@Mr-Kutaragi: the downsides far exceed your proposed benefits.. firstly, you're just totally fragmenting your experience rather than consolidating it, which is a step backwards.. having to fool around with two televisions, remote controls, and everything else is a far cry from having my media seamlessly integrated with my single device and augmented by some of the best voice control on the market today.. secondly, your theoretical solution hinges upon the idea that you can find a decent HDTV for $99 which is already a stretch.. My primary TV is a 1080p 52" Sony BRAVIA and even though I can snap TV and other media along side my gaming (which makes that TV media smaller), i'm only a single action away from bringing that content to fullscreen... so suggesting I settle for a crappy $99 TV instead of my full experience isn't appealing at all.. so for me, your "cheaper" argument falls flat right there..
but for the sake of argument, let's say we find a $99 HDTV, what about Netflix, Hulu, WatchESPN, and more?.. I can snap more than just live TV alongside my gaming with the Xbox One.. surely, you're not talking about a SmartTV for that price so you might as well throw the cost of a Roku box or something similar on top of that HDTV cost (which also means using yet another remote as well) or I guess it's time to break out the laptop too (which brings the total of devices being used to three)
Also you're forgetting about the gaming applications.. I can snap the Machinima app with my game and stream gaming walkthroughs, tips, and tricks while I play.. again, as mentioned earlier, I guess we might as well add the cost of a laptop, tablet, or smartphone to the mix (not to mention yet another device you have to juggle).. and even then, you'd still have to do a general search for videos for the game you're playing.. on the Xbox One, the Machinima app is contextual. Which means, if I'm playing Battlefield 4 and snap the app, it automatically brings up Battlefield 4 content.. if I'm playing Dead Rising 3, the app automatically loads Dead Rising 3 content..
This is the benefit of having integrated features instead of juggling two or three separate devices together to try and achieve a similar effect.. even if you do come close, you still fall short due to that fundamental separation.. gaming, live TV, media apps, gaming apps, and more are all tied together with one unified UI and can be navigated with one controller and/or with universal voice control.. your "solution" doesn't even compare..
this doesn't even mention the fact that no grown man wants to have two or more televisions sitting in his living room.. maybe if you're living in your mom's basement that would be acceptable but it would just look tacky and weird for nearly any normal adult..
and again, the idea that you're even suggesting this nonsense in the first place is kudos for the Xbox One's built-in multimedia capabilities.. Thanks again for the thumbs up..
Log in to comment