Will Halo Reach be 360's first AAAAE ?

Do you think so ?

...No

I want it to be, but hey, ODST got a 9.0, anything can happen.:P

No.

it certainly has the best chance. the multiplayer seems to have delivered, if they tell a compelling story.........maybe.

Didn't Halo 3 get a 9.5 on here? Isn't that AAAAE?

Edit: Ooops nevermind got numbers mixed up :|

It has the best shot this year.racing1750

[QUOTE="racing1750"]It has the best shot this year.Silverbond

Resounding YES!

[QUOTE="racing1750"]It has the best shot this year.Silverbond

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="racing1750"]It has the best shot this year.Sollet

Certainly not a FPS.

[QUOTE="racing1750"]It has the best shot this year.Silverbond

enlighten me. the only other one I can even think of is alan wake.....but I highly doubt it will be the robust beast that reach is.

Among 360 exclusives, it has the best chance.

Which isn't saying much. I'm 100% sure it has AAA on lock though.

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="Silverbond"]I must disagree.

Silverbond

Certainly not a FPS.

genre matters? a good game can't come from FPS? :? that means I play no good games.

a good game can't come from FPS? :?

lespaul1919

Where did I say that?

If Bungie invests enough money into "marketing" then I am sure that Reach will get a 10.0 here even though it isn't really an impressive score anymore with the games GS has given it to.

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="Silverbond"]I must disagree.

Certainly not a FPS.

Maybe. Speculating at this point is useless though. No one here really knows. Everyone is just intuitively (or biasedly) pulling their answer out of thin air.

If Reach gets AAAAE then I vow to leave and never come back, or some other punishment of someone elses choosing. It will not happen, you have my word.

If it gets a 10...Jeez. It will be a bad bad day here in SW.

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="Silverbond"]I must disagree.

Silverbond

Certainly not a FPS.

you said it here.

I highly doubt it. I think Alan Wake has a chance, but that's a very slim one.

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="Sollet"] What do you think has then?lespaul1919

Certainly not a FPS.

you said it here.

Please tell me you don't mean Alan Wake.

We already know the multiplayer is going to be the best on consoles, but if campaign winds up being equally good? AAAAE is definitely possible. To those of you acting as though there isn't even a chance, consider that ODST got a 9.0. Yes, a 5 hour campaign and one new multiplayer mode got a 9.0.

http://downloads.bungie.net/videos/invasion_showdown.mov

winwinwinwinwinwinwinwinwinhwinwin.

Do you think so ?

Zensword

I honestly see this thread being twisted around by cows in the future.SpiritOfFire117

What don't they twist around?

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="Sollet"] What do you think has then?lespaul1919

Certainly not a FPS.

you said it here.

No, I didn't. I simply said that no FPS will get a 10 this year.

[QUOTE="SpiritOfFire117"]I honestly see this thread being twisted around by cows in the future.Phoenix534

What don't they twist around?

GOTY so far for me is ME2. Halo Reach won't beat ME2 so no. I

[QUOTE="lespaul1919"]

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

Certainly not a FPS.

Silverbond

you said it here.

No, I didn't. I simply said that no FPS will get a 10 this year.

has more of a chance than any other genre with reach.

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="lespaul1919"]

you said it here.

lespaul1919

No, I didn't. I simply said that no FPS will get a 10 this year.

has more of a chance than any other genre with reach.

And now we're talking in circles.

for it to get an AAAA the story has to be the best thing bungie has ever done.lawlessx

Seems to me that it's still Halo. A 9 or 9.5 is very likely but I don't think it's going to get a 10.Ace6301

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]for it to get an AAAA the story has to be the best thing bungie has ever done.rlake

Silverbond is correct.

It would be near impossible for an FPS to get a 10 these days. The genre right now is in it's oversaturation (like how JRPGs were last gen, platformers the gen before, beat em'ups and fighters before that) and it's always been the gen that games get outdated quickly. Standards are constantly changing, I just don't see an FPS getting it.

It's definitely my most anticipated game though, a Halo game that actually sound like it's going to be great. Been a long time since 2001.

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]for it to get an AAAA the story has to be the best thing bungie has ever done.rlake

I would argue that this is the 360's best chance for a AAAA this year, but that is not saying much. But hey, if a very niche game with long cutscenes that constantly break up the action can be considered a AAAA here, then I just don't know anything.

http://downloads.bungie.net/videos/invasion_showdown.mov

winwinwinwinwinwinwinwinwinhwinwin.

lespaul1919

[QUOTE="rlake"][QUOTE="lawlessx"]for it to get an AAAA the story has to be the best thing bungie has ever done.ThatGuyFromB4

Seems to me that it's still Halo.Ace6301

There's a reason it's called Halo: Reach

[QUOTE="rlake"][QUOTE="lawlessx"]for it to get an AAAA the story has to be the best thing bungie has ever done.lawlessx

[QUOTE="ThatGuyFromB4"]

[QUOTE="rlake"] which i don't know how they could do, seeing as it is a prequel and we already know what happens. rlake