Games That You have Given a 10 Rating to?

I gave MGS4 a 9.8, so I rounded it to a 10 due to gamespot's rating system.

I gave Shadow of the Colossus a 9.9, and rounded that to a 10 also.

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
Chrono Trigger
Final Fantasy VII
Halo: Combat Evolved

I gave MGS3 a 10 :P

I still didn't rate most of my favorite games, but I think Zelda: A Link to the Past would score very high with me. Maybe a 10 as well. Now playing Mass Effect and really liking it, so maybe... but we will see later after finishing it.

Crysis: Maximum Edition 

Dead Space 

Dragon Age: Origins 

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare 

The Witcher: Enhanced Edition 

Brothers in Arms: Hell's Highway 

Mass Effect 2 

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

You give out 10s way too easliy.

I have given out 3:

MGS4

Braid

SMG2

I guess I should've listed mine to. :P

Fallout 3

GTA IV

Call of duty 4 Modern Warfare

Mass Effect 2

Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3

You give out 10s way too easliy.

stephenage

I never used to give 10 for any game few years ago, but recently i fall in love too easily with many games and give them very high score:P

Also all the games i listed weren't bad in any circumstances

I guess I should've listed mine to. :P

Fallout 3

GTA IV

Call of duty 4 Modern Warfare

Mass Effect 2

Tony Hawk Pro Skater 3

tntkng

Fallout 3: 8.0 (I want to give it less but I can see it has some merit)

GTA4: Maybe about the same. Horrendously overrated game.

CoD4: Haven't played enough to give it a score, but from the little I have played and my experience with other CoDs, an 8.5 would suffice for me.

ME2: Love the game but a 10 is too much for it, 9.5 for me. Has a few issues that hold it back.

THPS3: Im more of a 2 man :P, but yeah... Awesome game!

I've given out a lot actually, around 10 or so I believe, I don't mind giving out so many since I simply enjoyed all those games a whole lot.

Although I admit if I used a review system more specific than a 0.5 scale I probably could remove a few. 

Actually as I look at the games I gave a 10 I think if I shrinked things out and was very specific I would only give one game a 10, wihch would be The Legend of Zelda: Majoras Mask.

Interesting thoughts in this thread too. 

Although I admit if I used a review system more specific than a 0.5 scale I probably could remove a few. 

Shy_Guy_Red

0.1 scales are pointless. 

But it doesn't now.

[QUOTE="Shy_Guy_Red"]

Although I admit if I used a review system more specific than a 0.5 scale I probably could remove a few. 

nintendo_warrio

0.1 scales are pointless. 

This is true.

It used to!bugbag

It never has 

[QUOTE="Shy_Guy_Red"]

Although I admit if I used a review system more specific than a 0.5 scale I probably could remove a few. 

nintendo_warrio

0.1 scales are pointless. 

They are. 

oh my god, none.

I'm going to go give Unreal and SS2 tens.

[QUOTE="bugbag"]It used to!Shy_Guy_Red

It never has

It said 'perfect' under my ten rating at one point if I recall.

[QUOTE="Shy_Guy_Red"]

[QUOTE="bugbag"]It used to!bugbag

It never has

It said 'perfect' under my ten rating at one point if I recall.

It should never have meant that though I say, even if Gamespot said otherwise. :P 

oh my god, none.

 

I'm going to go give Unreal and SS2 tens.

MagUnreal

What about Killer 7 :(? 

[QUOTE="MagUnreal"]

oh my god, none.

 

I'm going to go give Unreal and SS2 tens.

nintendo_warrio

What about Killer 7 :(? 

Slap on the wrist for me! 

I will do.stephenage

I will heavenly smile when you do :D. 

[QUOTE="Shy_Guy_Red"]

Although I admit if I used a review system more specific than a 0.5 scale I probably could remove a few. 

nintendo_warrio

0.1 scales are pointless. 

[QUOTE="nintendo_warrio"][QUOTE="MagUnreal"]

oh my god, none.

 

I'm going to go give Unreal and SS2 tens.

MagUnreal

What about Killer 7 :(? 

Slap on the wrist for me! 

[QUOTE="MagUnreal"][QUOTE="nintendo_warrio"][QUOTE="MagUnreal"]

oh my god, none.

 

I'm going to go give Unreal and SS2 tens.

ebbderelict

What about Killer 7 :(? 

Slap on the wrist for me! 

the gamecube version runs really well. 

Deus Ex was the closest at 9.8 on the old rating system.ebbderelict

Interesting choice :P.

[QUOTE="ebbderelict"]Deus Ex was the closest at 9.8 on the old rating system.stephenage

Interesting choice :P.

I need to rate the Half Life's 9.0 and above. Half life 1 is a clear 10 though. 

[QUOTE="stephenage"]

[QUOTE="ebbderelict"]Deus Ex was the closest at 9.8 on the old rating system.MagUnreal

Interesting choice :P.

[QUOTE="ebbderelict"]Deus Ex was the closest at 9.8 on the old rating system.stephenage

Interesting choice :P.

AMAZING GAME!

Also, I just beat Killer7 and gave it a 10. 

Also, I just beat Killer7 and gave it a 10. 

nintendo_warrio

WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT THE ENDING. 

Mass Effect 2 is so good...Right now I would go 9.8, but I want to finish it first...bugbag

I liked the ending of ME 2.

Mass Effect 2 is so good...Right now I would go 9.8, but I want to finish it first...bugbag

But you're playing it wrong :(. Also don't talk score until you've beaten said said game... especially if its something as meaningless as 9.8.

[QUOTE="bugbag"]Mass Effect 2 is so good...Right now I would go 9.8, but I want to finish it first...stephenage

But you're playing it wrong :(. Also don't talk score until you've beaten said said game... especially if its something as meaningless as 9.8.

I don't comment when someone play in the way they like.siddarthshetty

Then why did you just comment? :P