckedonebeelothe book doesn't..........it is one of the most critically accliamed novels last decade.
Similar in concept, not at all in execution.meetroid8http://www.gamesradar.com/last-us-preview-survival-gets-real/ "But Ellie isnt just a foil for the player, or an easy way to deliver story. Ellies lack of knowledge also helps reinforce her innocence and perhaps even hope. Meanwhile, Joel clearly knows how to survive, reminding Ellie to scavenge around for anything they can use, and knowing when theyre in danger." Sounds like a ripoff.........seriously the characters in the Road represents the same thing.
[QUOTE="meetroid8"]Similar in concept, not at all in execution.texasgoldrushhttp://www.gamesradar.com/last-us-preview-survival-gets-real/ "But Ellie isnt just a foil for the player, or an easy way to deliver story. Ellies lack of knowledge also helps reinforce her innocence and perhaps even hope. Meanwhile, Joel clearly knows how to survive, reminding Ellie to scavenge around for anything they can use, and knowing when theyre in danger." Sounds like a ripoff.........seriously the characters in the Road represents the same thing. You appear to have an extremely narrow scope of fictional knowledge if you think The Road is the first piece of fiction to use that as a literary device. Granted I have past knowledge of your posts so I can say with certainty that I'm correct.
You appear to have an extremely narrow scope of fictional knowledge if you think The Road is the first piece of fiction to use that as a literary device. Granted I have past knowledge of your posts so I can say with certainty that I'm correct.Ace6301
Also this.
[QUOTE="texasgoldrush"][QUOTE="meetroid8"]Similar in concept, not at all in execution.Ace6301http://www.gamesradar.com/last-us-preview-survival-gets-real/ "But Ellie isnt just a foil for the player, or an easy way to deliver story. Ellies lack of knowledge also helps reinforce her innocence and perhaps even hope. Meanwhile, Joel clearly knows how to survive, reminding Ellie to scavenge around for anything they can use, and knowing when theyre in danger." Sounds like a ripoff.........seriously the characters in the Road represents the same thing. You appear to have an extremely narrow scope of fictional knowledge if you think The Road is the first piece of fiction to use that as a literary device. Granted I have past knowledge of your posts so I can say with certainty that I'm correct. However the way the literary device is used and the way the novel was written, its pretty original. More original than what the Last of Us is doing.
This game reminded me a lot of The Road, which has me very excited because ever since I read that book I was hoping for a video game to take on such a jounrney.
i've seen the film and am currently reading through the novel again, you are completely wrong. the road portrays its narrative through despondency and the most bare bonesdialogue i've ever read, there isn't even quotations to go along with the dialogue in the novel, serving to detach the reader from the characters and embed them in unity with the world around them. In ND's game, the characters are their own entities with presumably distinct attitudes and emotions.
The road had maybe one or two legitimate action scenes and took a whole different approach to the end-world aesthetic. The Last of Us seems to focus more on the action and character interaction.
The Road refer ed to the two protagonists as The Man and The Boy, that is how minimal the novel's approach to enhancing and developing its characters. The Road is a beautiful novel, but certainly not for everyone; a "presumed" video game adaption in the form of ND's new game, as you suggest, is completely ludicrous.
Stop looking for ways of bashing this game, or at least don't try to bring a venerable novel to this fanboy nonsense.
Wrong If you think that the man and the boy aren't their own entities you are completely wrong. Yes, the format of the novel and how it was wirtten is unique, but the characters are still there. And the game doesn't have to use the same naming convention...the same relationship is there. While they are not related, the parent-chiold bond and what the characters represent is still there. Face facts here, they took a bunch of elements from The Road. Its undeniable.i've seen the film and am currently reading through the novel again, you are completely wrong. the road portrays its narrative through despondency and the most bare bonesdialogue i've ever read, there isn't even quotations to go along with the dialogue in the novel, serving to detach the reader from the characters and embed them in unity with the world around them. In ND's game, the characters are their own entities with presumably distinct attitudes and emotions.
The road had maybe one or two legitimate action scenes and took a whole different approach to the end-world aesthetic. The Last of Us seems to focus more on the action and character interaction.
The Road refer ed to the two protagonists as The Man and The Boy, that is how minimal the novel's approach to enhancing and developing its characters. The Road is a beautiful novel, but certainly not for everyone, a "presumed" video game adaption in the form of ND's new game, as you suggest, is completely ludicrous.
Stop looking for ways of bashing this game, or at least don't try to bring a venerable novel to this fanboy nonsense.
Dead-Memories
The aesthetics and visuals are completely different. The Road was bleak compared to how much colour is in this game. biggest_loserstill post apocolyptic. Not much different. Also the title.
Notice I said nearly in my topic title....but from the looks of it, the core, the bond and the themes, of The Road and this game are way too similiar.So despite it being a complete ripoff, you still have to list the differences? What now?
Lionheart08
[QUOTE="Dead-Memories"]Wrong If you think that the man and the boy aren't their own entities you are completely wrong. Yes, the format of the novel and how it was wirtten is unique, but the characters are still there. And the game doesn't have to use the same naming convention...the same relationship is there. While they are not related, the parent-chiold bond and what the characters represent is still there. Face facts here, they took a bunch of elements from The Road. Its undeniable.i've seen the film and am currently reading through the novel again, you are completely wrong. the road portrays its narrative through despondency and the most bare bonesdialogue i've ever read, there isn't even quotations to go along with the dialogue in the novel, serving to detach the reader from the characters and embed them in unity with the world around them. In ND's game, the characters are their own entities with presumably distinct attitudes and emotions.
The road had maybe one or two legitimate action scenes and took a whole different approach to the end-world aesthetic. The Last of Us seems to focus more on the action and character interaction.
The Road refer ed to the two protagonists as The Man and The Boy, that is how minimal the novel's approach to enhancing and developing its characters. The Road is a beautiful novel, but certainly not for everyone, a "presumed" video game adaption in the form of ND's new game, as you suggest, is completely ludicrous.
Stop looking for ways of bashing this game, or at least don't try to bring a venerable novel to this fanboy nonsense.
texasgoldrush
Legitimate question. Do you have brain damage?
Wrong If you think that the man and the boy aren't their own entities you are completely wrong. Yes, the format of the novel and how it was wirtten is unique, but the characters are still there. And the game doesn't have to use the same naming convention...the same relationship is there. While they are not related, the parent-chiold bond and what the characters represent is still there. Face facts here, they took a bunch of elements from The Road. Its undeniable.[QUOTE="texasgoldrush"][QUOTE="Dead-Memories"]
i've seen the film and am currently reading through the novel again, you are completely wrong. the road portrays its narrative through despondency and the most bare bonesdialogue i've ever read, there isn't even quotations to go along with the dialogue in the novel, serving to detach the reader from the characters and embed them in unity with the world around them. In ND's game, the characters are their own entities with presumably distinct attitudes and emotions.
The road had maybe one or two legitimate action scenes and took a whole different approach to the end-world aesthetic. The Last of Us seems to focus more on the action and character interaction.
The Road refer ed to the two protagonists as The Man and The Boy, that is how minimal the novel's approach to enhancing and developing its characters. The Road is a beautiful novel, but certainly not for everyone, a "presumed" video game adaption in the form of ND's new game, as you suggest, is completely ludicrous.
Stop looking for ways of bashing this game, or at least don't try to bring a venerable novel to this fanboy nonsense.
SRTtoZ
Legitimate question. Do you have brain damage?
Are you an idiot?[QUOTE="SRTtoZ"][QUOTE="texasgoldrush"] Wrong If you think that the man and the boy aren't their own entities you are completely wrong. Yes, the format of the novel and how it was wirtten is unique, but the characters are still there. And the game doesn't have to use the same naming convention...the same relationship is there. While they are not related, the parent-chiold bond and what the characters represent is still there. Face facts here, they took a bunch of elements from The Road. Its undeniable.texasgoldrush
Legitimate question. Do you have brain damage?
Are you an idiot?Question answered.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment