X360 have 4 AAAE's this year (if gta iv EFLC will get AAA score )

we all know that GTA LAD is an AAA game if GS was review it, but now this game have

a secend chance to get an AAA score with gta iv episodes from liberty city, if the pack will be AAA, its proof that LAD is an AAA game.

and dont give me the "bu but its only DLC" becuse LAD is a 10h gameand thatslong then most of the full games that release this year (KZ2, HALO ODST, U2 and more).

so this year the 360 have 4 AAAE's:

HALO ODST
FORA 3
GTA IV LAD
GTA IV BOGT

thats not so bad after all

Nisim19

No, EFLC is one game (or two expansions) and it's not reviewed yet. Just admit defeat and look forward to 2010.

[QUOTE="Hahadouken"][QUOTE="aaronmullan"]

Lemmings are grasping for as many straws at they can this year. Counting both of the games in the GTA collection? Nah.

ZoomZoom2490

lol.....sony fanboys dont even try any more!!!!

[QUOTE="idontbeliveit"]

That's seriosuly grasping for straws man. Still though, it's not impressive that over half of the 360's AAAs this year come from expansions.

ZoomZoom2490

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"] i keep telling em that, but they dont listen. forza3 is the only aaae game this year so far, its a fact.Racer850

ok i get it.

HALO ODST FORA 3 Episodes from Liberty City L4D 2 thats 4 AAA games for the 360devilsoultaker2

L4D2 isn't rated yet.

At least you didn;t call it exclusive :P

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"][QUOTE="idontbeliveit"]

That's seriosuly grasping for straws man. Still though, it's not impressive that over half of the 360's AAAs this year come from expansions.

110million

HALO ODST FORA 3 Episodes from Liberty City L4D 2 thats 4 AAA games for the 360devilsoultaker2

We dont know GTA EfLC and L4D2 scores yet. Still yeah, they will probably get AAA

[QUOTE="ThePRAssassin"]

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]

Wait, what? You're counting GTA twice? BOGT is within Episodes from Liberty City--that is, if you're going to count LAD, since Gamespot isn't going to review LAD (it came out early 2009)

Stevo_the_gamer

Which is stupid. They reviewed Pinnacle Station, the atrocious DLC for Mass Effect.

HALO ODST FORA 3 Episodes from Liberty City L4D 2 thats 4 AAA games for the 360devilsoultaker2

[QUOTE="Hahadouken"][QUOTE="aaronmullan"]

Lemmings are grasping for as many straws at they can this year. Counting both of the games in the GTA collection? Nah.

comeonthehoops

so therefore it cant be viewed as two completely different gamesZoomZoom2490

[QUOTE="devilsoultaker2"]HALO ODST FORA 3 Episodes from Liberty City L4D 2 thats 4 AAA games for the 360ZoomZoom2490

Why are Cow's hated so much? I Find all fanboy's are equal.

Also, welcome To GS, LAD doesn't count in SW.

SolidTy

Because of their extraneous number.

Why are Cow's hated so much?

SolidTy

And posts.

[QUOTE="110million"][QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"] i keep telling em that, but they dont listen. forza3 is the only aaae game this year so far, its a fact.ZoomZoom2490

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

Why are Cow's hated so much?

mitu123

And posts.

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"][QUOTE="devilsoultaker2"]HALO ODST FORA 3 Episodes from Liberty City L4D 2 thats 4 AAA games for the 360comeonthehoops

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

Why are Cow's hated so much?

Hahadouken

And posts.

DLC's or expansion packs should not count towards the list of AAA games.

DLC's or expansion packs should not count towards the list of AAA games.

def_mode

DLC's or expansion packs should not count towards the list of AAA games.

def_mode

DLC's or expansion packs should not count towards the list of AAA games.

def_mode

DLC shouldn't count as a full retail game sorry. But both side will do anything to try and 1up each other, so they don't feel owned.

DLC shouldn't count as a full retail game sorry. But both side will do anything to try and 1up each other, so they don't feel owned.

2beers_in_hand

[QUOTE="def_mode"]

DLC's or expansion packs should not count towards the list of AAA games.

mitu123

[QUOTE="def_mode"]

DLC's or expansion packs should not count towards the list of AAA games.

comeonthehoops

Why are Cow's hated so much? I Find all fanboy's are equal.

Also, welcome To GS, LAD doesn't count in SW.

SolidTy

I haven't found lemmings complaining about the difference between 9.3 and 9.5 on GT, or signing petition pledging square enix to keep FFXIII exclusive, so while you can say that all fanboys are stupid, cows are definitely the worst

[QUOTE="2beers_in_hand"]

DLC shouldn't count as a full retail game sorry. But both side will do anything to try and 1up each other, so they don't feel owned.

Stevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

[QUOTE="def_mode"]

DLC's or expansion packs should not count towards the list of AAA games.

def_mode

"Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City delivers two games on one disc – the all-new episode The Ballad of Gay Tony and the first episode, The Lost and Damned – together on disc for the first time – for Xbox 360 for $US39.99 and will not require a copy of the original Grand Theft Auto IV to play."

Unless you count LAD seperate from the disc.

How can some lemms say that Halo3 ODST is Halo 4 and that the new GTA4 dlc is GTA5?

i just dont get it, is it the lack of new ip's and exclusives? maybe.

How can some lemms say that Halo3 ODST is Halo 4 and that the new GTA4 dlc is GTA5?

i just dont get it, is it the lack of new ip's and exclusives? maybe.

ZoomZoom2490

I don't remember Lems saying that.

How can some lemms say that Halo3 ODST is Halo 4 and that the new GTA4 dlc is GTA5?

i just dont get it, is it the lack of new ip's and exclusives? maybe.

[QUOTE="def_mode"][QUOTE="mitu123"] Please be specific, because half of the PC's AAAEs are expansion packs, look at the WOW expansions, LOL.

mitu123

"Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City delivers two games on one disc – the all-new episode The Ballad of Gay Tony and the first episode, The Lost and Damned – together on disc for the first time – for Xbox 360 for $US39.99 and will not require a copy of the original Grand Theft Auto IV to play."

Unless you count LAD seperate from the disc.

You are having a hard time understanding what I am trying to say. ODST is not a DLC of some sort, LAD is and it requires GTA4 to run. In my opinion it should not count towards the list of AAA. If you want them counted, in a different category, like in a DLC category but not in the level of full games. Lets say Ballad on Gay Tony got a 9.5 It does not automatically means Ballad of Gay Tony = Uncharted 2. That is not how games should be rated.def_mode

You must have missed Mitu's post, here just in case if you missed it:

Actually, you don't

"Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City delivers two games on one disc – the all-new episode The Ballad of Gay Tony and the first episode, The Lost and Damned – together on disc for the first time – for Xbox 360 for $US39.99 and will not require a copy of the original Grand Theft Auto IV to play."

Unless you count LAD seperate from the disc.

mitu123

Episodes from Liberty City counts whether you like it or not. It's a stand alone expansion, avaliable via retail, and holds more content than most full priced games. Exactly what I stated previously.

Whatever, in my opinion they shouldnt be rated but I dont care, its Gamespot's decisions. I am a big GTA4 fan but whatever.def_mode

Lemmings are grasping for as many straws at they can this year. Counting both of the games in the GTA collection? Nah.

aaronmullan

[QUOTE="def_mode"]You are having a hard time understanding what I am trying to say. ODST is not a DLC of some sort, LAD is and it requires GTA4 to run. In my opinion it should not count towards the list of AAA. If you want them counted, in a different category, like in a DLC category but not in the level of full games. Lets say Ballad on Gay Tony got a 9.5 It does not automatically means Ballad of Gay Tony = Uncharted 2. That is not how games should be rated.Stevo_the_gamer

You must have missed Mitu's post, here just in case if you missed it:

Actually, you don't

"Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City delivers two games on one disc – the all-new episode The Ballad of Gay Tony and the first episode, The Lost and Damned – together on disc for the first time – for Xbox 360 for $US39.99 and will not require a copy of the original Grand Theft Auto IV to play."

Unless you count LAD seperate from the disc.

mitu123

Episodes from Liberty City counts whether you like it or not. It's a stand alone expansion, avaliable via retail, and holds more content than most full priced games. Exactly what I stated previously.

Okay, I understand. They'll be great games but I do not think they'll get AAA.def_mode

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]

Lemmings are grasping for as many straws at they can this year. Counting both of the games in the GTA collection? Nah.

blackace

[QUOTE="def_mode"]Okay, I understand. They'll be great games but I do not think they'll get AAA.Stevo_the_gamer

Both of the games are on EFLC, I would imagine the would be counted as one game

LMAO. 3 on that list are expansions. kz2's campaign lasted 10 hours, but what made it a game, was the online. you cannot pass those as games, and the 360 failed horribly this year. and flopza? fantastic.... i can't wait to see the sales on that thing.... i bet they're horribly. probably lower than GT5P12345678ew

To everyone saying that EFLC should not count:

You do not need the GTA IV to play the game, so why should it not be counted?