Which game takes the Greatest Flop of All Time ( GS 2023 edition )

Starfield gotten positive scores, 88 on meta. truely a flop.

Starfield is the biggest flop since Jeff Gerstmann was still working for GS. Absolutely legendary.

Mid-field for sure.

Tons of Lems who won't show their faces today or ever come back at all because of this horrible news. Imagine how bad it would feel to hype a game for like 2 years only for it to be ANOTHER flop by a studio that cost 100 billion dollars.

It's so bad they are flooding the site causing errors, just so nobody else has to see that FLOP score 7.

Praying for the brave reviewer on here who stands up for truth. Lord knows these Lems are already trying to dox them.

Starfield is at least getting good scores, Redfall was widely panned.

Redfall is the only right answer, but far from the biggest flop of all time.

Between those 2 it's FlopField

But please put more in the poll. For those that remember Twilight princess is the biggest flop in GS history. The amount of suicide posts was utter craziness. To this day the sheep population has never been the same, heck after that they were just about wiped out.

Another locked thread for @daredevils2k.

Funny, you stated this "Shit. I hyped it as a 10."

Redfall without a doubt the way it was hyped by the Devs. It was a complete mess of a game.

Definitely a mega flop. This was supposed to be Bethesda's big comeback. It was also going to show that MS didn't waste billions of dollars.

Long story short. No comeback. And yes, MS wasted billions.

Damn its definitely close between Red Fall, Starfield and Cyberpunk.

@Pedro: I did lol. I truly thought I would see a 10 from Gamespot today. Bad-thesda and Microsoft let me down big time.

probably redfall or forspoken. Starfield has a 90 on MC, 94 on open critic. A fantastic game.

If you honestly believed that this game was going to receive 10/10 then, there isn't much to say.

@daredevils2k: In before the lock.

And, an 87/100 MC is not "the greatest flop of all time".

@Pedro: It was almost impossible to not get swept up in the hype here when posters are hyping it for years as "The Most Important Game Of This Generation"

I mean they were right,but not for the reason they wanted it to be 🤣

Ghost hyped Starfield, I generally consider him next to Champ the biggest gaming expert.

So when I heard Gamespot only gave it a 7 was shocked.

It seems like either payed off critics will say Zelda, or reality will happen, and BG3 will be GOTY.

Obviously Redfall of the two games. There have been bigger flops I think.

Redfall. My 88 meta prediction for Starfield holding strong.

@ghosts4ever:

Everyone knows Microsoft payed $$$ for some of those review scores.

I would say Starfield because it was hyped like it was the 2nd coming of jesus. I had a feeling the game would be shyt. Last Bathesda game i played was Fallout 4 and quit after 5 hours. They're just slow and the shooting is very awful

Probably Ghost of Tsushima or Days Gone?

No it's not because of bias Reviews from idiots like you Sony Fannies! Get real idiots!😆😆

@kathaariancode: you're taking this pretty hard today huh 😔🫂

@uitravioience: What?

@kathaariancode: I know man. It's best to just ignore it. I got you bro 🫂

It's still more ambitious than any overrated movie game from Sony! 😆

@uitravioience: I have no idea what are you talking about. Why did my post triggered you? Did you enjoyed those games? It's fine if you did.

@xhawk27: it's all good brother. C'mere man, it's alright I know today has been really tough for y'all. Get in here 🫂

@kathaariancode: I figured the extremely bad news about Starflop kind of has you a lil messed up. It's all good though. We all gone get through this.

@uitravioience: Yeah I told myself not to look at the reviews today! 😢

@xhawk27: I legit thought it was gonna get a 10 🤦

@uitravioience: I thought no less than a 9 but Sony spot sucks at reviews so who cares what they say! 😉

Ign and gamespot giving it a 7 but all the youtubers that arent tied to the corporations giving it a 10.

Can see this being another classic that mainstream media overlooked

What a failure. Wait til user reviews come in.

I am going to play it in three hours! 😊

Did you only look at IGN and Gamespot? Because every other critic has given it 9's and up bro.

@theam0g:

https://gamecritics.com/brad-gallaway/svg-special-episode-starfield-a-chat-review/

6.5

It's trash bruh. I'm offering hugs to any lem who needs one. Cmon in man 🫂

@uitravioience: I still have no idea what are you talking about.

@kathaariancode: it's ok.

This is the worst I have seen cows in 2023. I have seen meltdowns from them before, but this is their Meltdown 2023 of the Year for sure.

@kathaariancode: This you? "Wow, thanks uncle Phil for making a rare astronomical event just for Starfield's launch."

See. I knew you were feeling down today. Don't be mad at the cows. It's not their fault. Bring it in man. You'll feel better. 🫂

@uitravioience: I don't even know what to tell you, kinda feel embarrassed for you.

Do you really think I was attributing the happening of a cosmic event to Phil Spencer? How the hell Gamespot manages to attract so many weirdos?

Still don't know what exactly is your problem with me.

In other words you actually believed the game was 10/10 and now you want to blame others because someone told you it is not.😂

For the hype surrounding each game, easily 7field.

@Pedro: Pedro, I soooo wanted a brand new IP from Bethesda to snag a 10 here. Unfortunately they instead dropped a hot stinky 7 FLOP on us all 🤷

@kathaariancode: you're getting in your feels now guy. I have no problem with you. Just offering hugs to anyone who might feel down about Starflop. If you need a hug I got you bruh 🫂

So, you claimed to be swept up in the hype thus believing it is a 10/10 and then when someone you don't know told you it is a 7/10, it is a flop?😂 That is a very intriguing story.🙃

@Pedro: Pedro,I don't make the rules here sir!