Yay or Nay, they ruined the following people by giving them gimmicks

Crash Holly and his Jailbird/Mad gimmick YAY
Kane and his more humane gimmick YAY
JBL and his rich man gimmick NAY
Dvon Dudley with the reverend gimmick.YAY

ssj4josh

Crash Holly and his Jailbird/Mad gimmick YAY
Kane and his more humane gimmick YAY
JBL and his rich man gimmick YAY
Dvon Dudley with the reverend gimmick.YAY

Dark_Hylian8

Whos says YaY or Nay anymoreeugene05

us and u just did

JBL and his rich man gimmick

How could JBL be on a list of people ruined by a gimmick? This gimmick MADE JBL, he's improved immensely since he's gotten it. He shuoldn't have been pushed to the top so quickly because of it though.

Now gimmicks that really ruined people would be Terry Taylor when he became the Red Rooster and the mother of all gimmicks that ruined someone's career is the SHOCKMASTER.

Crash Holly and his Jailbird/Mad gimmick YAY
Kane and his more humane gimmick YAY
JBL and his rich man gimmick NAY
Dvon Dudley with the reverend gimmick.YAY

superman2412

[QUOTE="superman2412"]Crash Holly and his Jailbird/Mad gimmick YAY
Kane and his more humane gimmick YAY
JBL and his rich man gimmick NAY
Dvon Dudley with the reverend gimmick.YAY

Link-from-Hell

dont only put in the quote box i think its considered spam

Nova and his fitness guru gimmick. YAY

i think Kerwin White destroyed Chavo's wrestling careerDark_Hylian8

um, chavo ruined chavo's career

friends don't let friends get crappy gimmicks

ME

[QUOTE="Dark_Hylian8"]i think Kerwin White destroyed Chavo's wrestling careersephy37

um, chavo ruined chavo's career

friends don't let friends get crappy gimmicks

ME

[QUOTE="Dark_Hylian8"]i think Kerwin White destroyed Chavo's wrestling careersephy37

um, chavo ruined chavo's career

friends don't let friends get crappy gimmicks

ME

What the hell would you have told Chavo to do? If Chavo says "no" to the gimmick, he'd probably be fired by now. Right now he's stuck in a crappy gimmick, but he's still pulling in a paycheck, thats more than Kidman, Akio, or Haas could say.

The wrestlers don't have a choice, these days. They can either take whatever crap the Creative geniuses give them and try their best to make it work, or they can get fired and go back to making significantly less money in TNA and the Indies.

[QUOTE="sephy37"]

[QUOTE="Dark_Hylian8"]i think Kerwin White destroyed Chavo's wrestling careerThe_Dude14

um, chavo ruined chavo's career

friends don't let friends get crappy gimmicks

ME

What the hell would you have told Chavo to do? If Chavo says "no" to the gimmick, he'd probably be fired by now. Right now he's stuck in a crappy gimmick, but he's still pulling in a paycheck, thats more than Kidman, Akio, or Haas could say.

The wrestlers don't have a choice, these days. They can either take whatever crap the Creative geniuses give them and try their best to make it work, or they can get fired and go back to making significantly less money in TNA and the Indies.

[QUOTE="The_Dude14"][QUOTE="sephy37"]

[QUOTE="Dark_Hylian8"]i think Kerwin White destroyed Chavo's wrestling careerSwimPUNK

um, chavo ruined chavo's career

friends don't let friends get crappy gimmicks

ME

What the hell would you have told Chavo to do? If Chavo says "no" to the gimmick, he'd probably be fired by now. Right now he's stuck in a crappy gimmick, but he's still pulling in a paycheck, thats more than Kidman, Akio, or Haas could say.

The wrestlers don't have a choice, these days. They can either take whatever crap the Creative geniuses give them and try their best to make it work, or they can get fired and go back to making significantly less money in TNA and the Indies.

dude wow, that was a joke. u guys are taking it too seriously.

...but seriously, friends don't let friends drink and drive.

[QUOTE="SwimPUNK"][QUOTE="The_Dude14"][QUOTE="sephy37"]

[QUOTE="Dark_Hylian8"]i think Kerwin White destroyed Chavo's wrestling careersephy37

um, chavo ruined chavo's career

friends don't let friends get crappy gimmicks

ME

What the hell would you have told Chavo to do? If Chavo says "no" to the gimmick, he'd probably be fired by now. Right now he's stuck in a crappy gimmick, but he's still pulling in a paycheck, thats more than Kidman, Akio, or Haas could say.

The wrestlers don't have a choice, these days. They can either take whatever crap the Creative geniuses give them and try their best to make it work, or they can get fired and go back to making significantly less money in TNA and the Indies.

dude wow, that was a joke. u guys are taking it too seriously.

...but seriously, friends don't let friends drink and drive.

[QUOTE="sephy37"][QUOTE="SwimPUNK"][QUOTE="The_Dude14"][QUOTE="sephy37"]

[QUOTE="Dark_Hylian8"]i think Kerwin White destroyed Chavo's wrestling careerThe_Dude14

um, chavo ruined chavo's career

friends don't let friends get crappy gimmicks

ME

What the hell would you have told Chavo to do? If Chavo says "no" to the gimmick, he'd probably be fired by now. Right now he's stuck in a crappy gimmick, but he's still pulling in a paycheck, thats more than Kidman, Akio, or Haas could say.

The wrestlers don't have a choice, these days. They can either take whatever crap the Creative geniuses give them and try their best to make it work, or they can get fired and go back to making significantly less money in TNA and the Indies.

dude wow, that was a joke. u guys are taking it too seriously.

...but seriously, friends don't let friends drink and drive.

friends don't let friends miss punchlines

[QUOTE="sephy37"]

dude wow, that was a joke. u guys are taking it too seriously.

...but seriously, friends don't let friends drink and drive.

The_Dude14

[QUOTE="The_Dude14"][QUOTE="sephy37"]

dude wow, that was a joke. u guys are taking it too seriously.

...but seriously, friends don't let friends drink and drive.

SwimPUNK

friends don't let friends quote more often then they should and then reply with only two words and 2 periods.......:|

[QUOTE="SwimPUNK"][QUOTE="The_Dude14"][QUOTE="sephy37"]

dude wow, that was a joke. u guys are taking it too seriously.

...but seriously, friends don't let friends drink and drive.

sephy37

friends don't let friends quote more often then they should and then reply with only two words and 2 periods.......:|

[QUOTE="sephy37"][QUOTE="SwimPUNK"][QUOTE="The_Dude14"][QUOTE="sephy37"]

dude wow, that was a joke. u guys are taking it too seriously.

...but seriously, friends don't let friends drink and drive.

SwimPUNK

friends don't let friends quote more often then they should and then reply with only two words and 2 periods.......:|

friends don't let friends be friends with The_Dude....oh wait, he's my friend too :cry:

Crash Holly and his Jailbird/Mad gimmick- Never heard of it {Seriously}
Kane and his more humane gimmick- YAY- After Kane took of his mask his career went completely down hill in my opinion. The whole Mask/Not talking/ Mysterious thing was the reason Kane had fans
JBL and his rich man gimmick-NAY- Without this Gimmick JBL would of probably been fired like his partner in the A.P.A. The whole rich thing made his career go sky high. The only problem I have with it is his gimmick is basically Triple H gimmick. WWE need to be more Original.
Dvon Dudley with the reverend gimmick.- I didnt really care. i never pay much attention to the Dudley Boyz. Tag Team or Solo.