360 on SD RP vs HD

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for obsolete2k1
obsolete2k1

990

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#1 obsolete2k1
Member since 2007 • 990 Posts
Well I am upgrading my tv set, I just sold my old 46" Sony rear projection tv, which was basically a 600lbs cube. Now I am looking at gettingeither a 42" Samsungplasma or a 46" Samsung dlp. They are both native 720p, so will 1080i do anything for me on the size of screen that they are? While both have a "game mode" whichwould you suggest?
Avatar image for TimothyB
TimothyB

6564

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#2 TimothyB
Member since 2003 • 6564 Posts

Well I am upgrading my tv set, I just sold my old 46" Sony rear projection tv, which was basically a 600lbs cube. Now I am looking at gettingeither a 42" Samsungplasma or a 46" Samsung dlp. They are both native 720p, so will 1080i do anything for me on the size of screen that they are? While both have a "game mode" whichwould you suggest?obsolete2k1

Well, 1080i at that size wouldn't be much, especially since that means getting a CRT again to display 1080i. 720p is fine at that size if you are sitting like 6-8 feet away. You wouldn't pick 1080i since like you said, they are 720p tvs.

Game mode isn't needed too often with current tvs, and all it does is remove enhancements to get the video to the screen faster. But nice that it's there.

A 42inch Plasma? Are you sure it's full 1280*720 to meet 720p, a lot of them are 1024*768 at that size, sure it has enough horizontal lines to do 720, but you can't call it full 720p. I'd find gamers with the same screen to find out if burn-in is an issue, how good the blacks are.

DLP, if it's a slim thin model, make sure it has no pin cushioning (doesn't need to be slim and is where the picture bows in on the sides) or distortion around the corners being a slim model a curved mirror. You might see rainbows from DLP. And a lot more can go wrong with a DLP, like the bulb, spinning color wheel. And just replacing the bulb every 3 years for $200+ might no be to your liking. And it's important to get a warranty more with a rear projection, as again, so much can go wrong.

Check out the model numbers you are looking at at AVSForum.com, there's probably tons of info and questions there.

Avatar image for sldroftroy
sldroftroy

153

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#3 sldroftroy
Member since 2004 • 153 Posts
I've got a 46" Samsung DLP and love it. I purchased it in December of 2006 and haven't had any problems w/ it at all (knock on wood of course). TimothyB is correct though, all those things he mentioned are possibilities. You've just got to do your research and decide for yourself... I can tell you I've been told over and over that Plasma isn't the best choice for gaming if you can go w/ LCD or DLP.
Avatar image for Alpha172
Alpha172

1437

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 9

User Lists: 0

#4 Alpha172
Member since 2007 • 1437 Posts

Well I am upgrading my tv set, I just sold my old 46" Sony rear projection tv, which was basically a 600lbs cube. Now I am looking at gettingeither a 42" Samsungplasma or a 46" Samsung dlp. They are both native 720p, so will 1080i do anything for me on the size of screen that they are? While both have a "game mode" whichwould you suggest?obsolete2k1


If they both support 720p and 1080i then you should go for thedesign and colour.

Avatar image for fathertroy
fathertroy

1309

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 0

#5 fathertroy
Member since 2006 • 1309 Posts

[QUOTE="obsolete2k1"]Well I am upgrading my tv set, I just sold my old 46" Sony rear projection tv, which was basically a 600lbs cube. Now I am looking at gettingeither a 42" Samsungplasma or a 46" Samsung dlp. They are both native 720p, so will 1080i do anything for me on the size of screen that they are? While both have a "game mode" whichwould you suggest?Alpha172



If they both support 720p and 1080i then you should go for thedesign and colour.

ya

Avatar image for obsolete2k1
obsolete2k1

990

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#6 obsolete2k1
Member since 2007 • 990 Posts
I've looked all over the different tech sites and both tvs have very good reviews. As for the plasma, I'm not that concerned about burn in as i'm just a casual gamer, but some ppl say yah, others nay regarding gaming on a plasma. As for the plasma, all of the sites say that it is 720p, I will check the rez though, I agree that it may not be native 720p.