Who has the worst game library? PS3 or Wii

But then not all Final Fantasy games are made by the same developers.Eponique

And....you would not have played it?

isnt it sad that you're only interested because its mario? Doesnt that go to show that nintnedo seirously needs to branch from the same 3-4 formulae every gen?

JPOBS

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"]No, I was talking about Miyamoto and his creations...nintendofreak_2

[QUOTE="JPOBS"]Nintendo should have made mario galaxy with a different main character.

AgentA-Mi6

How about an overweight italian bus driver for example

[QUOTE="Eponique"]But then not all Final Fantasy games are made by the same developers.Vandalvideo

I think i speak for everyone of us when i say:

What the hell are you talking about?

[QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"][QUOTE="JPOBS"]Nintendo should have made mario galaxy with a different main character.
JPOBS

isnt it sad that you're only interested because its mario? Doesnt that go to show that nintnedo seirously needs to branch from the same 3-4 formulae every gen?

No, I would still play it. But people like you would call it uninspired, and uncreative junk. It's usually how you people talk.

[QUOTE="JPOBS"]And....you would not have played it?

isnt it sad that you're only interested because its mario? Doesnt that go to show that nintnedo seirously needs to branch from the same 3-4 formulae every gen?

nintendofreak_2

Is it a secret?Vandalvideo

[QUOTE="ball_of_air"][QUOTE="SuperMario_46"][QUOTE="AgentA-Mi6"]Motorstorm SUCKS?

Why?

SuperMario_46

Crappy gameplay and framerate, bad SP,plus i don't have access to online for the ps3 and not having offline Mp really makes it even suckier.

All I can do is :lol:

Why?

Do you deny that the SP suckz monkey A***, or the lame framerate of the game, or that there's no real valuefor me.

I bet you havent even payed the God DAMN GAME if you say its gameplay sucks and care for the framerate

[QUOTE="JPOBS"]

[QUOTE="nintendofreak_2"][QUOTE="JPOBS"]Nintendo should have made mario galaxy with a different main character.
Eponique

isnt it sad that you're only interested because its mario? Doesnt that go to show that nintnedo seirously needs to branch from the same 3-4 formulae every gen?

No, I would still play it. But people like you would call it uninspired, and uncreative junk. It's usually how you people talk.

[QUOTE="AgentA-Mi6"][QUOTE="JPOBS"]Nintendo should have made mario galaxy with a different main character.

JPOBS

How about an overweight italian bus driver for example

Like tennis , Racing or accountancy ?

I bet you havent even payed the God DAMN GAME if you say its gameplay sucks and care for the framerate

AgentA-Mi6

My opinion is not a fact you know?

The game sucked for me, it may be good for you but i just didn't like it

Happy?

why would we call it uninspired uncreative junk? JPOBS

Let me see....

You said the same thing about Mario sunshine, About Twilight princess and about MP3, why wouldn't you?

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="Eponique"]But then not all Final Fantasy games are made by the same developers.SuperMario_46

I think i speak for everyone of us when i say:

What the hell are you talking about?

3AAA's and 21 AA's > 2AAA and 8 AA. you cant possibly debate this. :|JPOBS

I could not possibly debate that 24 games is more then 10 games.. well i could, but lets not get into that :)

What i could debate, is that those games do not equal a better library for the ps3 compared with the wii. The number score is not all that matters, surely we can agree on that.

Oh, i'd also like to refer you to my gamerankings listing a couple of pages back.. i know system wars rules say only gamespots matter, but surely we can have a meaningful discussion about the worth of their libraries in the "real world". :D I like to point out gamerankings results just because some people actually believe that the number of AA's and AAA's equal the best library, and that because gamespot has given it more then it is better for sure!Not that i believe the number of AA and AAA equal the better system. By system wars rules that is one thing, i don't really know these well.. but in reality, it's not necissarily the case. NOTE: i'm not saying wii's library is better for sure, merely it's not inferior FOR A FACT as some have said. The ps3 could have a superior library, but the reason people seem to be giving for it are note right.

in terms of over-all: the Ps3

in terms of exclusives: Wii

Wii has Super Metroid!!!chicken008

Godly game.

[QUOTE="SuperMario_46"]

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="Eponique"]But then not all Final Fantasy games are made by the same developers.Vandalvideo

I think i speak for everyone of us when i say:

What the hell are you talking about?

Your not happy with the 5 he made in the last 4 years?

Um Warhawk is great and HS has got good reveiws to it hasnt even been reveiwed by GS so what the hell are you talking about. The Wii on the other hand is the home of more crap then any console in history. Polaris_choice

None of it as bad as the bad stuff on the PS3 or Xbox 360...

Your not happy with the 5 he made in the last 4 years? GundamGuy0

[QUOTE="JPOBS"]why would we call it uninspired uncreative junk? SuperMario_46

Let me see....

You said the same thing about Mario sunshine, About Twilight princess and about MP3, why wouldn't you?

[QUOTE="Polaris_choice"]Um Warhawk is great and HS has got good reveiws to it hasnt even been reveiwed by GS so what the hell are you talking about. The Wii on the other hand is the home of more crap then any console in history. GundamGuy0

None of it as bad as the bad stuff on the PS3 or Xbox 360...

You're joking, right?

Wii right now.

[QUOTE="JPOBS"]3AAA's and 21 AA's > 2AAA and 8 AA. you cant possibly debate this. :|blahzor

I could not possibly debate that 24 games is more then 10 games.. well i could, but lets not get into that :)

What i could debate, is that those games do not equal a better library for the ps3 compared with the wii. The number score is not all that matters, surely we can agree on that.

Oh, i'd also like to refer you to my gamerankings listing a couple of pages back.. i know system wars rules say only gamespots matter, but surely we can have a meaningful discussion about the worth of their libraries in the "real world". :D I like to point out gamerankings results just because some people actually believe that the number of AA's and AAA's equal the best library, and that because gamespot has given it more then it is better for sure!Not that i believe the number of AA and AAA equal the better system. By system wars rules that is one thing, i don't really know these well.. but in reality, it's not necissarily the case. NOTE: i'm not saying wii's library is better for sure, merely it's not inferior FOR A FACT as some have said. The ps3 could have a superior library, but the reason people seem to be giving for it are note right.

[QUOTE="GundamGuy0"]Your not happy with the 5 he made in the last 4 years? Vandalvideo

Then you're demanding too much from a person.

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="GundamGuy0"]Your not happy with the 5 he made in the last 4 years? Eponique

Then you're demanding too much from a person.

[Excuse me for not being content with the same old franchises.Vandalvideo

[QUOTE="Eponique"]

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="GundamGuy0"]Your not happy with the 5 he made in the last 4 years? Vandalvideo

Then you're demanding too much from a person.

I'd like to see a person making new franchises at the same rate.

I'd like to see a person making new franchises at the same rate.Eponique

[QUOTE="Eponique"]I'd like to see a person making new franchises at the same rate.Vandalvideo

Uhh okay. And I refuse to buy another Final Fantasy. So it's settled.

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="Eponique"]I'd like to see a person making new franchises at the same rate.Eponique

Uhh okay. And I refuse to buy another Final Fantasy. So it's settled.

[QUOTE="Eponique"]

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="Eponique"]I'd like to see a person making new franchises at the same rate.Vandalvideo

Uhh okay. And I refuse to buy another Final Fantasy. So it's settled.

God damn, back toSquare one.

God damn, back toSquare one.

Eponique

or the sake of arguement, what would the gamerankings numbers be exactly?
JPOBS

Sure no problem; i have no problem providing some of that info! (this is a list complied from games with at least 20 reviews)

PS3:

AAA: 1
Oblivion

AA: 14
Resistance (87.4)
Virtua Fighter 5 (87.1)
Ninja Gaiden Sigma (86.7)
Rainbow six vegas (85.9)
NBA Street Homecourt (83.9)
Warhawk (83.8 - note the reviews are still coming in i imagine! could rise!)
Fight Night Round 3 (83.5)
MotorStorm (82.8 )
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 07 (81.9)
Darkness (81.7)
NBA 2k7 (81.4)
Call of Duty 3 (81.0)
Virtua Tennis 3 (80.4)
NHL 2k7 (80.1)

A: 9
Marvel Ultimate Alliance (79.3)
Ridge Racer 7 (78.9)
Madden NFL 07 (77.9)
Tony Hawk's Project 8 (77.8 )
MLB 07: The Show (77.3)
Formula ONe Championship Edition (77.2)
Need for Speed Carbon (74.8 )
Godfather don's edition (72.9)
FEAR (72.5)

Total: 24

Wii

AAA: 3
LOZ: Twilight Princess (94.3)
Metroid Prime 3 Corruption (92.2 - reviews still to come in!)
Resident EVil 4 (91.2)

AA: 5
Super Paper Mario (86.1)
WarioWare: Smooth Moves (81.7)
Madden NFL 07 (81.6)
Mercury Meltdown Revolution (currently 80.8 )
Trauma Center: Second Opinion (80.3)

A: 20
Mario Strikers Charged (79.4)
Godfather Blackhand edition (77.2)
Wii Sports (76.6)
Rayman Raving Rabbids (76.5)
Elebits (75.4)
Excite Truck (75)
Marvel Ultimate Alliance (74.8 )
SSX Blur (74.0)
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 07 (73.5)
Metal SLug Anthology (73.4)
Super Swing Golf (73.2)
Super Monkey Ball: Banana Blitz (73.0)
Mortal Kombat: Armageddon (72.3)
DragonBall Z: Budokai tenkaichi 2 (72.0)
Prince of Persia Rival Swords (71.8 )
Sonic and the Secret Rings (71.3)
Kororinpa: Marble Mania (71.1)
Harry Potter and the order of the phoenix (71.0)
Scarface: The world is yours (70.8 )
Big Brain Academy Wii degree (70.1)

Total: 28

Flip a coin. Both platforms are lacking quality titles. Overall the PS3 probably have more favorable titles that everyone wants to play, but they lack quality exclusives. The Wii has probably the best exclusive titles right now, but most of their 3rd party titles are crap. So if you want quality exclusives right now, it would be the Wii with the best titles and PS with the worse. If you don't care about exclusives much, but want more decent games to play, the PS3 would be the way to go, with the Wii having unfavorable library.

This is why I have a XBox 360. ;)

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=25902136&page=1

The Ps3 doesn't have a single AAA exclusive.

Someone said something about Mario Galaxy having someone other than Mario...

What's the point of that? It's still the same game, just with a different character and story. If you want Nintendo to make a new franchise, don't suggest that that franchise be exactly the same as Mario.

Also, give Miyamoto a break damnit. He's made more famous franchises than any other developer out there, and he still is making new ones. Like Pikmin, Animal Crossing, and the one he's apparantly working on.

Am I the only who thinks that new characters don't always make installments feel new?crazyjames1080

Never did never will.

I voted PS3 because there are only 2 games I want to play on it currently (Warhawk and MotorStorm) which is the reason I have not purchased it!

[QUOTE="crazyjames1080"]Am I the only who thinks that new characters don't always make installments feel new?Eponique

Never did never will.

I don't see the problem. I mean.. platformers were never about the narrative so at the end of the day the characters are just skins.

Oblivion PS3 > Everything on Wii.

I know, you sheep played it on another system. :|

PS3 is far worse imo. Cows will list that it has more AA titles, but who cares when more than half of those AA titles are Sport games? Resistance isn't that amazing of an FPS, Warhawk is online only, I have Ninja Gaiden on my Xbox, and Oblivion on my PC. There is NO need for me to get a PS3 at all.

On the other hand, the Wii already has 2 classics from Zelda TP and Metroid Prime 3 (laugh at scores all you want, it wont change this). RE:4 I owned on my GameCube, so it's much like Ninja Gaiden on PS3, and Trauma Center is a lot of fun! Super Paper Mario is also great, but it doesn't take advantage of the Wii-mote. After that we get into WW, Wii Sports, and all the other stuff.

So, looking at my 2 options, I would EASILY take the Wii over the PS3.

The Wii has too many remakes , multiplats and kiddy games so I voted for it and moreover if we go by line up the Ps3 Obliterates the little white thing...AgentA-Mi6

sure keep telling yourself that nobody agrees with you i vote ps3 not enogh good AA or AAA exclusives.