What controler is the best for a FPS

IF all the consoles had the same exact graphics and games what controler will you chose

I will go with the wii remote since its the most presise out of all the controlers and it feels the most like holding a real gun. Next will be 360 controler because of the bottom buttons feal like triggers on a gun. Last is ps3 controler it dont feal like holding a gun at all.

Keyboard and mouse.

Seriously though if the Wii had better graphics, it would be the Wii.

In order:

1. KB+M
2. Xbox 360 (selected)
3. PS3
4. Wii

1:360 controller

2:key board and mouse

3:wii mote

4:ps3 controller

i even play pc games with a controller:P

Keyboard and mouse. Anyone who says otherwise, lies.

Why isn't it in the poll? People game on the PC why is everyone in SW such a nugget >.>

I would imagine the Wii mote being the worst for FPS's because its to sensitive. black_awpN1

And a little delayed.

360 controller hands down

1:key board and mouse

2:wii mote

3:360 controller

4:ps3 controller

i dont play pc games with a controller:P

Kirlok

fixed

[QUOTE="black_awpN1"]I would imagine the Wii mote being the worst for FPS's because its to sensitive. MTBare

And a little delayed.

My main issue with the Wiimote is that it loses "sight" with the screen. It's the only one of the 4 controls (PC, PS3, Xbox 360) that has this flaw. Your mouse doesn't fall of the edge of the screen, and dual analog doesn't allow for it either. In turn it's not just the losing sight that is an issue it's the turning velocity and how to maximize it.

I just don't care to keep track of a pseudo bounding box in reality to make my games work, especially in an FPS.

[QUOTE="Kirlok"]

1:key board and mouse

2:wii mote

3:360 controller

4:ps3 controller

i dont play pc games with a controller:P

XEviscerateX

fixed

[QUOTE="XEviscerateX"][QUOTE="Kirlok"]

1:key board and mouse

2:wii mote

3:360 controller

4:ps3 controller

i dont play pc games with a controller:P

Kirlok

fixed

Get your 360 pad, go play some CSS come back after you rage quit.

Of course Keyboard and Mouse, then Wiimote, then I have to say the 360 controller, but I have never used a PS3 controller. But I' guessing that is pretty much like the PS2 controller, horrible. I don't really like using duel analog at all. When ever I play a FPS on the 360, I just wish I could use the Wiimote :cry:BubbyJello

For me when I played MP3, I wished I could use dual analog :P

[QUOTE="Kirlok"][QUOTE="XEviscerateX"][QUOTE="Kirlok"]

1:key board and mouse

2:wii mote

3:360 controller

4:ps3 controller

i dont play pc games with a controller:P

death1505921

fixed

Get your 360 pad, go play some CSS come back after you rage quit.

[QUOTE="death1505921"][QUOTE="Kirlok"][QUOTE="XEviscerateX"][QUOTE="Kirlok"]

1:key board and mouse

2:wii mote

3:360 controller

4:ps3 controller

i dont play pc games with a controller:P

Kirlok

fixed

Get your 360 pad, go play some CSS come back after you rage quit.

What the hell? Counterstrike source is for the PC. Like I just said, use anything other than a mouse/kb and come back when you rage quit. WHy would you use a D-Pad for fps. I mean seriously.

Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.Smoke_ManMuscle

[QUOTE="Kirlok"][QUOTE="death1505921"][QUOTE="Kirlok"][QUOTE="XEviscerateX"][QUOTE="Kirlok"]

1:key board and mouse

2:wii mote

3:360 controller

4:ps3 controller

i dont play pc games with a controller:P

death1505921

fixed

Get your 360 pad, go play some CSS come back after you rage quit.

What the hell? Counterstrike source is for the PC. Like I just said, use anything other than a mouse/kb and come back when you rage quit. WHy would you use a D-Pad for fps. I mean seriously.

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.C_BozkurT_C

[QUOTE="C_BozkurT_C"][QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.Smoke_ManMuscle

That's more an assumption than factual data, further more the number of FPS to judge that from on the Wii is quite small.

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"][QUOTE="C_BozkurT_C"][QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.-RPGamer-

That's more an assumption than factual data, further more the number of FPS to judge that from on the Wii is quite small.

If you noticed what i asid earlier I said if all the consoles had the same exact graphics and games what controler will you use.

[QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"][QUOTE="C_BozkurT_C"][QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.EmperorZeruel

That's more an assumption than factual data, further more the number of FPS to judge that from on the Wii is quite small.

If you noticed what i asid earlier I said if all the consoles had the same exact graphics and games what controler will you use.

Well for starters conditional "ifs" don't make it any more factual. Secondly, I would still choose a regualr controller, albeit I won't act like I speak for some majority that may or may not exist.

