Which game released on May that you think will score the highest here on GS?

A negative will be, "too good for a Wii game"Nuck81

I don't think any of these games will get a 9.5.

My predictions:

Alan Wake: 9.0.

Red Dead Redemption: For some reason, I find this one very hard to predict, but I'll go with 9.0.

Super Mario Galaxy 2: 9.0. It might be better than the original, but I'm pretty sure it'll score less for being "samey".

Modnation Racers: 8.5.

Lost Planet 2: 8.0.

3D Dot Heroes: 8.0.

I think Mario Galaxy 2 and Red Dead Redemption both have a good shot of scoring 9.0 or higher. Alan Wake should score a 9.0, but this is Gamespot and most likely they will score it 8.0 or 8.5 knowing them. Just like they gave Splinter Cell an 8.0 when most sites scored it a solid 9.0.

safe bet super mario galaxy 9.5. if RDR delivers whats advertised then that will probaly be a 9.5 as well. I want lost planet 2 the most though

Super Mario Galaxy 2.

Red dead redemption-9.5

Alan Wake-9

Super Mario Galaxy-9

I forsee 8.5's for SMG2, RDR and Alan Wake. So all three of those.

I forsee 8.5's for SMG2, RDR and Alan Wake. So all three of those.

foxhound_fox

Red Dead Redemption...hands down

and PW? remember it is on PSP, with lower standars than console gamesGiancar

Red Dead Redemption. Up against some stiff competition, but holy crap the game looks good.

[QUOTE="Nuck81"] A negative will be, "too good for a Wii game"blue_hazy_basic

im pretty sure the hd consoles would die for a mario game they are too awesome for any platform:)

Im going with Peace Walker. Im gona go ahead and say it now. This game will get no lower then a 9.5:P

[QUOTE="Giancar"]and PW? remember it is on PSP, with lower standars than console gamesfoxhound_fox

My money's on Red Dead Redemption.

I don't think any of these games will get a 9.5.

My predictions:

Alan Wake: 9.0.

Red Dead Redemption: For some reason, I find this one very hard to predict, but I'll go with 9.0.

Super Mario Galaxy 2: 9.0. It might be better than the original, but I'm pretty sure it'll score less for being "samey".

Modnation Racers: 8.5.

Lost Planet 2: 8.0.

3D Dot Heroes: 8.0.

GreySeal9

I suspect your predictions are spot-on. Except maybe 8.5 for Alan Wake.

Im gonna guess Justin Calvert will review RDR, and he is a huge GTA fanboy. Expect a 9.0 or 9.5 from there.

SMG2 probably a 8.5-9.0. So I guess Id go with RDR.

It will be Galaxy, mostly because everyone looks upon the Super Mario series with Rose colored glasses and doesn't realize the stagnant series hasn't evolved since Mario 64 essentially.

SemiMaster

Who knows?