What was the most unfair flop given to the xbox360 right here on Gamespot

I would say Fable 2 getting 8.5. Should of been AAA. Crackdown getting A was another one that comes to mind, and the original Mass Effect. Please say which one was the most unfair flop. Thanks

Either Crackdown or Alan Wake. Alan Wake should have been AAA, and Crackdown AA imo.Anjunaddict

I agreed with them on Alan Wake because I thought it got too repetitive, that game started off awesome but definitely was not as fun as I came close to ending it.

Alan Wake, Too Human second.

I totally agree. It was unfair of them to express their opinion that you don't agree with. Who do they think they are.Skittles_McGee

didnt ask for your opinion and Gamespot is the best at reviews and we go by them, they are untitled to be off once in a while so we discuss. Please leave the thread if you dont have anything other than that to offer.

Alan Wake or Halo Wars.Chrome-

I agree Halo Wars was very tough review.

I can't think of one really. I agree with the range of alot of the scores for games here.FlamesOfGrey

that is fair they are the best at what they do for sure.

Unfair flop?

Expressing an opinion on a game isn't unfair.

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"]I totally agree. It was unfair of them to express their opinion that you don't agree with. Who do they think they are.ProjectNatalFan

didnt ask for your opinion and Gamespot is the best at reviews and we go by them, they are untitled to be off once in a while so we discuss. Please leave the thread if you dont have anything other than that to offer.

Either Crackdown or Alan Wake. Alan Wake should have been AAA, and Crackdown AA imo.Anjunaddict

[QUOTE="FlamesOfGrey"]I can't think of one really. I agree with the range of alot of the scores for games here.ProjectNatalFan

that is fair they are the best at what they do for sure.

[QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"]I totally agree. It was unfair of them to express their opinion that you don't agree with. Who do they think they are.Skittles_McGee

didnt ask for your opinion and Gamespot is the best at reviews and we go by them, they are untitled to be off once in a while so we discuss. Please leave the thread if you dont have anything other than that to offer.

we are bros for life my friend, Gamespot rules too. =D

[QUOTE="Anjunaddict"]Either Crackdown or Alan Wake. Alan Wake should have been AAA, and Crackdown AA imo.Diviniuz

what did LO get? Everyone talks about that game!!!

[QUOTE="Anjunaddict"]Either Crackdown or Alan Wake. Alan Wake should have been AAA, and Crackdown AA imo.Diviniuz

Mass Effect hands down.

Mass Effect

Halo Wars

Lost Odyssey

Crackdown

Too Human

Oh and Halo 3 should have got the 10/10 and GOTY or at the very least FPS OTY. :P

[QUOTE="Anjunaddict"]Either Crackdown or Alan Wake. Alan Wake should have been AAA, and Crackdown AA imo.Diviniuz

I definitely agree with Lost Odyssey's score. FlamesOfGrey

[QUOTE="Anjunaddict"]Either Crackdown or Alan Wake. Alan Wake should have been AAA, and Crackdown AA imo.Diviniuz

I'm not gonna lie, it's a lot better than I anticipated. I think the Gametrailers review was pretty spot on.

Mass Effect hands down.

ImaPirate0202

Mass Effect

Halo Wars

Lost Odyssey

Crackdown

Too Human

Oh and Halo 3 should have got the 10/10 and GOTY or at the very least FPS OTY. :P

SecretPolice

i do not bother looking at gamespot's scores because they usually do not know what they are talking about. i only look at metacritic or watch gametrailers reviews..i like to see the game that is being reviewed.

but i will list some games on the 360 i think deserve to be talked about. kameo and banjo nuts and bolts were both good. nobody talks PGR but it is a solid franchise that kept getting better. alan wake was not a AAA game but it was a great game and was actually unique. viva pinata gets a bad rap but i think it is good for people who like that sort of thing. in other words i didn't hate playing it.