[QUOTE="BubbyJello"]Of course Keyboard and Mouse, then Wiimote, then I have to say the 360 controller, but I have never used a PS3 controller. But I' guessing that is pretty much like the PS2 controller, horrible. I don't really like using duel analog at all. When ever I play a FPS on the 360, I just wish I could use the Wiimote :cry:-RPGamer-

For me when I played MP3, I wished I could use dual analog :P

Thats odd. Even most reviewers say MP3:C has the best controls for any console FPS. I don't really see how one could prefer analog, but as this polls seems to be showing, many people do.

...Or are they just saying that beacuse they don't like the Wii?..

[QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]

[QUOTE="BubbyJello"]Of course Keyboard and Mouse, then Wiimote, then I have to say the 360 controller, but I have never used a PS3 controller. But I' guessing that is pretty much like the PS2 controller, horrible. I don't really like using duel analog at all. When ever I play a FPS on the 360, I just wish I could use the Wiimote :cry:BubbyJello

For me when I played MP3, I wished I could use dual analog :P

Thats odd. Even most reviewers say MP3:C has the best controls for any console FPS. I don't really see how one could prefer analog, but as this polls seems to be showing, many people do.

...Or are they just saying that beacuse they don't like the Wii?..

I listed why I prefer dual analog over motion controls earlier. As for the remainder of these people well who knows, I'm sure some fanboys picked one for reasons that weren't based on the actual topic.

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"][QUOTE="C_BozkurT_C"][QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.-RPGamer-

That's more an assumption than factual data, further more the number of FPS to judge that from on the Wii is quite small.

I suppose you have factual data to support that Wiimote isn't more precise, allows for more fluid aiming, and quicker turning than dual analog?

I guess there's not factual data that keyboard and mouse do that, either, then.

[QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"][QUOTE="C_BozkurT_C"][QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.Smoke_ManMuscle

That's more an assumption than factual data, further more the number of FPS to judge that from on the Wii is quite small.

I suppose you have factual data to support that Wiimote isn't more precise, allows for more fluid aiming, and quicker turning than dual analog?

I guess there's not factual data that keyboard and mouse do that, either, then.

This all true but its had a delayed feel to it. If it was really precise and exact with every movement you do then I would agree but its not.

[QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]

[QUOTE="BubbyJello"]Of course Keyboard and Mouse, then Wiimote, then I have to say the 360 controller, but I have never used a PS3 controller. But I' guessing that is pretty much like the PS2 controller, horrible. I don't really like using duel analog at all. When ever I play a FPS on the 360, I just wish I could use the Wiimote :cry:BubbyJello

For me when I played MP3, I wished I could use dual analog :P

Thats odd. Even most reviewers say MP3:C has the best controls for any console FPS. I don't really see how one could prefer analog, but as this polls seems to be showing, many people do.

...Or are they just saying that beacuse they don't like the Wii?..

You can usually spot someone who hasn't played a proper FPS title (Metroid or Medal of Honor) on Wii, or any Wii title that utilizes the pointer well for that matter. They always say something along the lines of "I don't like FPS with motion controls", when motion controls aren't what makes FPS controls on Wii better than dual analog.

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"][QUOTE="C_BozkurT_C"][QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.Killfox

That's more an assumption than factual data, further more the number of FPS to judge that from on the Wii is quite small.

I suppose you have factual data to support that Wiimote isn't more precise, allows for more fluid aiming, and quicker turning than dual analog?

I guess there's not factual data that keyboard and mouse do that, either, then.

This all true but its had a delayed feel to it. If it was really precise and exact with every movement you do then I would agree but its not.

You should probably get your wiimote checked. The only FPS title on Wii where a delay was obvious was the glitchy pointer in Red Steel. There is no delay, at all, in Metroid or MoHH2.

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"][QUOTE="C_BozkurT_C"][QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]Wiimote. By far. It completely blows dual-analog out of the water.Killfox

That's more an assumption than factual data, further more the number of FPS to judge that from on the Wii is quite small.

I suppose you have factual data to support that Wiimote isn't more precise, allows for more fluid aiming, and quicker turning than dual analog?

I guess there's not factual data that keyboard and mouse do that, either, then.

This all true but its had a delayed feel to it. If it was really precise and exact with every movement you do then I would agree but its not.

Maybe you need to tweak the settings a bit? I even have to do that with KB and Mouse, otherwise I experience what I believe you are describing.

I don't like the KB + M. (For FPS)

I think MS has the perfect controller for shooters.

I've played a FPS with the Wii-mote, and I'm just saying, things didn't go over well...

And I hate the playstation controllers in general. Don't like the shoulder buttons at all.

I suppose you have factual data to support that Wiimote isn't more precise, allows for more fluid aiming, and quicker turning than dual analog?

