How could they give it a 9.3 when they said the game is flawless and has the best graphics ever well that knocks crysis out. lol
fortunehunter55
They didn't say any of that :?
This topic is locked from further discussion.
How could they give it a 9.3 when they said the game is flawless and has the best graphics ever well that knocks crysis out. lol
fortunehunter55
They didn't say any of that :?
And for all you people thinking uncharted 2 is failing i guess you havent seen the N4G 64 reviews and has a score of 9.6 showme a handful of games that have a 9.6 after 64 reviews. No matter what people say Uncharted 2 is still up there with the greates games ever made atleast the score is. lol
just be happy they don't give it a low score and laugh at your face. at least now they try to not be as biased. maybe another year when there are more ps3 players than xbox in the us.kaparsaparIf they gave it a low score, they'd lose all credibility. Giving it a 9.3--a score just below Gears--is a "safe" score for them to give so they can have their cake and eat it too.
And for all you people thinking uncharted 2 is failing i guess you havent seen the N4G 64 reviews and has a score of 9.6 showme a handful of games that have a 9.6 after 64 reviews. No matter what people say Uncharted 2 is still up there with the greates games ever made atleast the score is. lol
fortunehunter55
I really don't think theres anyone out there saying this game is failing. Its more people just laughing at the fact that there are actually people complaining about the fact that it only scored a 9.3 and acting as if thats a horrible score when its not.
[QUOTE="789shadow"]Probably 9.5 or 10 here, GS likes good presentation over gameplay. U2 delivers on the presentation department even if the story is not original. most reviews tell us about an outstanding gameplay and a very charismatic story :?With the big hype train coming, I would die if it got an 8.5 here.:lol:
themyth01
Just watched the review. I know I have been a bit nitpicky about graphics kings in that they have to be out first, but I guess by now every single critic would agree that its the best looking console game ever.
And after all those footages in the review, I think I'll seriously stop watching any more SP videos till its release. Man this game is going to be epic.
[QUOTE="themyth01"][QUOTE="789shadow"]Probably 9.5 or 10 here, GS likes good presentation over gameplay. U2 delivers on the presentation department even if the story is not original. most reviews tell us about an outstanding gameplay and a very charismatic story :? Charismatic != original. Extremely linear gameplay, average AI and basically the same shooting mechanics as the first game could be considered good, while others may expect more.With the big hype train coming, I would die if it got an 8.5 here.:lol:
Giancar
GT review it self mention almost no flaws in the game... or no flaws at all
9.3 Is a great score but according to the review it should have gotten more thats why i said what i said
[QUOTE="Giancar"][QUOTE="themyth01"] Probably 9.5 or 10 here, GS likes good presentation over gameplay. U2 delivers on the presentation department even if the story is not original. themyth01most reviews tell us about an outstanding gameplay and a very charismatic story :? Charismatic != original. Extremely linear gameplay, average AI and basically the same shooting mechanics as the first game could be considered good, while others may expect more. extreamly linear? dont over due it, they never said that, no1 ever said that. U2 is as linear as gears. and about the average AI....halo 3 got a 9.8 there. halo 3's AI....they never mentione anything about its AI....halo has TERRIBLE AI but they didnt feel the need to mention it...
I hate how they keep on saying it has no originality. I bet if naughty dog made an FPS where you had guns, they'd say it borrowed the concept of using guns in an FPS :roll:munu9
The sad thing is I bet they would call gears an orginal game which is complete 100% BS.
Charismatic != original. Extremely linear gameplay, average AI and basically the same shooting mechanics as the first game could be considered good, while others may expect more. extreamly linear? dont over due it, they never said that, no1 ever said that. U2 is as linear as gears. and about the average AI....halo 3 got a 9.8 there. halo 3's AI....they never mentione anything about its AI....halo has TERRIBLE AI but they didnt feel the need to mention it...[QUOTE="themyth01"][QUOTE="Giancar"] most reviews tell us about an outstanding gameplay and a very charismatic story :?Revolution316
Once again, Halo 3 is Overrated. If you want Unchated 2 to join those ranks, then go ahead.
Charismatic != original. Extremely linear gameplay, average AI and basically the same shooting mechanics as the first game could be considered good, while others may expect more. extreamly linear? dont over due it, they never said that, no1 ever said that. U2 is as linear as gears. and about the average AI....halo 3 got a 9.8 there. halo 3's AI....they never mentione anything about its AI....halo has TERRIBLE AI but they didnt feel the need to mention it... The guy was walking next to the AI who somehow failed to notice Drake being there, average was going easy judging from that scene, even Assassins' Creed looks good in comparison. How exactly does Halo have terrible AI? because if Halo has been praised for one thing it has being the excellent AI that comes along with each build. Watch the video again you obviously missed when they do mention AI and show video to prove it.[QUOTE="themyth01"][QUOTE="Giancar"] most reviews tell us about an outstanding gameplay and a very charismatic story :?Revolution316
"It isn't very original, but it's basically a capsule of the last 10 years of game development buffed to a fine sheen." Gametrailers makes it sound like its the best game ever but yet dont give it the score it deserves kind of fishy here.
[QUOTE="Revolution316"]extreamly linear? dont over due it, they never said that, no1 ever said that. U2 is as linear as gears. and about the average AI....halo 3 got a 9.8 there. halo 3's AI....they never mentione anything about its AI....halo has TERRIBLE AI but they didnt feel the need to mention it... The guy was walking next to the AI who somehow failed to notice Drake being there, average was going easy judging from that scene, even Assassins' Creed looks good in comparison. How exactly does Halo have terrible AI? because if Halo has been praised for one thing it has being the excellent AI that comes along with each build. Watch the video again you obviously missed when they do mention AI and show video to prove it. hmm never happend to me in co op. i guess its a once in a life time thing. loll yup that rite thers should cause the score to go lower[QUOTE="themyth01"] Charismatic != original. Extremely linear gameplay, average AI and basically the same shooting mechanics as the first game could be considered good, while others may expect more. themyth01
The great AI:is he not sleeping tho? :P....this just shows that nathan drake is as good as snakethemyth01
why do people say dumb no brain nonsence. every game takes from another. blaz blue uses fireball motions must be copying street fighter.
The review had so much spoilers :/ Wow, they basically say the presentation is perfect, then go and give it a 9.8 instead of a 10 or even 9.9 :/... Not a big deal but still, then what deserves the other 2?Roushrshwho cares about the numbers. It is that they completely did a stupid review in the same way as B&K nuts and bolts. It is just one of those wtf reviews where they destroy a game based on a silly fanboy perspective of the world. Originiality in gameplay for an action adventure is as bad as it gets in terms of reviews. Thinking of B&K nuts and bolts review when they gave it a 6.7 over how it is different to the 2 older B&K games is the other horrible horrible review. Easily one of their most BS reviews I've seen. Just another one of those sigh moments though. I wish I would review games. Wouldn't have any of that Fanboy bs in any review (lacks originality, and then for another game too innovative doesn't play similar to the old games). It is as if they have an agenda against some games. MW2 will easily not get called that.
Talk for yourself Uncharted 2 is scoring higher then almost any 360 game out there in total reviews.
First off, awesome score, did not watch the review, and am going to stop reading in case someone spoils something, but awesome score is awesome, can't wait for this.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment