Will Banjo outscore Ratchet and make another area where 360 is better then PS3?

Well first of all the guy who reviewed R&C did a crappy job at it. His reviews was just bad. Hell im pretty sure if banjo had a last gen game this banjo would get the same score as R&C did. In GS anyway. Im pretty sure he would have pooped all over SMG too.

Now first off I think the Wii is the best console for platformers.

Ratchet and Clank scored 7.5 so will Banjo: Nut and Bolts score higher then that? If so it would be another area where 360 is better then PS3 the platformer area. Even though 360 has Kameo that scored 8.7

Just look at the scores of some of the other games that can not be played on the other console. This is 360vs PS3. Only put games that have scores. This is how the other areas of gaming stack up-

Shooter- Halo 3 (9.5) Gears 1 (9.6) > RFoM (8.6) Haze (6.0) (360 wins)

Racers- Forza 2 (9.2) PGR4 (8.5) > Motorstorm (7.9) GT5P (7.5) (360 wins)

RTS- CnC3: Tib wars (8.7)> PS3 does not have any (360 wins)

JRPG-Lost ODyssey (7.5) > ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have already (360 wins)

WRPG-Mass Effect (8.5)> ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have (360 wins)

Fighting- DOA 4 (8.8 ) > Tekken 5 (8.3) (360 wins)

Stealth-360 does not have any that the ps3 does not already have that I could think of < MGS4 (10.0)

(PS3 wins)

So if Banjo scores higher then there will be no doubt at all the 360 has the better platformer games over the PS3. So do you think Banjo will score higher then Ratchet?

Edit-Forgot about LBP to late to add to the poll.So if you think LBP will be the best just post that you think it will score better.

rybe1025

What you just did is select single games that score better than the other and saying the system wins that genre because of one game thats better than another game.

I could say Resistance: (8.6)> Fear Files: (7.0)= PS3 Wins FPS Genre

hmmm, I can't tell if you're trying to ask a serious question or you're just trying to make yourself feel better.

hmm, I can't tell...

hmmm, I can't tell if you're trying to ask a serious question or you're just trying to make yourself feel better.

hmm, I can't tell...

RacoonusDoodus

The latter...

[QUOTE="rybe1025"]

Now first off I think the Wii is the best console for platformers.

Ratchet and Clank scored 7.5 so will Banjo: Nut and Bolts score higher then that? If so it would be another area where 360 is better then PS3 the platformer area. Even though 360 has Kameo that scored 8.7

Just look at the scores of some of the other games that can not be played on the other console. This is 360vs PS3. Only put games that have scores. This is how the other areas of gaming stack up-

Shooter- Halo 3 (9.5) Gears 1 (9.6) > RFoM (8.6) Haze (6.0) (360 wins)

Racers- Forza 2 (9.2) PGR4 (8.5) > Motorstorm (7.9) GT5P (7.5) (360 wins)

RTS- CnC3: Tib wars (8.7)> PS3 does not have any (360 wins)

JRPG-Lost ODyssey (7.5) > ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have already (360 wins)

WRPG-Mass Effect (8.5)> ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have (360 wins)

Fighting- DOA 4 (8.8 ) > Tekken 5 (8.3) (360 wins)

Stealth-360 does not have any that the ps3 does not already have that I could think of < MGS4 (10.0)

(PS3 wins)

So if Banjo scores higher then there will be no doubt at all the 360 has the better platformer games over the PS3. So do you think Banjo will score higher then Ratchet?

Edit-Forgot about LBP to late to add to the poll.So if you think LBP will be the best just post that you think it will score better.

spidadragon1

What you just did is select single games that score better than the other and saying the system wins that genre because of one game thats better than another game.

I could say Resistance: (8.6)> Fear Files: (7.0)= PS3 Wins FPS Genre

he picked highest scoring exclusives on each platform

[QUOTE="rybe1025"]

Now first off I think the Wii is the best console for platformers.

Ratchet and Clank scored 7.5 so will Banjo: Nut and Bolts score higher then that? If so it would be another area where 360 is better then PS3 the platformer area. Even though 360 has Kameo that scored 8.7

Just look at the scores of some of the other games that can not be played on the other console. This is 360vs PS3. Only put games that have scores. This is how the other areas of gaming stack up-

Shooter- Halo 3 (9.5) Gears 1 (9.6) > RFoM (8.6) Haze (6.0) (360 wins)

Racers- Forza 2 (9.2) PGR4 (8.5) > Motorstorm (7.9) GT5P (7.5) (360 wins)

RTS- CnC3: Tib wars (8.7)> PS3 does not have any (360 wins)

JRPG-Lost ODyssey (7.5) > ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have already (360 wins)

WRPG-Mass Effect (8.5)> ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have (360 wins)

Fighting- DOA 4 (8.8 ) > Tekken 5 (8.3) (360 wins)

Stealth-360 does not have any that the ps3 does not already have that I could think of < MGS4 (10.0)

(PS3 wins)

So if Banjo scores higher then there will be no doubt at all the 360 has the better platformer games over the PS3. So do you think Banjo will score higher then Ratchet?