I guess there's not factual data that keyboard and mouse do that, either, then.

Smoke_ManMuscle

The quicker turning isn't really factual at all. I can lean my thumb in any direction as far as I want (turn up the sensitivity) and spin the day away in a blur. With the Wii you can't go as far as you want, like I said earlier the Wiimote adds a pseudo bounding box in reality that the gamer has to keep tabs on, which does not exist for the other control types. So again there is nothing factual about turn velocity.

I'll give you fluid aiming, since it emulates pointing much like a mouse does (albeit losing the stability of a stationary surface mouse users gain). As for precise that really depends on the user.

I regress though, your statement was "the majority's opinion is that the Wiimote blows the rest out of the water." You're not speaking for the majority, there is no data that says the majority of gamers think the Wiimote blows the rest out of the water (or in similar words), no such study on the market has been done. And as I said before the data is rather limited on the Wii side with it's limited library of FPS.

I don't like the KB + M. (For FPS)

I think MS has the perfect controller for shooters.

I've played a FPS with the Wii-mote, and I'm just saying, things didn't go over well...

And I hate the playstation controllers in general. Don't like the shoulder buttons at all.

SSCyborg

Which FPS title did you play? I guarantee I can tell you how to make playing a FPS with the wiimote more enjoyable than with dual analog.

You can usually spot someone who hasn't played a proper FPS title (Metroid or Medal of Honor) on Wii, or any Wii title that utilizes the pointer well for that matter. They always say something along the lines of "I don't like FPS with motion controls", when motion controls aren't what makes FPS controls on Wii better than dual analog.

Smoke_ManMuscle

I own and have played MP3, hell I played it at the Fusion Tour before it came out (was in line for hours). Please don't assume what you don't actually know.

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]

I suppose you have factual data to support that Wiimote isn't more precise, allows for more fluid aiming, and quicker turning than dual analog?

I guess there's not factual data that keyboard and mouse do that, either, then.

-RPGamer-

The quicker turning isn't really factual at all. I can lean my thumb in any direction as far as I want (turn up the sensitivity) and spin the day away in a blur. With the Wii you can't go as far as you want, like I said earlier the Wiimote adds a pseudo bounding box in reality that the gamer has to keep tabs on, which does not exist for the other control types. So again there is nothing factual about turn velocity.

So you're saying that I don't have sensitivity (lol), but you're still giving me fluidity and, I assume, precision (which there's no argument here, Wii wins).

If you can explain why a more precise and more fluid interface for FPS is worse than a less precise and less fluid interface for FPS, then by all means continue on. Otherwise, just admit the facts: wiimote is a better interface for FPS titles.

[QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]

You can usually spot someone who hasn't played a proper FPS title (Metroid or Medal of Honor) on Wii, or any Wii title that utilizes the pointer well for that matter. They always say something along the lines of "I don't like FPS with motion controls", when motion controls aren't what makes FPS controls on Wii better than dual analog.

-RPGamer-

I own and have played MP3, hell I played it at the Fusion Tour before it came out (was in line for hours). Please don't assume what you don't actually know.

Don't call me out on a lack of factual data if you're just going to bring up anecdotal evidence.

The mouse if I could get away with it. But since were talking consoles, wiimote.

I can't imagine anyone actually choosing dual analog.

[QUOTE="-RPGamer-"][QUOTE="Smoke_ManMuscle"]

I suppose you have factual data to support that Wiimote isn't more precise, allows for more fluid aiming, and quicker turning than dual analog?

I guess there's not factual data that keyboard and mouse do that, either, then.

Smoke_ManMuscle

The quicker turning isn't really factual at all. I can lean my thumb in any direction as far as I want (turn up the sensitivity) and spin the day away in a blur. With the Wii you can't go as far as you want, like I said earlier the Wiimote adds a pseudo bounding box in reality that the gamer has to keep tabs on, which does not exist for the other control types. So again there is nothing factual about turn velocity.

So you're saying that I don't have sensitivity (lol), but you're still giving me fluidity and, I assume, precision (which there's no argument here, Wii wins).

If you can explain why a more precise and more fluid interface for FPS is worse than a less precise and less fluid interface for FPS, then by all means continue on. Otherwise, just admit the facts: wiimote is a better interface for FPS titles.

Did I say you can't adjust the sensitivity? Hmmm, nope sure didn't. I gave you fluidity/intuitive b/c it's a pointer set up (much like a light gun), the percision I left open seeing as it's user specific (nothing is really stopping a person from being precise with dual analog, I've seen people do really well with it actually).

It's not a fact, I stated a flaw with it already earlier in the thread. The term "better" in this case is user specific, it's a preference. Do you understand the difference between subjectivity and fact?