what do you think will be the most overated game for 2011?

Uncharted 3...Jamani

The only thing overrated on this board are people's opinion of their opinions. Deathtransit

Probably Resistance 3

Probably Resistance 3

ps3wizard45

Resistance 1 was solid. Resistance 2 was garbage.

-Snooze-

I was under the impression that garbage is a solid... :|

Joking aside: I loved both Resistance games (although R1 had a better Single Player, imo).

Topic: Probably Crysis 2.

• Crysis 2
• R3
• DE:HR (a la Fallout 3)
• KZ3
• Gears 3

The next CoD. those games have been way overrated since 4

The next CoD. those games have been way overrated since 4

taterfrickintot

Any of Sony big exclusives of this year: Resistance 3, Killzone 3 or Uncharted 3.Miroku32

Wish I could say the same about M$'s exclusives this year... :(

Oh wait, there's only one!

Uncharted 3 by several miles. People are going to claim its better than Jesus and then forget about it when Uncharted 4 comes out.

Skyward Sword. No matter what they release it will be proclaimed as the second coming by some. Doesn't matter what they've changed, what they haven't, and it wont be judged on its own merits but on the fact that it is zelda.

So that. Compared to, say, Skyrim, it will be around 3 points worse yet may recieve a better score. Because it is zelda and you can't be realistic about it.

Skyward Sword. No matter what they release it will be proclaimed as the second coming by some. Doesn't matter what they've changed, what they haven't, and it wont be judged on its own merits but on the fact that it is zelda.

So that. Compared to, say, Skyrim, it will be around 3 points worse yet may recieve a better score. Because it is zelda and you can't be realistic about it.

Chemical_Viking

ok then...

[QUOTE="Chemical_Viking"]

Skyward Sword. No matter what they release it will be proclaimed as the second coming by some. Doesn't matter what they've changed, what they haven't, and it wont be judged on its own merits but on the fact that it is zelda.

So that. Compared to, say, Skyrim, it will be around 3 points worse yet may recieve a better score. Because it is zelda and you can't be realistic about it.

Shinobishyguy

ok then...

Doesn't matter. It will not be judged on its own merits. The early screenshots show a game which looks nothing but average, yet people are salivating over it. That shows all you need to know. At this stage, it has a lot to live up to and I sincerely doubt it will achieve anything. If they change it, the fans whine because it isn't zelda. If they don't, it stagnates.

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="GreenGoblin2099"]

Skyward Sword.

iloverikku11

X3

Also any 3DS game that is just a "remake" of an N64 game. :roll:

▲ Agreed. I'm not saying these will be bad games, but I doubt most of them will be as good as their scores say. Also, I'm surprised to see charizard1605 actually saying that ▲

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"]

[QUOTE="Chemical_Viking"]

Skyward Sword. No matter what they release it will be proclaimed as the second coming by some. Doesn't matter what they've changed, what they haven't, and it wont be judged on its own merits but on the fact that it is zelda.

So that. Compared to, say, Skyrim, it will be around 3 points worse yet may recieve a better score. Because it is zelda and you can't be realistic about it.

Chemical_Viking

ok then...

Doesn't matter. It will not be judged on its own merits.

or is this the whole "b'aaaw everyone's a nintendo fanboy but me, ONLY I CAN SEE THE TRUTH" type of deal?

[QUOTE="Chemical_Viking"]

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"] so you've pretty much made up your mind that the game is gonna be over-rated without considering that maybe...just maybe..it might actually end up deseving it's praise?

ok then...

Shinobishyguy

Doesn't matter. It will not be judged on its own merits.

or is this the whole "b'aaaw everyone's a nintendo fanboy but me, ONLY I CAN SEE THE TRUTH" type of deal?

▲ I thought I was the only one who had this condition, no? ▲

probably killzone 3. cows will scream its the greatest game in the world, then abandon the onlinemultiplayer like they did killzone 2

[QUOTE="Chemical_Viking"]

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"] so you've pretty much made up your mind that the game is gonna be over-rated without considering that maybe...just maybe..it might actually end up deseving it's praise?

ok then...

Shinobishyguy

Doesn't matter. It will not be judged on its own merits.

or is this the whole "b'aaaw everyone's a nintendo fanboy but me, ONLY I CAN SEE THE TRUTH" type of deal?

