Which game should have gotten a higher rating from GS?

Fallout, Red Dead Revolver, Doom 2

Uncharted

R&C:TOD

There are several other games that have recieved WTF? reviews/scores from GS in the last 2 years but I can only remember two.

Uncharted

R&C:TOD

There are several other games that have recieved WTF? reviews/scores from GS in the last 2 years but I can only remember two.

skektek

[QUOTE="skektek"]

Uncharted

R&C:TOD

There are several other games that have recieved WTF? reviews/scores from GS in the last 2 years but I can only remember two.

macca404

[QUOTE="macca404"]

[QUOTE="skektek"]

Uncharted

R&C:TOD

There are several other games that have recieved WTF? reviews/scores from GS in the last 2 years but I can only remember two.

princeofshapeir

Metal Gear Solid 1

Mario Kart 64

Demigod

Uncharted

Left 4 Dead

Metal Gear Solid 3 (8.7???? should have been 9.5)

Mount & Blade deserves a lot better than 6.0.

dsgsdfgf

• Fallout
• Fallout 2
• Deus Ex
• System Shock 2
• Arcanum
• Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

identity crysis...

ImaPirate0202

MGS1, Uncharted, R&C: Tools of Destruction, Mass Effect, Motorstorm, Resistance 1.

Audiosurf- dersrved at least an 8.5

Metroid prime 3-9.0

madworld-8.0

Left 4 Dead and Uncharted.

Yeah Metal Gear Solid would probably be my pick.

Left 4 Dead, anyone thats played it will agree that it deserved at least a 9.5, it has the best replayability this gen.godofwar2610

you gotta be kidding me maybe if it was a full game it did not feel like a full purchase

Tools of Destruction, Uncharted, and Crackdown come to mind.

Uncharted and Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction. Those two games along with other reason are why I think GS reviews are a joke and completely ignore them.

Team Fortress 2, especially considering how piss-poor the criticisms were like:

"Heavy reliance on other players can make or break the experience"

What are they expecting from a team-based shooter? This isn't called Me Fortress 2.

"Strategic depth can be daunting"

Daunting? They're so easily to learn and its quick to understand everything about each class.

"Price pushes boundaries of reasonability."

:| It had more content than L4D, a $50 dollar game on release, and TF2 is only $20. This was just a plain stupid thing to say.

Left 4 Dead, anyone thats played it will agree that it deserved at least a 9.5, it has the best replayability this gen.godofwar2610

uncharted and ratchet and clank: tools of distruction

ratchet and clank future tools of destruction. a 7.5??? seriously gamespot?

Left 4 Dead, anyone thats played it will agree that it deserved at least a 9.5, it has the best replayability this gen.godofwar2610

Fallout2, Shenmue2, Lost Odyssey, Demigod, Ratchet And Clank, Suikoden1 and Kameo.

But..... Team Fortress2 is up to aswell. Its the best onlien shooter this gen and a 10/10 for me personall (PC version of course).

Odin Sphere. Definitely. 7.6 doesn't do one of the best games of the generation justice... especially not for only just technical issues as a negative.

Thinking of this gen : Ratchet and Clank : ToD , Uncharted , Mass Effect , Killzone 2 and Resistence : FoM

Uncharted, rachet and clank:ToD, MGS1, GT1, legend of zelda: twilight princess

SMG, if the par for 10 was set at MGS4 and GTA4 then SMG should have hit 10, along with others but SMG is the best and most refined game this gen surrealnumber5

THIS!!!! SMG kicked serious ass! Aweasome soundtrack btw

Deus Ex, System Shock 2, Planescape: Torment, Lost Odyssey, Crackdown, Uncharted, etc. Oh, I want to add SMG, too. A perfect 10, imo.

1. Mass Effect. I don't care if it was glitchy, had framerate issues and texture pop in. As far as I'm concerned, Mass Effect deserves no less than a 9.

2. Crackdown. A 7.8? Seriously? :|

3. Mario Kart 64. That 6.4 score was a travesty.

4. Bomberman 64. This game deserved far better than a 4.6.

I'll add more when I think of them.

Mass Effect CrackdownPG_Chimp

I was going to say the same thing... Mass Effect was amazing, and Crackdown was way higher than a 7.8...

Probably

Ratchet and Clank: ToD - probably should have easily gotten an 8.5 at least

Uncharted 1 - This should have AT least gotten an 8.5

Twightlight Princess for Wii - 9.0 and editors choice

Mario Kart 64 - definitely too low

Diddy King Racing 64 - THIS GAME IS BETTER THAN MK64 NO DOUBT... It should have easily gotten a 9.0. If you think I'm an idiot for saying this you:

a) probably never played the game

b) probably never played through the story mode

c) probably never played the game in 2 player co-op (which was still challenging and fun as hell)

d) probably never played 4 person multiplayer modes in the game

The whole racing desing of the game was really great and the game definitely felt different from mario kart.

This a game you could probably still go back to and enjoy beating today...

Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

identity crysis...

ImaPirate0202

That was the biggest joke of a review ever, wtf was he thinking? I was going to say uncharted but atleast the review made legit points about the game and expressed why he didnt like some of it. For the ratchet and clank review i think he played a hour and called it quits.

Lost odyssey, Metal Gear solid, Mass effect and twilight princess.

Rayman 2, and Banjo Kazooie should have easily been 10's if games like GTA IV got 10....

Deus Ex, System Shock 2, Half-Life 2 (9.2 is not enough)

Madworld-7.5

too low IMO.

For mee..

R&C: TOD 8.5-9

Uncharted 9

COD4 9.5

Resident Evil 5 9

Mass Effect 9

Devil May Cry 4 8.5

MGS 9.5

MGS3 9.5

Shadow Of The Colossus 9-9.5

Resistance 9

Metroid Prime 3 9

LOZ: Twilight Princess 9-9.5

GOD OF WAR 1 and 2 9.5-10

Gears 2 9.5

Which game (in YOUR opinion) should have gotten a higher rating?

For me its MGS. It only got a 8.5!:(

Serously, MGS4 got a 10 but they give MGs a 8.5!:evil:

BTW,im new:)

ramealdabest

^Oops, I forgot to put the score I thought it should have received.

Madworld-8.5