Which game takes the Greatest Flop of All Time ( GS 2023 edition )

@kvallyx: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kTT0880lEsU&pp=ygUWbXV0YWhhciBsYXVnaCBvcmlnaW5hbA%3D%3D

(Not sure how to embed videos, but it’s Mutahar from SomeOrdinaryGamers laughing since I found your post hilarious)

@hardwenzen: I would love to be a fly on the wall when you and your hero had that discussion. You would both be so busy falling all over yourselves to be right, and get in the next word. I'm guessing it would devolve into guttural grunting and chest-beating within 10 minutes, tops. 😂

I never defended Redfall. I successfully defend Halo Infinite all the time.

There are *some* issues, it still is 88/86 on Metacritic. GS happened to give it the 2nd lowest score.

You're literally obsessed lol. You kinda remind me of Cringehog89 a little bit. Not expecting you to know who he is, but just know that you two are very similar.

It dropped 0.2 points? Bethesda fell off😥

@hardwenzen: "You're literally obsessed lol."

I said that to you 3 hours ago. Please form original thoughts, I'll get bored otherwise. 😴

No. I've noticed you obsession three days ago when you began quoting me with your walls. Then followed me here on SW. You're weird.

@hardwenzen: it must suck for you that you are in here defending Game Spot and its review of Starfield (while at the same time bashing Halo Infinite) when Game Spot gave Halo Infinite a 9/10, and the Master Chief is on display on the front page of the site because Halo Infinite is one of the "Best Xbox Game Pass Games" (along with titles like Grand Theft Auto).

It doesn't suck at all. If your Infinite was indeed a 9/10 like GS has stated, its multiplayer would be healthy, all the higher ups wouldn't be fired, half of the dev team wouldn't have been fired, appology letters wouldn't have been sent and you'd be hearing about the upcoming expansion packs to expand the story, you know, the game that was supposed to last for 10 years. Of course, these are the things you will try your best to ignore just so you could continue telling yourself that its 9/10 score is accurate.

How is Starfield a flop? The reviews are generally positive, and whilst I don't think it's anything spectacular, and even a step back from previous BGS games in some respects, it's not the dumpster fire that is Redfall.

@PernicioEnigma: Scored a low 7 here at gamespot. It flopped.

GS scored the single player and multiplayer separately.

Failed again, eh?

*It flopped "on GameSpot".

Like BOTH didn't have massive issues😆😆😆😆😆Like who are you trying to fool here, dabear? I know Infinite better than any of you lems.

@kvallyx said:

Another locked thread for @daredevils2k.

This post didn't age well. But I agree, its time for the mods to finally gift @kvallyx by closing this thread :)

@daredevils2k - I'm confused and I hate to be the grammar guy but this is bothering me:

Why not ask, "Which game takes greatest flop of the year (2023)"?

While that's still poor sentence structure, it makes sense enough. It's kinda strange that you would phrase the question as, "of all time" in one breath and in the next breath request people not actually consider "all time" but rather limit their answers to the current year ONLY, which fundamentally breaks the first half of the premise, no? If you're not actually asking about "all time" relevance, then why put it in the title at all?

You mean to either ask, "Which game takes the crown as the greatest flop of all-time?"

...or you ask, "Which game takes the crown as the greatest flop of the year (2023 edition)?"

...or maybe if you want to be extreme, you ask, "Were the biggest flops of the year (2023) actually the biggest flops of all-time?"

but it can't be all of them at once. That's not how English works.