There is Nothing in Uncharted 3 that can't be done on a 360

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwywuVzrJTg&feature=player_embedded#at=70

The only thing that is amazing is the lighting model. Everything else can easily be done on a 360, Stop over hyping this game. Its as bad as the PC elites thinking the Witcher 2 can not look good on Consoles.

Opps the Witcher 2 looks fine on the 360 so far.

360 would hiccup.

it would probably need a 4th disc for the MP portion.;)

It can be done, but you'd need 2-3 discs just to play a 10 hour game. Thanks to the 360's horrible storage medium.

Didnt Naughty Dog say themselves it cant be done? Literally not figuratively. So you're saying we should take some random gamespot posters word over the developers themselves?

Hmm...

Could be done just look at BF, Rage, Crysis 2 , TW2, Gears, Forza, ME3 etc.......But it won't be done

its PS3 exclusive. Can't wait for UC3 game.

TW2 actually looks far worse on 360 than PC, if you take a look at any PC screen you can see the massive drop in quality, Also UC3 on 360 will never happen.

The Witcher 2 looks quite a bit worse on 360 actually.

I thought all major exclusives couldn't be done on the opposing console. Since there's such a huge variation in power and all. Can you imagine if they were powered relatively the same? Most games would be multiplats, that looked the same on both consoles!UCF_Knight

What a crazy world that would be.

Didnt Naughty Dog say themselves it cant be done? Literally not figuratively. So you're saying we should take some random gamespot posters word over the developers themselves?

Hmm...

SRTtoZ

Yea okay ....remember when Ubisoft said conviction couldn't be done on PS3 only on 360. Was that true no.

http://www.joystiq.com/2007/05/07/ubisoft-says-conviction-cant-be-done-on-ps3/

TW2 actually looks far worse on 360 than PC, if you take a look at any PC screen you can see the massive drop in quality, Also UC3 on 360 will never happen.

NanoMan88

except for being a Sony Exclusive.

360 would hiccup.

it would probably need a 4th disc for the MP portion.;)

It can be done, but you'd need 2-3 discs just to play a 10 hour game. Thanks to the 360's horrible storage medium.

rasengan2552

The Witcher 2 looks quite a bit worse on 360 actually.

NaveedLife

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"]

360 would hiccup.

it would probably need a 4th disc for the MP portion.;)

It can be done, but you'd need 2-3 discs just to play a 10 hour game. Thanks to the 360's horrible storage medium.

AugustusGraham

Which Uncharted 3 can also do.

Also about the DVD.....Gears of War isn't even Gold yet, The Game may end up being 2 discs you know.

Yes it can be done.

Remember when having 16 cars on track in GT5 with super detailed cars was only possible on the PS3 due to the Cell?

Amazing how it's suddenly in Forza 4... WITH the extremely detailed environments.

Many at system wars will eventually realise that both of these consoles are close in power.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

The Witcher 2 looks quite a bit worse on 360 actually.

khoofia_pika

Of course it would look worse on the PS3 as well. But to act like The Witcher 2 looks nearly as good as the PC version, or even that it beats Uncharted 3, is rediculous.

[QUOTE="rasengan2552"]

360 would hiccup.

it would probably need a 4th disc for the MP portion.;)

It can be done, but you'd need 2-3 discs just to play a 10 hour game. Thanks to the 360's horrible storage medium.

AugustusGraham

Could be but wont. This argument is pointless.

Only what will be done is relevent, and MS have no reason to invest in quality titles.

Which is sad for Xbox only owners waiting for quality exclusives. It's a mark of their incompetence that they need Third Party assistance toshow of their consoles power. If it werent for EPIC the Xbox would be dead in the water.

Nobody thinks that the PS3 is leaps and bounds more powerful then the 360. But the CPU for the PS3 is a little more advanced. If you have a game like uncharted 3 which is made specifically for PS3 and uses a lot of techniques that specifically utalize the cell and/or bluray then no, it's not outside the relem of possibility that it couldn't be done on 360. At least not in the form it is now. It's not a diss to the 360 it siply that for all their similarities there are differences between them and some games take advatage of those differences more then others, particularly exclusives.

Nobody thinks that the PS3 is leaps and bounds more powerful then the 360. But the CPU for the PS3 is a little more advanced. If you have a game like uncharted 3 which is made specifically for PS3 and uses a lot of techniques that specifically utalize the cell and/or bluray then no, it's not outside the relem of possibility that it couldn't be done on 360. At least not in the form it is now. It's not a diss to the 360 it siply that for all their similarities there are differences between them and some games take advatage of those differences more then others, particularly exclusives.

Pray_to_me

PS3 has a better CPU

360 has a better GPU

don't get mad at naughty dog and ps3 fans because microsoft failed e3 2011.

don't get mad at naughty dog and ps3 fans because microsoft failed e3 2011.

dipsetboy17

What makes you think he's mad at Naughty Dog or cows?

[QUOTE="dipsetboy17"]

don't get mad at naughty dog and ps3 fans because microsoft failed e3 2011.

waltefmoney

What makes you think he's mad at Naughty Dog or cows?

[QUOTE="dipsetboy17"]

don't get mad at naughty dog and ps3 fans because microsoft failed e3 2011.

waltefmoney

What makes you think he's mad at Naughty Dog or cows?

And what does MS losing E3 have to do with the topic of this thread.

he must be mad or envious of something then.dipsetboy17

What makes you think he is?

Obviously and the same could be said about Gears 3. Both consoles are technically even.

Are any of you programers? No? Well I'm sure Naughty Dog knows what they're talking about. The things that happen in UC can't be done on the 360. The way a level is strung together without a break hasn't been done before to my knowledge. You can given your opinions, but unless you know what you're talking about your opinion is still just an opinion.

Could it be done in its current form? Probably not. However, that doesn't mean that it can't be done at all. You can do some things on the PS3 you can't do on the 360, and vice versa. If it could be done on the 360, I'd expect to notice several differences.

Are any of you programers? No? Well I'm sure Naughty Dog knows what they're talking about. The things that happen in UC can't be done on the 360. The way a level is strung together without a break hasn't been done before to my knowledge. You can given your opinions, but unless you know what you're talking about your opinion is still just an opinion.

lowkey254

Yea okay ....remember when Ubisoft said conviction couldn't be done on PS3 only on 360. Was that true no. Devs always say this its just propaganda pushed by who ever pays the devs.

http://www.joystiq.com/2007/05/07/ubisoft-says-conviction-cant-be-done-on-ps3/

Obviously and the same could be said about Gears 3. Both consoles are technically even.

PAL360

Best things about UC3(water and fire) could be quite easily made on 360.UC3 water looks brilliant,but thats not because of power of a cell,its because their artists nailed rigging of it and animations(similar to how R* made horses muscle look so good when moving).Fire would be there without trouble since its high on bandwidth,its alpha effect and PS3 generally has harder time with those(lots of fire,smoke and grass).

Other than that those faces from trailer were pre rendered with better skin shading,shadowing and lighting(DF just confirmed it).UC3 is the best looking game on consoles IMO after seeing SP footage.MP...not so much.

360 would hiccup.

it would probably need a 4th disc for the MP portion.;)

It can be done, but you'd need 2-3 discs just to play a 10 hour game. Thanks to the 360's horrible storage medium.

rasengan2552

Are any of you programers? No? Well I'm sure Naughty Dog knows what they're talking about. The things that happen in UC can't be done on the 360. The way a level is strung together without a break hasn't been done before to my knowledge. You can given your opinions, but unless you know what you're talking about your opinion is still just an opinion.

lowkey254

Yes, let´s pretend games like Crysis 2, Forza 4 and Gears 3 dont exist.....

[QUOTE="dipsetboy17"]he must be mad or envious of something then.waltefmoney

What makes you think he is?

What makes you think what walt said was serious?