Why???? Gametrailers???? Just why????

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjPKKF7TD_Y

Go to :49 to see why they loose so much cred. Hint :its Grid all over again but with Wolverine. How can you have xbox button controls on the PS3 half of the comparison?

Thoughts?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjPKKF7TD_Y

Go to :49 to see why they loose so much cred. Hint :its Grid all over again but with Wolverine. How can you have xbox button controls on the PS3 half of the comparison?

Thoughts?

De_Bears

lmao... that's a horrible mistake.verbalfilth

buh buh everyone is going after da pstriple1!!1! :cry:

Here's the comparison on the GT site:

http://www.gametrailers.com/player/48753.html

The buttons are right.

It was a mistake and they fixed it.. This stuff happens.

Please explain how this can be a mistake? The screens are split. If it isn't done intentionally then please explain the process for having side by side comparisons. Understand this issue cuts both ways, someone could have tried to compare the same video so the other system didn't look so bad, but it still calls to question their motive for doing this and their cred.

:lol: whats their excuse?xxThyLordxx

I hope that was a mistake. If they really done that just because they're petty fanboys, then that's really sad, who would risk their job and their employers reputation because of that?

[QUOTE="xxThyLordxx"]:lol: whats their excuse?HarlockJC

Here's the comparison on the GT site:

http://www.gametrailers.com/player/48753.html

The buttons are right.

IronBass

OK there was a mistake.....sure. I buy it. But how many other mistakes are out there without the tell-tale signs that they were comparing the screens from the same system. LOL

People use bullshots and videos to claim superiority around here. I use several sites to help me decide what version to buy, how can I trust Gametrailers?

OK there was a mistake.....sure. I buy it. But how many other mistakes are out there without the tell-tale signs that they were comparing the screens from the same system. LOL

People use bullshots and videos to claim superiority around here. I use several sites to help me decide what version to buy, how can I trust Gametrailers?

De_Bears

they changed it. when they realized their mistake, but it was too late. people had already downloaded it and put it on YouTube.xxThyLordxx

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjPKKF7TD_Y

Go to :49 to see why they loose so much cred. Hint :its Grid all over again but with Wolverine. How can you have xbox button controls on the PS3 half of the comparison?

Thoughts?

De_Bears

I never trusted Gametrailers after MGS4 was downscored for it's story. Also, Halo 3 getting a 9.8. It's a good game, but DAMN.

OK there was a mistake.....sure. I buy it. But how many other mistakes are out there without the tell-tale signs that they were comparing the screens from the same system. LOL

People use bullshots and videos to claim superiority around here. I use several sites to help me decide what version to buy, how can I trust Gametrailers?

[QUOTE="De_Bears"]

OK there was a mistake.....sure. I buy it. But how many other mistakes are out there without the tell-tale signs that they were comparing the screens from the same system. LOL

People use bullshots and videos to claim superiority around here. I use several sites to help me decide what version to buy, how can I trust Gametrailers?

HarlockJC

OK there was a mistake.....sure. I buy it. But how many other mistakes are out there without the tell-tale signs that they were comparing the screens from the same system. LOL

People use bullshots and videos to claim superiority around here. I use several sites to help me decide what version to buy, how can I trust Gametrailers?

[QUOTE="freeloader_101"][QUOTE="HarlockJC"] How many other things are out there without mistakes? It's easier to think of the errors over corrections. They are only human. Also you care about graphics way to much.IronBass

lulz ? just immediatly after couple of people download it and uploaded it on youtube :P .So much for "teh xcuzes"freeloader_101

[QUOTE="freeloader_101"]lulz ? just immediatly after couple of people download it and uploaded it on youtube :P .So much for "teh xcuzes"IronBass

I never trusted Gametrailers after MGS4 was downscored for it's story. Also, Halo 3 getting a 9.8. It's a good game, but DAMN.

Lethalhazard

Yea exactly and "teh xcuzes" :roll:freeloader_101

What exactly is the problem? Gametrailers messed up again and that just shows how unprofessional they are. I don't see how they put the PS3 in a negative light with that comparison even with the mistake.

What exactly is the problem? Gametrailers messed up again and that just shows how unprofessional they are. I don't see how they put the PS3 in a negative light with that comparison even with the mistake.

Archaic8

hmmm well some ppl are calling it mistake but how can it... i really doubt that they didnt see while editing it... it takes time to edit.. add sceens.. how could they have not noticed it..while working on it... not that i care about this..just asking..

How do you mistakenly do that.

hmmm well some ppl are calling it mistake but how can it... i really doubt that they didnt see while editing it... it takes time to edit.. add sceens.. how could they have not noticed it..while working on it... not that i care about this..just asking..

devious742

How do you mistakenly do that.

WhenPicklezFly

Why are you guy getting so pissy about a game that's not even exclusive on a site that has Geoff Keighly or whatever his name is as a host?

just to let you guys know the video editor at GT is bias for the 360 so dont be suprised i read a letter he wrote and it was bashing the ps3 to the high heavens. Look it up on google and you know why i dont trust gt at all.

I never trusted Gametrailers after MGS4 was downscored for it's story. Also, Halo 3 getting a 9.8. It's a good game, but DAMN.

Lethalhazard

Anyways, GT's reviews are the only ones I've ever cared about. Their scores always seem to fit my own image of the game. I don't know what to say about this so called "mistake" more then I hope it was just a mistake.

You're letting System Wars get to your head... Gametrailers isn't in the business to make console A or console B look bad by "cheating" like that. It was probably a mistake, even if that.DonPerian

[QUOTE="devious742"]

hmmm well some ppl are calling it mistake but how can it... i really doubt that they didnt see while editing it... it takes time to edit.. add sceens.. how could they have not noticed it..while working on it... not that i care about this..just asking..

navyguy21

How do you mistakenly do that.

WhenPicklezFly

hmm.. i dont own either console :!:.... only pc here :|

I'm big on video editing and it's an easy mistake to make. Especially when you have a lot of videos to make on a schedule like Gametrailers. And for people asking how this could be a mistake...wow. There are a number of ways this could happen. One way is poor organization of video clips can lead a X360 clip getting mixed in with the PS3 clips. I do think Gametrailers should quit it with these comparison videos though. But maybe they really need more people to come to their site.

[QUOTE="De_Bears"]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjPKKF7TD_Y

Go to :49 to see why they loose so much cred. Hint :its Grid all over again but with Wolverine. How can you have xbox button controls on the PS3 half of the comparison?

Thoughts?

TheGreatOutdoor

[QUOTE="TheGreatOutdoor"]

[QUOTE="De_Bears"]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NjPKKF7TD_Y

Go to :49 to see why they loose so much cred. Hint :its Grid all over again but with Wolverine. How can you have xbox button controls on the PS3 half of the comparison?

Thoughts?

SilverChimera

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="De_Bears"]

OK there was a mistake.....sure. I buy it. But how many other mistakes are out there without the tell-tale signs that they were comparing the screens from the same system. LOL

People use bullshots and videos to claim superiority around here. I use several sites to help me decide what version to buy, how can I trust Gametrailers?

freeloader_101

[QUOTE="xxThyLordxx"]:lol: whats their excuse?HarlockJC