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

Mass Effect

Halo Wars

Lost Odyssey

Crackdown

Too Human

Oh and Halo 3 should have got the 10/10 and GOTY or at the very least FPS OTY. :P

mystervj

....boom, pow, right to the moon. :P

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"]I totally agree. It was unfair of them to express their opinion that you don't agree with. Who do they think they are.ProjectNatalFan

didnt ask for your opinion and Gamespot is the best at reviews and we go by them, they are untitled to be off once in a while so we discuss. Please leave the thread if you dont have anything other than that to offer.

Alan Wake for sure. AW should have easily been a 9.0 or 9.5.

The fact that AW only got an 8.5 and GTA4 got a 10 is just proof that reviews are nothing more than opinions, and most of the time they are wrong.

Alan Wake for sure. AW should have easily been a 9.0 or 9.5.

The fact that AW only got an 8.5 and GTA4 got a 10 is just proof that reviews are nothing more than opinions, and most of the time they are wrong.

[QUOTE="ImaPirate0202"]

Mass Effect hands down.

FlamesOfGrey

^^ This. ME1 was "good" at best, but not AAA material in any way (at least on 360).

Alan Wake for sure. AW should have easily been a 9.0 or 9.5.

The fact that AW only got an 8.5 and GTA4 got a 10 is just proof that reviews are nothing more than opinions, and most of the time they are wrong.

coasterguy65

An opinion can't be wrong.

Alan Wake for sure. AW should have easily been a 9.0 or 9.5.

The fact that AW only got an 8.5 and GTA4 got a 10 is just proof that reviews are nothing more than opinions, and most of the time they are wrong.

most unfair flop on gamespot was perfect dark zero. i dont know why gamespot gave it the score it got...Rahnyc4

Alan Wake for sure. AW should have easily been a 9.0 or 9.5.

The fact that AW only got an 8.5 and GTA4 got a 10 is just proof that reviews are nothing more than opinions, and most of the time they are wrong.

[QUOTE="ImaPirate0202"]

Mass Effect hands down.

FlamesOfGrey

To each his own. I thought the games problems were miniscule when compared to it's combat, storyline, music, voice acting... all of the things I loved about it.

The Mako controls were pretty bad, though.

[QUOTE="FlamesOfGrey"][QUOTE="ImaPirate0202"]

Mass Effect hands down.

To each his own. I thought the games problems were miniscule when compared to it's combat, storyline, music, voice acting... all of the things I loved about it.

The Mako controls were pretty bad, though.

[QUOTE="FlamesOfGrey"][QUOTE="ImaPirate0202"]

Mass Effect hands down.

ImaPirate0202

To each his own. I thought the games problems were miniscule when compared to it's combat, storyline, music, voice acting... all of the things I loved about it.

The Mako controls were pretty bad, though.

[QUOTE="FlamesOfGrey"][QUOTE="ImaPirate0202"]

Mass Effect hands down.

ImaPirate0202

To each his own. I thought the games problems were miniscule when compared to it's combat, storyline, music, voice acting... all of the things I loved about it.

The Mako controls were pretty bad, though.

The combat was pretty average, the story didn't really go anywhere for half the game, and the voice acting was "okay" since characters didn't seem to have much emotion in their diologe for the most part (Shephard was the worst offender of this).

I would say Fable 2 getting 8.5. Should of been AAA. Crackdown getting A was another one that comes to mind, and the original Mass Effect. Please say which one was the most unfair flop. Thanks

ProjectNatalFan

same with mass effect, at the time i was saying good game but omg can thecombat get any clunkier and wth is up with the damn elevators?

• Lost Odyssey
• Mass Effect

And I'll add a multiplat:

• NIER

I think TC is asking for peoples own opinions on what was an unfair flop.

Fable II was horrible.

If anything alan wake.

[QUOTE="Chrome-"]Alan Wake or Halo Wars.ProjectNatalFan

I agree Halo Wars was very tough review.