When episodes from liberty city gets AAA....

will it count as a AAA exclusive, we all know GS will review it and its not on Ps3 and its def gonna get AAA so.... 360 AAA exlusive in october!!!!!!

There's going to be a huge war over thatpyromaniac223

It's on a disc and you don't need to GTA IV to play it...oh boy, this is going to be a toughie.

There's going to be a huge war over thatpyromaniac223

That's ifGamespot reviews it.

[QUOTE="pyromaniac223"]There's going to be a huge war over thatnhh18

will it count as a AAA exclusive, we all know GS will review it and its not on Ps3 and its def gonna get AAA so.... 360 AAA exlusive in october!!!!!!

xnacommunityxna

It's on a disc and you don't need to GTA IV to play it...oh boy, this is going to be a toughie.

mitu123

I guess so then, but still 2009 = Year of the PS3.

[QUOTE="pyromaniac223"]There's going to be a huge war over thatnhh18

oh man.... people still are in denial?

That's ifGamespot reviews it.

Lionheart08

Everyone knows that TLAD was about 10 hours of content, Gay Tony will be the same...20 hours is a complete game but I mean...I'm confused on it. I think it should count as long as it's just the DLC and not the actual GTA IV game and since it doesn't, I think Episodes should count as it's an exclusive Expansion if you will.

It's on a disc and you don't need to GTA IV to play it...oh boy, this is going to be a toughie.

mitu123

it's been established multiple times that it's counting. Standalone games that don't need previous games to run them = counts on spreadsheet. Really not that hard to understandDeadMagazines

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

It's on a disc and you don't need to GTA IV to play it...oh boy, this is going to be a toughie.

110million

Compilations have never counted in the past (reviewed or not).

It's on a disc and you don't need to GTA IV to play it...oh boy, this is going to be a toughie.

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

That's ifGamespot reviews it.

Toriko42

Well now I do. :P

Personally I say it should count, as one AA or AAA though.

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

It's on a disc and you don't need to GTA IV to play it...oh boy, this is going to be a toughie.

110million

[QUOTE="nhh18"]

[QUOTE="pyromaniac223"]There's going to be a huge war over thatxnacommunityxna

oh man.... people still are in denial?

Compilations have never counted in the past (reviewed or not).

Nike_Air

Yes it should count.

Lots of expansions are counted as AAAE, so I don't see why EFLC should be exempted.

Compilations have never counted in the past (reviewed or not).

Nike_Air

Yup, AAAE.

After all this, watch it get a AA. Ha.

[QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

Compilations have never counted in the past (reviewed or not).

DeadMagazines

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"][QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

Compilations have never counted in the past (reviewed or not).

Nike_Air

L&D wasn't reviewed.

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"][QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

Compilations have never counted in the past (reviewed or not).

Nike_Air

HL2: Episode 2 and Portal got their own reviews, even though they were already a part of The Orange Box.

Another AAA from an expansion? What a surprise.

Yup, AAAE.

After all this, watch it get a AA. Ha.

BioShockOwnz

[QUOTE="xnacommunityxna"]

[QUOTE="nhh18"]until 6 months later when it is finally comes out on ps3 when then it suddenly is just dlc.

nhh18

oh man.... people still are in denial?

apparently you dont understand contracts.... allow me to explain... when microsoft purchased the DLC from rockstar they made whats called a contract, in this contract it states that the two DLC episodes will remain exclusive... no matter how much cows cry about it

Another AAA from an expansion? What a surprise.

DealRogers

Yup, AAAE.

After all this, watch it get a AA. Ha.

BioShockOwnz

It's possible. They could mark it down for not being a huge improvement of GTAIV, but BoGT looks like an epic win so I think it'll get AAA.

Another AAA from an expansion? What a surprise.

[QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"] It's not a compilation if it hasn't been released or already reviewed. ..just quit. SpinoRaptor24

HL2: Episode 2 and Portal got their own reviews, even though they were already a part of The Orange Box.

