Which game has a better shot at being AAAAE? Uncharted 3 or Zelda SS?

Is that necessarily a good thing? Especially when it comes to gaming?funsohng

I guess Uncharted 3 but for the record, I believe they both practically have an equal chance. I'm giving UC3 the edge because Tom McShea can be a hard-ass to Wii games.

Let's be honest here. Zelda has no chance.

[QUOTE="funsohng"] Is that necessarily a good thing? Especially when it comes to gaming?IronBass

I think Zelda has the best chance but I think U3 will deserve it more. Mostly because I believe that franchises like Zelda are becoming overrated because of nostalgia.

Cheesehead9099

:|

Zelda is amazing. They didn't overrate Twilight Princess, and they won't overrate SS. If it gets a 10 it will have deserved it :). Uncharted 3 and Skyward Sword are two of my most hyped games at the moment.

Neither game has a chance, but I think SS will have a better shot at a 10 than U3.

By the way, I have an internet.

Neither game has a chance, but I think SS will have a better shot at a 10 than U3.

By the way, I have an internet.

The-Mosher

If GTA IV and Super Mario Galaxy 2 can get a 10, both of these games can definitely get a 10.

Uncharted is simply the superior series. Zelda can't match UC's cinematic experience.IronBass

[QUOTE="funsohng"] Is that necessarily a good thing? Especially when it comes to gaming?IronBass

I cannot stand this lol. Do people realize that gaming has been getting more and more cinematic every year? Uncharted does this well. I can understand if people dont like all the scenes of MGS4 (I love the game), but Uncharted has amazing gameplay that is enhanced by its cinematic feel. Guess what? Super Metroid was more cinematic than Metroid. And the Prime series was even more cinematic...My gosh the insanity!

[QUOTE="IronBass"]Uncharted is simply the superior series. Zelda can't match UC's cinematic experience.DarkLink77

join us DL....join us:twisted:

and you have Mass Effect 3 on your sig..... OH SNAP :Pfunsohng

Must... resist... :PDarkLink77

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

[QUOTE="IronBass"]Uncharted is simply the superior series. Zelda can't match UC's cinematic experience.eboyishere

join us DL....join us:twisted:

Must... resist... :PDarkLink77

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"] Must... resist... :P

DarkLink77

join us DL....join us:twisted:

sarcasm?.......no....my pride:|

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]but Zelda still hasn't changed much over the years.funsohng

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

I think Zelda has the best chance but I think U3 will deserve it more. Mostly because I believe that franchises like Zelda are becoming overrated because of nostalgia.

NaveedLife

:|

Zelda is amazing. They didn't overrate Twilight Princess, and they won't overrate SS. If it gets a 10 it will have deserved it :). Uncharted 3 and Skyward Sword are two of my most hyped games at the moment.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

I think Zelda has the best chance but I think U3 will deserve it more. Mostly because I believe that franchises like Zelda are becoming overrated because of nostalgia.

Cheesehead9099

:|

Zelda is amazing. They didn't overrate Twilight Princess, and they won't overrate SS. If it gets a 10 it will have deserved it :). Uncharted 3 and Skyward Sword are two of my most hyped games at the moment.

I thought he was fired for Kane and Lynch? TP was the best Zelda game I've played yet (/inserts haters gonna hate gif here)

I predict Skyward Sword being the underdog this year. We know UC3 is gonna be great, but GS is gonna find something to give it a 9.0. Still, none will come close to 10 status as BF3 :twisted:

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

[QUOTE="SaltyMeatballs"] Nah that's just your opinion. SaltyMeatballs

"I suppose that it is, but Zelda still hasn't changed much over the years."

Looks like your hyping Uncharted. Uncharted 2 brought nothing new (from what I have heard I have not played it) and is one of the highest rated games this gen. With bi-annual releases you should get ready to be disappointed with the franchise if you think Zelda is over rated.

Zelda franchise is unique, and we are lucky to get 2 a generation. Wii will be getting its first this year, it looks great, and will be a nice change for the franchise. Nintendo is addressing a lot I suggest you check some interviews. Uncharted is just better than the sum of it's parts.

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"][QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

:|

Zelda is amazing. They didn't overrate Twilight Princess, and they won't overrate SS. If it gets a 10 it will have deserved it :). Uncharted 3 and Skyward Sword are two of my most hyped games at the moment.

ChubbyGuy40

I thought he was fired for Kane and Lynch? TP was the best Zelda game I've played yet (/inserts haters gonna hate gif here)

I predict Skyward Sword being the underdog this year. We know UC3 is gonna be great, but GS is gonna find something to give it a 9.0. Still, none will come close to 10 status as BF3 :twisted:

SS still has a chance to get AAAA, but if they don't make any more changes to the game than they have in previous entries, then I probably won't agree with the score unless they pull a SMG2.

