Uncharted Collection Digital Foundry Analysis

Looks like they did a good job with it overall. Too bad for no MP though. Skipping this one though, as I've already played all three.

Same. No MP, no money from me. I have them all on PS3, and will spend my available game money on Halo, Rise of TR and Fallout 4

@cainetao11: Good choice, my friend. I will also get Halo 5 and Tomb Raider. I'd love to get Fallout too I can't take all those freebies for myself. Plus I'm buying Guardians with my own cash.

Gonna buy this awesome trilogy since I don't have a PS3 anymore.

Definitely picking this up. Having no MP is lazy, but I'm not bothered by it.

Seems like the controls have been improved which is great, thats what kept me away from the games previously. Will probably pick it up.

Definitely a worthy pick up as they are leaps and bounds over their PS3 counterparts. It's a no brainer. Based Bluepoint.

I might look into it once I get a PS4, the clunky controls were what ruined Uncharted for me back on the PS3 tbh(although admittedly I never tried the 3rd one.)

Yeah no thanks

Why not just backwards compatibility for the loyal fans?

They made a top 5 GOAT even better. Incredible.

I still own my PS3 copies I'll pick the collection up when it's cheap enough.

Looks nice but I was gonna buy this at first but I already all the PS3 versions so this isn't on my radar. Sure it has the Beta for Uncharted 4 but I don't wanna be spoiled what awaits for me in UC4 and the fact this cost $60 for a last-gen port is a rip-off, not to mention no MP. That said, this collection was meant to be for those who never own a PS3 and went PS4 this gen should pick this up. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves is arguably the best in it's series. I don't know about you, but Sony could at least put the Vita Uncharted in it as well form that price there asking.

I dont care about MP so anyways the question to me is if i want buy it at all, i mean i already got the games on Ps3

That is a massive improvement for Drake's fortune.

Already have the games on PS3, so pass.

Drake's Fortune did release back on PS3 November 2007 which is one year past when PS3 first arrive but now in 2015, Drake's Fortune is 8 years old so yeah, this is indeed a massive improvements. It does shows these game age well and the same for Gears of War: Ultimate Edition.

Because then they could play the games for free instead of shelling out another $60.

And so Sony can charge there fans with PS Now BC fees.

Doesn't look like they did a whole lot and I've got to say that these games while not even that old didn't age well at all. Sure the resolution and framerate can go a long way but beyond that the changes or actual work put into these games looks pretty minimal, mostly just unpacked textures and increased draw distance. I'll wait to get this one when it's second hand or very cheap, I'm just not seeing the point or value here, especially since the multiplayer was so lazily gutted.

This seems to be a recurring trend with Sony's remasters, the work done doesn't justify the price or even the existence.

Awesome, can't wait, gonna be excellent.

If I hadn't played them all to death, I would get it. Looks like they did a great job on the remakes.

This from the dude who try to pass Halo 5 as a good looking game...lol

Already played them all, will get them when they are cheap.

@tormentos: It is a good looking game, dude.

I see the PS4 struggles with frames while even running an old engine. Still cows celebrate.

If this was a Xbox exclusive dipping to 55 FPS there would be 5 hate threads.

Uhuh...

To people with low standards probably,it has a solid performance.

Loyal fans would have kept their PS3's and they're more likely to buy UC4 anyway. Also, loyal fans are the one's who provided feedback for the improvements in this remaster.

They redid the lighting, controls, textures and got it to run at 1080p/60fps. For 3 games. They even redid the prerendered stuff. They did way more than others do in terms of the game engines.

Never thought I'd see you use bullshots....

Hahahaha

I'll probably end up getting this just before U4 when its dropped in price

Yeah and I saw Drake's Fortune was a huge improvements since considering the game is almost 8 years old. Like you said, this collection is optional for those who want it or not but if you still own your PS3, you really don't need it unless you want to play UC4 beta that is. Granted, I already play these games and I'll just wait for UC4.

Well by your logic, then this collection must be looking very bad.

No multiplayer is a no buy for me and seems like nothing is improved beside the res and framerates that still dip, not much but still for small firefights andsome water on screen it should not be allowed.

People can buy the original 3 for a total price of 25 bucks WITH multiplayer. Oh well atleast it's better then GOW3 "HD" on the PS4.

@nyadc said:

@tormentos said:

@nyadc said:

Doesn't look like they did a whole lot and I've got to say that these games while not even that old didn't age well at all. Sure the resolution and framerate can go a long way but beyond that the changes or actual work put into these games looks pretty minimal, mostly just unpacked textures and increased draw distance. I'll wait to get this one when it's second hand or very cheap, I'm just not seeing the point or value here, especially since the multiplayer was so lazily gutted.

This seems to be a recurring trend with Sony's remasters, the work done doesn't justify the price or even the existence.

This from the dude who try to pass Halo 5 as a good looking game...lol

Uhuh...

dont post bull shots...halo 5 looks good tho

Same here. Looks like a nice improvement over the older versions too.

the lack of MP is seriously inexcusable and would be a definite deal breaker for me if it wasnt for the fact that i completely missed UC2 and UC3 last gen.

For those of you who are bitching about the lack of no MP, the first Uncharted didn't have it and yet, it was a really good game in it's own right. Uncharted 2/3 to me was just a tack-on MP that I feel it didn't need it. I played both MP and I got bored with it in 2 weeks and really, not all games needs MP, this is one of them. That said, all 3 single player are really good, it didn't need MP from the gek-go in my opinion so don't let this collection get you down because MP isn't included but remember that there will be a Beta for Uncharted 4 so that's something worth it. That said, Uncharted games has alway have great single player and that's something to appreciate, not MP.

Day one. I might actually enjoy platting them this time thanks to the removal of the crappy mp.(which I boosted anyway)

I loved Uncharted 2 multiplayer, and enjoyed 3 as well for a bit, but yeah there's no reason to include multiplayer for this collection which would probably have poor netcode like the MCC, and would take away from polishing the single player experience.

Online multiplayer games are destined to go offline people.

@nyadc said:

Uhuh...

So Halo 5 is a 3rd person shooter now...Nice...

So much bullshit it hurts...lol

Oh but i haven't say it is a great looking collection hell i haven't even say a most have or even get it cheap.

Problem with that argument is that Uncharted was never really known for its multiplayer it was OK but nothing out of this world and certainly not Halo.

Yeah that is the same thing i say about MCC on xbox one and all were working on xbox 360 unlike MCC for several months.

so they basically crapped out a last gen port at 60fps like they did with TLOU? For such a hyped developer ND sure is really fucking lazy.

ND didn't do the remasters...

These games don't have multiplayer either.

Fantastic remaster, Bluepoint can do magic. If you're a newbie to the series or a massive fan it's a no-brainer. No wonder lemmings are upset here trying to deflect with their awful sequel to that generic reboot.

You do know what a remaster is, right lems? Spoiler: it's isn't a lazy remake like Gears Ultimate.

Must own!! Only occasional frame-rate dips and when it does its never lower than 55FPS.

Well done BluePoint Games. All those who jumped ship from the 360 - PS4 are going to have a great time with this collection.