Edit-Forgot about LBP to late to add to the poll.So if you think LBP will be the best just post that you think it will score better.

spidadragon1

What you just did is select single games that score better than the other and saying the system wins that genre because of one game thats better than another game.

I could say Resistance: (8.6)> Fear Files: (7.0)= PS3 Wins FPS Genre

What if R & C: Quest for Booty gets a better review than both of them?Itinerant_Voice

so far there are 25 fanboys who actually think banjo 3 won't beat that redicolous score that is 7.5 :lol:

this one is quite obvious.

so far there are 25 fanboys who actually think banjo 3 won't beat that redicolous score that is 7.5 :lol:

this one is quite obvious.

Cyberfairy

What's worse is, they cling to that 'we must change the SW rules pertaining to reviews' mantra, just for that game. They want to utiilze every other source for reviews because of R & C, use just GS for MGS4 and then go back to multiple sources for PSN's Siren. Talk about flip floping....

[QUOTE="VanHelsingBoA64"][QUOTE="rybe1025"]

JRPG-Lost ODyssey (7.5) > ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have already (360 wins)

rybe1025

Add Folklore. Scored a 7, but still.

Sony lists it as an RPG on the playstation store. You can level up and level up your folks, so its an RPG. And LBP is the platformer that should judge how well the PS3's platformers are.

Gamespot scores do not count on Gamerankings!! Try system wars. Ratchet got almost a 9 there.

And you are clearly a fanboy, yep no doubt about it, if you were a sheep thn you would be making one of those "List of wii games" threads right now.

Banjo bound to outscore R&C TOD.

The score that come got is by no means the quality of that title, that reviewer seriously needed to be fired for that pitiful review cause that game was far more enjoyable then Kameo, a title I might have you that got a freakin 8.7 or something around here.

And how is one game going to make the 360 better in platformers?

Yes as I think Banjo N&B is on track to get the highly coveted AAAE at GS and will be a instant classic.

I can't hardly wait until holiday 2008.

Yes as I think Banjo N&B is on track to get the highly coveted AAAE at GS and will be a instant classic.

I can't hardly wait until holiday 2008.

SecretPolice

It's possible. this is the only platformer that's going to have a full, true multiplayer, not some rushed added multiplayer.

in this genre im sorry but you just cant leave out the Wii just because it's not HD? mario galaxy is just the best platform game this gen by a mile and banjo will certainly not get close

[QUOTE="rybe1025"][QUOTE="dkhw"]

[QUOTE="MerisYaki"] For fighting, Dead or Alive 5 outscored the non-existant ps3 exclusive fighter.dkhw

Tekken 5...fanboy intelligence falls everyday.

DOA4 (8.8 ) > tekken 4 (8.3) ....360 wins

i detest both franchises, and they are nothing but glorified button mashers compared to Street Fighter or Virtual Fighter, but Tekken is the most overrated fighting franchise ever, and any, i mean ANY fighting game beats any tekken game.

1. no, little big planet would crush it anyway.

2. the only area that 360 beats the ps3 in my mind is the jrpgs.

i think killzone 2 and resistance 2 are better than halo 3 and gears

i think gt5 and motorstorm 2 beat any 360 racing game

fighting i think tekken 6 beats doa 4

wheres the tps area? mgs4, uncharted

wheres the action adventure are? uncharted, infamous, god of war 3

sorry, 360 does not beat ps3 in every category just because gamespot says so.

[QUOTE="Cyberfairy"]

so far there are 25 fanboys who actually think banjo 3 won't beat that redicolous score that is 7.5 :lol:

this one is quite obvious.

AlphaGamer469

What's worse is, they cling to that 'we must change the SW rules pertaining to reviews' mantra, just for that game. They want to utiilze every other source for reviews because of R & C, use just GS for MGS4 and then go back to multiple sources for PSN's Siren. Talk about flip floping....

says the lemmings when they continue to try and use other reviews against mgs4 :roll: talk about flip floping...

1. no, little big planet would crush it anyway.

2. the only area that 360 beats the ps3 in my mind is the jrpgs.

i think killzone 2 and resistance 2 are better than halo 3 and gears

i think gt5 and motorstorm 2 beat any 360 racing game

fighting i think tekken 6 beats doa 4

wheres the tps area? mgs4, uncharted

wheres the action adventure are? uncharted, infamous, god of war 3

sorry, 360 does not beat ps3 in every category just because gamespot says so.

_witenite_

I gave the stealth area to the PS3 with MGS4

Infamous and GoW3 are not even out so what is your point since there is not a review for them?

As far as action games. NG2 scored the same Uncharted or Heavenly Sword but Dead Rising scored higher then all 3 so 360 would win the Action area also. If you want to put MGS4 as a action game and not a Stealth game then PS3 still only wins one area. It would just win action and not stealth.

[QUOTE="_witenite_"]

1. no, little big planet would crush it anyway.

2. the only area that 360 beats the ps3 in my mind is the jrpgs.

i think killzone 2 and resistance 2 are better than halo 3 and gears

i think gt5 and motorstorm 2 beat any 360 racing game

fighting i think tekken 6 beats doa 4

wheres the tps area? mgs4, uncharted

wheres the action adventure are? uncharted, infamous, god of war 3

sorry, 360 does not beat ps3 in every category just because gamespot says so.

rybe1025

I gave the stealth area to the PS3 with MGS4

Infamous and GoW3 are not even out so what is your point since there is not a review for them?

As far as action games. NG2 scored the same Uncharted or Heavenly Sword but Dead Rising scored higher then all 3 so 360 would win the Action area also. If you want to put MGS4 as a action game and not a Stealth game then PS3 still only wins one area. It would just win action and not stealth.

oh god the irony. the reviewers still basically rate the games on how they like it, so how is their opinion any different from any one elses. and mgs4 is and stealth action game. it can be considered both.

Now first off I think the Wii is the best console for platformers.

Ratchet and Clank scored 7.5 so will Banjo: Nut and Bolts score higher then that? If so it would be another area where 360 is better then PS3 the platformer area. Even though 360 has Kameo that scored 8.7

Just look at the scores of some of the other games that can not be played on the other console. This is 360vs PS3. Only put games that have scores. This is how the other areas of gaming stack up-

Shooter- Halo 3 (9.5) Gears 1 (9.6) > RFoM (8.6) Haze (6.0) (360 wins)

Racers- Forza 2 (9.2) PGR4 (8.5) > Motorstorm (7.9) GT5P (7.5) (360 wins)

RTS- CnC3: Tib wars (8.7)> PS3 does not have any (360 wins)

JRPG-Lost ODyssey (7.5) > ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have already (360 wins)

WRPG-Mass Effect (8.5)> ps3 does not have any that the 360 does not have (360 wins)

Fighting- DOA 4 (8.8 ) > Tekken 5 (8.3) (360 wins)

Stealth-360 does not have any that the ps3 does not already have that I could think of < MGS4 (10.0)

(PS3 wins)

So if Banjo scores higher then there will be no doubt at all the 360 has the better platformer games over the PS3. So do you think Banjo will score higher then Ratchet?

Edit-Forgot about LBP to late to add to the poll.So if you think LBP will be the best just post that you think it will score better.

rybe1025

Your logic fails. DoA4> Tekken 5(ps2 game technically). Yet you compare lost oddyssey and say ps3 does not have any jrpgs. If we were going by your logic, Ps3 would be jrpg king cuz of the ps2 gen. You sure you're not a fanboy? o.0

have fun arguing for 2nd and 3rd place

nobody else cares

have fun arguing for 2nd and 3rd place

nobody else cares

mistervengeance

Another, you make it sound like the 360 is better than the Ps3. IamTehN00bness

In terms of games? it is. duh.

[QUOTE="IamTehN00bness"]Another, you make it sound like the 360 is better than the Ps3. Kratos_OMEGA

In terms of games? it is. duh.

not-for-long

[QUOTE="mistervengeance"]

have fun arguing for 2nd and 3rd place

nobody else cares

SecretPolice

KAMEO is allrady outscore R&C

Hmmm back to Gamespot scores already? Fanboy logic at its best.

Hmmm back to Gamespot scores already? Fanboy logic at its best.

sam280992

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"][QUOTE="mistervengeance"]

have fun arguing for 2nd and 3rd place

nobody else cares

Shinobishyguy

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="SecretPolice"][QUOTE="mistervengeance"]

have fun arguing for 2nd and 3rd place

nobody else cares

SecretPolice

Except that one is a 3-4 hour $15 XBLA game and the other a full $50 game. Huge difference.

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="SecretPolice"][QUOTE="mistervengeance"]

have fun arguing for 2nd and 3rd place

nobody else cares

SecretPolice

You are actually comparing a 5 hour downloadable game (which have different standard) to a fully fledged game like Mario?

Wow the Lemmings have become desperate.

[QUOTE="Jack_Bauer07"][QUOTE="SecretPolice"][QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="SecretPolice"][QUOTE="mistervengeance"]

have fun arguing for 2nd and 3rd place

nobody else cares

SecretPolice

Except that one is a 3-4 hour $15 XBLA game and the other a full $50 game. Huge difference.

It's ether 9.5 for all or 9.5 for none. Which shall it be ?

I was talking about the difference between Braid and SMG. I don't disagree that Banjo will be 9-9.5 worthy, just that comparing SMG and Braid is ridiculous.