No, it's a kind of "vast examples of past experience on the matter" types of deal. The second part of your post made absolutely no sense btw.

[QUOTE="Miroku32"]Any of Sony big exclusives of this year: Resistance 3, Killzone 3 or Uncharted 3.xYamatox

Wish I could say the same about M$'s exclusives this year... :(

Oh wait, there's only one!

No there isn't.

I'm going to say Mass Effect 3. It will probably be a good game, but people will praise it like it's the greatest game of all time. Bioware is overrated IMO.

i think it will either be mass effect 3 or uncharted 3, not that they will be bad but after how much praises and good reviews ME2 and UC2 have. People will be expecting those games to be absolutely incredible. Kind of like GT5, decent game but destroyed by its own hype.

ps resistance is amazing, especially the second game. I thought the multiplayer werent so great but the single player was very fast pace, lots of enemies on screen at the same time making things chaotic ina fun way, gigantic enemies, chalenging, pretty awesome experience for me lengthy campaign (at least thats what i remember). its not your typical shooter. oh and shocking ending.

i would say resistance 3 or pokemon black or whitedkdrumin

Killzone 3 if it's anything like the 2nd. SAGE_OF_FIRE

[QUOTE="Miroku32"]Any of Sony big exclusives of this year: Resistance 3, Killzone 3 or Uncharted 3.xYamatox

Wish I could say the same about M$'s exclusives this year... :(

Oh wait, there's only one!

Any of Sony big exclusives of this year: Resistance 3, Killzone 3 or Uncharted 3.Miroku32

[QUOTE="iloverikku11"]

[QUOTE="charizard1605"] This man speaks the truth.Loco_Live

X3

Also any 3DS game that is just a "remake" of an N64 game. :roll:

▲ Agreed. I'm not saying these will be bad games, but I doubt most of them will be as good as their scores say. Also, I'm surprised to see charizard1605 actually saying that ▲

Forza 4... Hell. The studio that makes it will probably over hype at E3 and laugh at PD face for scoring lower than Forza 3.. right there... on stage.

[QUOTE="Loco_Live"]

[QUOTE="iloverikku11"]

X3

Also any 3DS game that is just a "remake" of an N64 game. :roll:

charizard1605

▲ Agreed. I'm not saying these will be bad games, but I doubt most of them will be as good as their scores say. Also, I'm surprised to see charizard1605 actually saying that ▲

Forza 4... Hell. The studio that makes it will probably over hype at E3 and laugh at PD face for scoring lower than Forza 3.. right there... on stage.

Infinite_Access

[QUOTE="Infinite_Access"]

Forza 4... Hell. The studio that makes it will probably over hype at E3 and laugh at PD face for scoring lower than Forza 3.. right there... on stage.

foxhound_fox

... and yet for me the better game is Gran Turismo. Why the **** can't I use my G27 with Forza? Why can't I turn off all the assists? Turn 10 does so much better, I really hope they address this stuff in the future.

... and yet for me the better game is Gran Turismo. Why the **** can't I use my G27 with Forza? Why can't I turn off all the assists? Turn 10 does so much better, I really hope they address this stuff in the future.

psn8214

Which assist can't be turned off?

[QUOTE="psn8214"]

... and yet for me the better game is Gran Turismo. Why the **** can't I use my G27 with Forza? Why can't I turn off all the assists? Turn 10 does so much better, I really hope they address this stuff in the future.

waltefmoney

Which assist can't be turned off?

Active steering. If you're playing with a gamepad, it's incredibly noticeable. Try to turn hard left or right and observe, then try that in GT5. It diminishes the overall sense of control over a car, especially compared to GT5 with no assists where the slightest turn of the wheel or analog stick will move your car.

If Skyrim turns out like Oblivion did, then I'd definitely consider that the most overrated game of 2011. Oblivion was more overrated than Gears of War, which is saying a LOT.

... and yet for me the better game is Gran Turismo. Why the **** can't I use my G27 with Forza? Why can't I turn off all the assists? Turn 10 does so much better, I really hope they address this stuff in the future.

psn8214

uncharted 3

Pokemon Black/Whitedkdrumin

This, easily. I've never seen any game series get away with not evolving like Pokemon. Pun not intended.

Killzone 3

Gears of War 3 and Uncharted 3