Me, Infamous 2. It did not deserve a 7.5, it was better than 1.
What about you?
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Let's see, where do I start:
Infamous 2, deserved higher.
New Vegas, deserved higher.
Far Cry 2, deserved lower.
First Assassin's Creed, deserved lower.
Infamous 2 for sure, but Zelda Skyward Sword deserved at least a 9.0. It's probably the best Zelda game since Wind Waker.
mgs4 by a long shot
gtaiv i like it but not a 10
skyrim
duke nukem forever really wasnt that bad people.....
resident evil: orc ive never experienced the complaints people ever made. i just think the players that played it sucked ass
heavy rain
and the rest is to what rage quitter said
Nice to see you agree, I forgot to mention Skyrim, 9's and 10's for something that doesn't work, and about Duke Nukem, could you recomend it? I want to play it despite the reviews.mgs4 by a long shot
gtaiv i like it but not a 10
skyrim
duke nukem forever really wasnt that bad people.....
resident evil:orc ive never experienced the complaints people ever made. i just think the players that played it sucked ass
heavy rain
and the rest is to what rage quitter said
almasdeathchild
Nice to see you agree, I forgot to mention Skyrim, 9's and 10's for something that doesn't work, and about Duke Nukem, could you recomend it? I want to play it despite the reviews.yeah,i mean it's not uptodate but it certantly aint sh!t either i enjoyed it cause i don't hype things. and playing the multiplayer maps were fun too. i thought it was a solid 7.5-8[QUOTE="almasdeathchild"]
mgs4 by a long shot
gtaiv i like it but not a 10
skyrim
duke nukem forever really wasnt that bad people.....
resident evil:orc ive never experienced the complaints people ever made. i just think the players that played it sucked ass
heavy rain
and the rest is to what rage quitter said
RageQuitter69
Your talking about Gamespot right? Well DO realize Gamespot isnt the ONLY place and isnt the ONLY ONE to have reviews that should ONLY be taken for a reason to buy a game.
Nice to see you agree, I forgot to mention Skyrim, 9's and 10's for something that doesn't work, and about Duke Nukem, could you recomend it? I want to play it despite the reviews.yeah,i mean it's not uptodate but it certantly aint sh!t either i enjoyed it cause i don't hype things. and playing the multiplayer maps were fun too. i thought it was a solid 7.5-8 Sounds good to me, I will have to get it sometime, you saying it is not up to date actually sounds like a good thing because up to date games usually value story over gameplay.[QUOTE="RageQuitter69"]
[QUOTE="almasdeathchild"]
mgs4 by a long shot
gtaiv i like it but not a 10
skyrim
duke nukem forever really wasnt that bad people.....
resident evil:orc ive never experienced the complaints people ever made. i just think the players that played it sucked ass
heavy rain
and the rest is to what rage quitter said
almasdeathchild
GTA IV didn't deserve a 10 and Perfect Dark 0 didn't desrve a 9. GTA IV was more like a 9 and PD0 was more like a 7.5.
Yep,Infamous 2,the gamespot review was terrible.It was marked down for things that were in the first game which got a better score.Overall it was a slightly better game but scored worse.Made no sense at all.
Nice to see you agree, I forgot to mention Skyrim, 9's and 10's for something that doesn't work, and about Duke Nukem, could you recomend it? I want to play it despite the reviews. Skyrim works fine on 360 and PC.[QUOTE="almasdeathchild"]
mgs4 by a long shot
gtaiv i like it but not a 10
skyrim
duke nukem forever really wasnt that bad people.....
resident evil:orc ive never experienced the complaints people ever made. i just think the players that played it sucked ass
heavy rain
and the rest is to what rage quitter said
RageQuitter69
[QUOTE="RageQuitter69"]Nice to see you agree, I forgot to mention Skyrim, 9's and 10's for something that doesn't work, and about Duke Nukem, could you recomend it? I want to play it despite the reviews. Skyrim works fine on 360 and PC. I know it does, I was referring to the inferior PS3 version, I don't understand why critics rate PS3 versions of some games (The original Skate game for example) lower than the 360 versions when the PS3 version is perfectly fine but they don't rate the PS3 version of Skyrim lower than the 360 version.[QUOTE="almasdeathchild"]
mgs4 by a long shot
gtaiv i like it but not a 10
skyrim
duke nukem forever really wasnt that bad people.....
resident evil:orc ive never experienced the complaints people ever made. i just think the players that played it sucked ass
heavy rain
and the rest is to what rage quitter said
speedfreak48t5p
Scoring it in comparison to a PC is unfair? But I thought PC didn't have higher standards! :oThe one most glaring is the mugging Halo Wars got here. :P
SecretPolice
:twisted:
Journey deserves a 10, Lost Planet 2 deserves a 7, Dear Esther deserves a 10, Mirror's Edge deserves at least an 8.
Scoring it in comparison to a PC is unfair? But I thought PC didn't have higher standards! :o[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]
The one most glaring is the mugging Halo Wars got here. :P
blue_hazy_basic
:twisted:
Score it comparison with Wii since Wii has the same standards or so I've heard said here. :o :PFlight Simulator X. It received an 8.5 here at GS. It should've been at least a 9.0. What other game has longer legs? No other game has the sheer amount of DLC available for it which in many cases, cost more than the game itself.
inFamous 2 deserved at least an 8 or 8.5, but 7.5 is still "good", I just think it was a far better game than that.
GTA4 did not deserve a 10 maybe an 8.5
Duke Nukem did not deserve a 3. I played it, while far from perfect a 6.5 or 7 would have been the proper score, but it was Kevin V after all.
MGS4 was in no way a 10 game. Way to many flaws, and poor AI to be considered a perfect game. 8.5-9 maybe.
Those are all I can think of right now, but I'm sure there are more.
GTA IV and MGS IV getting 10's was a joke. Neither game deserved higher then a 9.0. This was just the tip of the iceberg though really. Most of the scores given by Gamespot were wrong and way off.Me, Infamous 2. It did not deserve a 7.5, it was better than 1.
What about you?
Second_Hokage
monster hunter series deserve to got higher scores and mgs4 ,gta4 wtf !!!! why did they got a 10????
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment