What do you think will sell more Playstation Move or Microsoft Natal?

Wii sports had a cool boxing game it was limited you could just flick the controller and even in the Kevin Butler ad sony was trying to convince people that the PS3 move was more response but it will be the same.

Natal on the other hand scan's your whole body so ever punch and kick will be replicated, I'm just wishful thinking here but if capcom could make a street fighter game where you face the character head on and make it work would be awesome.

I think most people will be more interested in Natal just because it requires no controls and especially if it runs as smooth as in the demos.

[QUOTE="djsifer01"]PS Move. Natal is going to completely fail.GreySeal9

Do you have any particular reason for saying this?

I think they'll both flop hard, but be refined and included in the next gen, four years down the line. Add-ons always have a hard time. People don't want the accessory unless there are good games, but companies won't invest heavily in making quality games unless there's a sufficient user base to buy the product. Bundles are a good start, but this late in the generation, the markets are pretty well saturated.

I think they'll both flop hard, but be refined and included in the next gen, four years down the line. Add-ons always have a hard time. People don't want the accessory unless there are good games, but companies won't invest heavily in making quality games unless there's a sufficient user base to buy the product. Bundles are a good start, but this late in the generation, the markets are pretty well saturated.

hellhund

[QUOTE="hellhund"]

I think they'll both flop hard, but be refined and included in the next gen, four years down the line. Add-ons always have a hard time. People don't want the accessory unless there are good games, but companies won't invest heavily in making quality games unless there's a sufficient user base to buy the product. Bundles are a good start, but this late in the generation, the markets are pretty well saturated.

adamlovesu

I think they'll both flop hard, but be refined and included in the next gen, four years down the line. Add-ons always have a hard time. People don't want the accessory unless there are good games, but companies won't invest heavily in making quality games unless there's a sufficient user base to buy the product. Bundles are a good start, but this late in the generation, the markets are pretty well saturated.

[QUOTE="hellhund"][QUOTE="adamlovesu"] this is where ms has things on lock...... adamlovesu

[QUOTE="adamlovesu"][QUOTE="hellhund"] How so? The rumored price is pretty high, unless a $300 Natal bundle is true. But even then, you can't play normal games with Natal. The lack of buttons is fatal. And if you're using a normal controller, what's the point of Natal? Any voice commands could be done with a headset, like has been done before. During intense gameplay, you're not going to want to take a hand of the controller to make signals to the camera. It'll be fine for Wii Sports, Tiger Woods and Mario Party clones, but not much else.adamlovesu

your calling a headset a suffecient replacement to natal?adamlovesu

[QUOTE="adamlovesu"]your calling a headset a suffecient replacement to natal?hellhund

Natal will appeal more to casuals, which is a big chunk of the market. When casuals look at Move, they are just going to say it's just a Wii ripoff. I can already do that with my Wii. I still have to play with a wand and a nunchuck. Natal is hands free, casuals will like that.

Of course the main driving factor will be game support. Are there fun games to play?

[QUOTE="hellhund"][QUOTE="adamlovesu"]your calling a headset a suffecient replacement to natal?adamlovesu