[QUOTE="nhh18"]

[QUOTE="xnacommunityxna"]

oh man.... people still are in denial?

xnacommunityxna

apparently you dont understand contracts.... allow me to explain... when microsoft purchased the DLC from rockstar they made whats called a contract, in this contract it states that the two DLC episodes will remain exclusive... no matter how much cows cry about it

Even if GS reviews it, it will simply count towards the XBL category which is not included in overrall exclusives...this gen at least.

Even if GS reviews it, it will simply count towards the XBL which is not included in overrall exclusives...this gen at least.

Derek240

[QUOTE="SpinoRaptor24"]

[QUOTE="Nike_Air"]The Lost and Damned was already released. This pack is just a compilation of a previous game and a new one that will be counted seperately too becasue it's its own entity as well.

Nike_Air

HL2: Episode 2 and Portal got their own reviews, even though they were already a part of The Orange Box.

I don't understand what people are arguing for. Of course it will be rated. Gamespot rates the Fallout 3 DLC, they'll rate this too. And it should count. Now that it's on disk, I don't even consider it DLC anymore. It's now considered an EXPANSION PACK. You know, those things from last gen? Of course you can't remeber! Stupid DLC movement!! :x

[QUOTE="Derek240"]

Even if GS reviews it, it will simply count towards the XBL which is not included in overrall exclusives...this gen at least.

Toriko42

Ah I see. So it will be on store shelves?

[QUOTE="xnacommunityxna"]

[QUOTE="nhh18"]Yeah. Just like people are in denial about bioshock coming to ps3, lost planet, eternal sonata, tales of vesperia, ninja gaiden 2, and every 3rd party xbox 360 game. Don't worry the chances that ff14, and agent staying ps3 exclusive is just as likely. None. Expect an announcement no later than march 2010, than we won't have to hear about gta 4 dlc being counted exclusive or not.

nhh18

apparently you dont understand contracts.... allow me to explain... when microsoft purchased the DLC from rockstar they made whats called a contract, in this contract it states that the two DLC episodes will remain exclusive... no matter how much cows cry about it

funny, coulda sworn that was the 3rd party devs who paid for the production.....

.QUOTE="xnacommunityxna"]

[QUOTE="xnacommunityxna"]

apparently you dont understand contracts.... allow me to explain... when microsoft purchased the DLC from rockstar they made whats called a contract, in this contract it states that the two DLC episodes will remain exclusive... no matter how much cows cry about it

nhh18

funny, coulda sworn that was the 3rd party devs who paid for the production.....

[QUOTE="Nike_Air"]

[QUOTE="SpinoRaptor24"]

HL2: Episode 2 and Portal got their own reviews, even though they were already a part of The Orange Box.

mitu123

[QUOTE="nhh18"]

[QUOTE="xnacommunityxna"]

oh man.... people still are in denial?

xnacommunityxna

apparently you dont understand contracts.... allow me to explain... when microsoft purchased the DLC from rockstar they made whats called a contract, in this contract it states that the two DLC episodes will remain exclusive... no matter how much cows cry about it

Theres no way to know what the guidelines of the contract were. For all we know the contract was limited to a set period of time where all GTA DLC is exclusive only during that time and could thus be released on the PS3 after that.

If this is the case cows wanna go down, then neither NG sigma games will count, GT5P won't count, none of their JRPG ports will count etc etc. Since the ports have already been reviewed, then the new releases on ps3 cease to exist by SW logic. Demos do not exist as well. I'm sure I can find more instances if I wanted to try harder.DeadMagazines

None of them have ever count as exclusives. :|

Can somebody answer this: Will eflc be available on store shelves?

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"]If this is the case cows wanna go down, then neither NG sigma games will count, GT5P won't count, none of their JRPG ports will count etc etc. Since the ports have already been reviewed, then the new releases on ps3 cease to exist by SW logic. Demos do not exist as well. I'm sure I can find more instances if I wanted to try harder.Lionheart08

None of them have ever count as exclusives. :|