And I can't wait for BF3 either :D

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

I think Zelda has the best chance but I think U3 will deserve it more. Mostly because I believe that franchises like Zelda are becoming overrated because of nostalgia.

Cheesehead9099

:|

Zelda is amazing. They didn't overrate Twilight Princess, and they won't overrate SS. If it gets a 10 it will have deserved it :). Uncharted 3 and Skyward Sword are two of my most hyped games at the moment.

Wow you must have stupidly high standards then.

PS - why did you review Uncharted 2 at a 10 then? :?

Sorry, got that wrong, yeah he was fired for Kane and Lynch. There was still a huge uproar about the score here though, so my point still sort of stands. Cheesehead9099

Wasn't the Twlight Princess score when System Wars warriors were out in full-force? :lol:

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"][QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

:|

Zelda is amazing. They didn't overrate Twilight Princess, and they won't overrate SS. If it gets a 10 it will have deserved it :). Uncharted 3 and Skyward Sword are two of my most hyped games at the moment.

NaveedLife

Wow you must have stupidly high standards then.

PS - why did you review Uncharted 2 at a 10 then? :?

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]Sorry, got that wrong, yeah he was fired for Kane and Lynch. There was still a huge uproar about the score here though, so my point still sort of stands. ChubbyGuy40

Wasn't the Twlight Princess score when System Wars warriors were out in full-force? :lol:

Uncharted because if the trend stays the next one will be a 10.

[QUOTE="funsohng"][QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]but Zelda still hasn't changed much over the years.Cheesehead9099

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"][QUOTE="funsohng"] [spoiler] [/spoiler] indeed.funsohng

Plus Uncharted series has just begun. If Sony decides to continue this series and in 5 years they haven't done anything big, then I will be pissed. But this is just the third game, and the MP looks vastly improved.

Also, I don't see how you can think that U1 to U2 wasn't a massive jump in quality.

When all is said and done, I guess it really is my opinion then. I won't keep arguing about something that we clearly think differently about.

Also, what I meant by "we're not talking about U3" was that I wasn't comparing the two games. I was simply saying that Zelda was a bit overrated. I guess the topic is about comparing, so it's my fault for that comment. I apologize for the confusion.

They'll both be great games anyways :P

stuff above my post

Cheesehead9099

So you think Uncharted 4 should be an FPS...or a horror game...or soemthing completely different? I don't want Zelda to change too much. They changed Metroid, and I would give anything for it to be back to its old self :P.

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

stuff above my post

NaveedLife

So you think Uncharted 4 should be an FPS...or a horror game...or soemthing completely different? I don't want Zelda to change too much. They changed Metroid, and I would give anything for it to be back to its old self :P.

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

stuff above my post

DarkLink77

So you think Uncharted 4 should be an FPS...or a horror game...or soemthing completely different? I don't want Zelda to change too much. They changed Metroid, and I would give anything for it to be back to its old self :P.

True, BUT those were the change to 3D. Just as Ocarina of Time and Mario 64 were from their 2D counterparts. THEN they changed it to Other M, which was fun, but the formula is downright broken and makes you wish you were playing Prime or Super.

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

stuff above my post

NaveedLife

So you think Uncharted 4 should be an FPS...or a horror game...or soemthing completely different? I don't want Zelda to change too much. They changed Metroid, and I would give anything for it to be back to its old self :P.

Alright, I understand that the games have improved and added features, but I really think that after so long they should make a big change to the core formula. you know, add something game-changing, not just new features or settings (like i said before, maybe voice acting). And for the record, I do NOT have anything against Zelda.

Plus Uncharted series has just begun. If Sony decides to continue this series and in 5 years they haven't done anything big, then I will be pissed. But this is just the third game, and the MP looks vastly improved.

Also, I don't see how you can think that U1 to U2 wasn't a massive jump in quality.

When all is said and done, I guess it really is my opinion then. I won't keep arguing about something that we clearly think differently about.

Also, what I meant by "we're not talking about U3" was that I wasn't comparing the two games. I was simply saying that Zelda was a bit overrated. I guess the topic is about comparing, so it's my fault for that comment. I apologize for the confusion.

They'll both be great games anyways :P

Cheesehead9099

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

stuff above my post

Cheesehead9099

So you think Uncharted 4 should be an FPS...or a horror game...or soemthing completely different? I don't want Zelda to change too much. They changed Metroid, and I would give anything for it to be back to its old self :P.

lol yeah I guess to each their own. After nearly 5 years I cannot wait for more Zelda fun, not something else. I own every Zelda game btw (except CD-i junk).

