What would happen if Brawl got a 7.5?

every nintendo fanboy will kill themselves for seeing the horror of a game that got anything less than a 9

im not a basher or hater but come on, nintendo has to stop making the same rehases every year i swear if i see another SSB or Zelda game im gonna tape 360 to my chest and shout "Halo3 rules" in nintendos hq

Reviews still carry weight here on GS after Kane & Lynch? Not in my world.

Besides, a 7.5 would have no effect on sales or how good it is. EVeryone knows what to expect.

Didnt a version of smash get a so-so review anyway?

If it gets a 7.5, then it gets the score it deserves for being a wanna be fighter in party game clothing.grimhope

Agree with that but i dont see it possible for a 7.5. 8.5+ for sure

Yeah I would'y care

ARWEN'S BABY ELF TURD

If it gets a 7.5, then it gets the score it deserves for being a wanna be fighter in party game clothing.grimhope

Just FYI, your fanboy opinion isn't the "truth" nor do it "hurt" anything but your quickly decaying credibility.

As of now, I have no idea of the exact score Gamespot will give it, but judging by their previews, they weren't impressed with some of the control schemes of the game, which means they'll probably give it lower than a 9.

IGN has also hinted at their score in a podcast, saying that it won't score as high as Metriod Prime 3 (which they gave a 9.5).

Reviews still carry weight here on GS after Kane & Lynch? Not in my world.

flazzle

agreed ever since the jeff thing i dont even bother with the reviews here

famitsu gave it top marks which is a rare sight so i have high hopes from there judgement that it will get 9.0 or higher here (unless no money has changed hands)

I'd imagine it'd go something like this, only maybe a bit worseTyrantDragon55

There is no way it's scoring higher than 8.5. It's exactly the same as the first two games. Then again, GS has rated all GTA and Halo games insanely high depsite being exactly the same, so anything is possible I guess.UssjTrunks

LOL at both your quote and your sig :lol:

"exactly the same".... yeah ok

If it gets a 7.5, then it gets the score it deserves for being a wanna be fighter in party game clothing.grimhope

So just because it doesn't quite fit within the definition of an incredibly unimaginative genre it should get a bad score. Once you've seen one fighter, you've seen them all, even 2-D and 3-D aren't that different.

[QUOTE="grimhope"]If it gets a 7.5, then it gets the score it deserves for being a wanna be fighter in party game clothing.Tylendal

So just because it doesn't quite fit within the definition of an incredibly unimaginative genre it should get a bad score. Once you've seen one fighter, you've seen them all, even 2-D and 3-D aren't that different.

You've done it now :P People are going to start posting how much skill fighting games take.... (aka memorization)

every nintendo fanboy will kill themselves for seeing the horror of a game that got anything less than a 9

im not a basher or hater but come on, nintendo has to stop making the same rehases every year i swear if i see another SSB or Zelda game im gonna tape 360 to my chest and shout "Halo3 rules" in nintendos hq

Pinkyimp

Interesting.... if Nintendo stopped making Smash Bros and Zelda games I would be one unhappy camper. Also please note this is only the 3rd Smash game. The last one came out 6 years ago, nice try though.

Remember on lost when Locke stopped pressing the button in the hatch?

Thats what would happen.

[QUOTE="Tylendal"]

[QUOTE="grimhope"]If it gets a 7.5, then it gets the score it deserves for being a wanna be fighter in party game clothing.PopeReal

So just because it doesn't quite fit within the definition of an incredibly unimaginative genre it should get a bad score. Once you've seen one fighter, you've seen them all, even 2-D and 3-D aren't that different.

You've done it now :P People are going to start posting how much skill fighting games take.... (aka memorization)

Well, I play SC: II as Ivy, so I know that huge moves are useless unless you can disrupt the opponent with quick moves first. And you do need to have incredibly fast reflexes to use things like impact guards.

However, it annoys me when people call Brawl a button masher, and then talk about a game where, unlike SSB, buttom-mashing is actually a viable strategy as you're always forced into close quarters. Brawl is all about positioning and movement, whereas traditional fighters are more concerned with attack and defense.

And I stand by what I said. I don't deny that they need skill, but you see one fighter, you've seen them all.

Remember on lost when Locke stopped pressing the button in the hatch?

Thats what would happen.

Bread_or_Decide

Who would give a damn? It's not like a 7.5 is horrible/broken.

From what I've seen so far about it though, it'll probably get a 9.