I don't think either will but Zelda deserves it more

Deus Ex Human Revolution says hello 8)

But if my choices are strictly limited to these two then SS. Uncharted is seriously overrated. Don't get me wrong UC is a great franchise but it's not GOTY. If anyone hasn't been paying attention to the updates, UC3's MP has been CODified. Perks that allow you to spawn with the last power weapon that killed you? Gun customization with scopes, sights and noobtubes? Going on a kill-streak makes the next time you die spawn with a power weapon? Yeah, UC3 will be that blockbuster thrill ride that people will want to play for just a few days or a week or so but Skyward Sword will be a lot more in-depth and hold more value in the long run.

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]Alright, I understand that the games have improved and added features, but I really think that after so long they should make a big change to the core formula. you know, add something game-changing, not just new features or settings (like i said before, maybe voice acting). And for the record, I do NOT have anything against Zelda.

Plus Uncharted series has just begun. If Sony decides to continue this series and in 5 years they haven't done anything big, then I will be pissed. But this is just the third game, and the MP looks vastly improved.

Also, I don't see how you can think that U1 to U2 wasn't a massive jump in quality.

When all is said and done, I guess it really is my opinion then. I won't keep arguing about something that we clearly think differently about.

Also, what I meant by "we're not talking about U3" was that I wasn't comparing the two games. I was simply saying that Zelda was a bit overrated. I guess the topic is about comparing, so it's my fault for that comment. I apologize for the confusion.

They'll both be great games anyways :P

funsohng

P.S. I love your sig :D. But I'm guessing Canucks in seven; Boston's too good at home. Thomas has gotten inside the Nucks' heads though, what with all the slashing and jeering. He's a damn coward :x

I dunno man, at this point you've thouroughly owned me I suppose. But I still don't feel as if....they're making the RIGHT changes? I dunno. It's hard to get my point across :P. I will still get the game and enjoy it, whether or not they take the risks I'm looking for.

P.S. I love your sig :D. But I'm guessing Canucks in seven; Boston's too good at home. Thomas has gotten inside the Nucks' heads though, what with all the slashing and jeering. He's a damn coward :x

Cheesehead9099

[QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

I dunno man, at this point you've thouroughly owned me I suppose. But I still don't feel as if....they're making the RIGHT changes? I dunno. It's hard to get my point across :P. I will still get the game and enjoy it, whether or not they take the risks I'm looking for.

P.S. I love your sig :D. But I'm guessing Canucks in seven; Boston's too good at home. Thomas has gotten inside the Nucks' heads though, what with all the slashing and jeering. He's a damn coward :x

funsohng

[QUOTE="funsohng"][QUOTE="Cheesehead9099"]

I dunno man, at this point you've thouroughly owned me I suppose. But I still don't feel as if....they're making the RIGHT changes? I dunno. It's hard to get my point across :P. I will still get the game and enjoy it, whether or not they take the risks I'm looking for.

P.S. I love your sig :D. But I'm guessing Canucks in seven; Boston's too good at home. Thomas has gotten inside the Nucks' heads though, what with all the slashing and jeering. He's a damn coward :x

Cheesehead9099

Every since TP Uncharted for sure

Every since TP Uncharted for sure

bri360

No idea what this is supposed to mean...

Uncharted 3. Wind Waker didn't get AAAAE for a reason.CleanPlayer

You mean to tell me UC3 would get the presitgious 10 over SS based off of looks? What about replay value? What about actual value? What about a story that makes sense? What about better and more challenging gameplay? Great cinematics win movie awards but it shouldn't win game awards.

[QUOTE="CleanPlayer"]Uncharted 3. Wind Waker didn't get AAAAE for a reason.commonfate

You mean to tell me UC3 would get the presitgious 10 over SS based off of looks? What about replay value? What about actual value? What about a story that makes sense? What about better and more challenging gameplay? Great cinematics win movie awards but it shouldn't win game awards.

[QUOTE="commonfate"]

[QUOTE="CleanPlayer"]Uncharted 3. Wind Waker didn't get AAAAE for a reason.CleanPlayer

You mean to tell me UC3 would get the presitgious 10 over SS based off of looks? What about replay value? What about actual value? What about a story that makes sense? What about better and more challenging gameplay? Great cinematics win movie awards but it shouldn't win game awards.

That's the only thing I feel like SS has going against it... The controls. Still it was specifically designed with the controller in mind so it shouldn't be some half-assed port like TP. Maybe, GS will give UC3 the GOTY because UC2 didn't get it and it kinda deserved it but 3D Zelda games are legendary for a reason.