GTA IV 360 disc image. Real or fake?

[QUOTE="RoslindaleOne"]If this is fake it's by far the best I've ever seen.whodeysay85

[QUOTE="whodeysay85"][QUOTE="RoslindaleOne"]If this is fake it's by far the best I've ever seen.GnR-SLaSh

Agreed

[QUOTE="Vic_Vega1994"]Its fake. Why would you have the face over the holeclyde46

I dont see how you can say its fake just because the hole for the spindle covers her face.

I can lol, its poor design

[QUOTE="clyde46"]

[QUOTE="Vic_Vega1994"]Its fake. Why would you have the face over the holeNOD_Grindking

I dont see how you can say its fake just because the hole for the spindle covers her face.

I can lol, its poor design

agreed, whats the point in having her as an image if u cant even see her.

here are my two Mass Effect discs. As you can see M$ has put some sort of reflective ring around the spindle hole. Exactly the same as the disc here.

clyde46

Your point being what? That doesn't mean it is 100% real....anybody can duplicate that.....from the angle of the GTA 4 disc is at, you can't tell if its made of that shiny material....

i think its fake

[QUOTE="NOD_Grindking"][QUOTE="clyde46"]here are my two Mass Effect discs. As you can see M$ has put some sort of reflective ring around the spindle hole. Exactly the same as the disc here.

clyde46

Your point being what? That doesn't mean it is 100% real....anybody can duplicate that.....from the angle of the GTA 4 disc is at, you can't tell if its made of that shiny material....

Are you sure you are seeing the same disc as me? I can clearly see the XBOX logo in the reflective ring around the spindle hole.

heres my theory....its a real 360 dics with a fake image overtop.....so for example, he took a mass effect disc and put the GTA skin overtop, that way it still has the 360 reflective ring

[QUOTE="NOD_Grindking"][QUOTE="clyde46"][QUOTE="NOD_Grindking"][QUOTE="clyde46"]here are my two Mass Effect discs. (pic) As you can see M$ has put some sort of reflective ring around the spindle hole. Exactly the same as the disc here. (pic)

clyde46

Your point being what? That doesn't mean it is 100% real....anybody can duplicate that.....from the angle of the GTA 4 disc is at, you can't tell if its made of that shiny material....

Are you sure you are seeing the same disc as me? I can clearly see the XBOX logo in the reflective ring around the spindle hole.

heres my theory....its a real 360 dics with a fake image overtop.....so for example, he took a mass effect disc and put the GTA skin overtop, that way it still has the 360 reflective ring

Then if it was faked, why go to all the trouble of putting all the small text around the edge of the disc and the "Do not make illegal copies of the game" in?

to trick people into thinking you have the first leaked copy of one of the most anticipated video games of all time?

Then if it was faked, why go to all the trouble of putting all the small text around the edge of the disc and the "Do not make illegal copies of the game" in?

clyde46

to trick people into thinking you have the first leaked copy of one of the most anticipated video games of all time?

if it didn't have the legal notices on it, then it would be OBVIOUS that it was A FAKE

[QUOTE="NOD_Grindking"]

[QUOTE="destinhpark"]Look legit to me.JetSpiderMan

the pic definetly looks real....but i don't know, the way the face is almost totally cut off with the disc hole makes me wonder if its legit......why would they position it so stupidly?

maybe they think that some uber dork will put there uber sized thing in there.......

Like he said, so someone will stick their thing in her "mouth"

but no really, you guys are observant. Both the home made label theory and the stupid design of covering her face seem like plausible explanations as to it being fake versus real.

[QUOTE="JetSpiderMan"][QUOTE="NOD_Grindking"]

[QUOTE="destinhpark"]Look legit to me.xboxfreak1

the pic definetly looks real....but i don't know, the way the face is almost totally cut off with the disc hole makes me wonder if its legit......why would they position it so stupidly?

maybe they think that some uber dork will put there uber sized thing in there.......

Like he said, so someone will stick their thing in her "mouth"

but no really, you guys are observant. Both the home made label theory and the stupid design of covering her face seem like plausible explanations as to it being fake versus real.

Its only covering her face due to the reflective ring that M$ puts on its games. The ps3 disc has the same design but no reflective ring.

[QUOTE="xboxfreak1"][QUOTE="JetSpiderMan"][QUOTE="NOD_Grindking"]

[QUOTE="destinhpark"]Look legit to me.clyde46

the pic definetly looks real....but i don't know, the way the face is almost totally cut off with the disc hole makes me wonder if its legit......why would they position it so stupidly?

maybe they think that some uber dork will put there uber sized thing in there.......

Like he said, so someone will stick their thing in her "mouth"

but no really, you guys are observant. Both the home made label theory and the stupid design of covering her face seem like plausible explanations as to it being fake versus real.

Its only covering her face due to the reflective ring that M$ puts on its games. The ps3 disc has the same design but no reflective ring.

ya but obviously Rockstar would know that the ring is going to be there, so why would they leave it like that?

[QUOTE="clyde46"][QUOTE="xboxfreak1"][QUOTE="JetSpiderMan"][QUOTE="NOD_Grindking"]

[QUOTE="destinhpark"]Look legit to me.NOD_Grindking

the pic definetly looks real....but i don't know, the way the face is almost totally cut off with the disc hole makes me wonder if its legit......why would they position it so stupidly?

maybe they think that some uber dork will put there uber sized thing in there.......

Like he said, so someone will stick their thing in her "mouth"

but no really, you guys are observant. Both the home made label theory and the stupid design of covering her face seem like plausible explanations as to it being fake versus real.

Its only covering her face due to the reflective ring that M$ puts on its games. The ps3 disc has the same design but no reflective ring.

ya but obviously Rockstar would know that the ring is going to be there, so why would they leave it like that?

Since the game is on both PS3 and 360, Rockstar have used the same disc cover. M$ just happenes to require a reflective for the 360 version.

[QUOTE="clyde46"]Alright for all those who think its fake. Look very carefully at both the 360 version and ps3 version. Look around the edges, you shouldn't seen any overlap or peeling. When someone copies a cover it doesnt fit correctly onto the disc. These are legit because there is no overlap, the covers are machine cut and machine stuck down with no bumps.They include all the legal text and aswell as an ESRB or whatever rating. Just because the 360 version has a reflective ring that covers up are face doesnt mean its bad desgin. Its being shipped on BOTH the 360 AND the ps3, thus the disc's look the same.NOD_Grindking

no but your wrong....THERE IS overlap....look at the TOP of the 360 disc, to the right....see that? thats blank disc, because the label is not positioned correctly....it is quite obviously noticable

Well I'm currently looking at my C&C3 disc from a simular angle to the camera taking the shot of the 360 disc and it appears the same as disc shown.

i dont think its real because on the disc they would either simply put

GTA IV or niko's face imo

i dont think its real because on the disc they would either simply put

GTA IV or niko's face imo

devil_1994

with past GTA's they didnt put the main protagonist on the disc.

I call fake.

That's probably the worst image position I've ever seen on a disc. I bet the real one will just be black.

[QUOTE="clyde46"]Alright for all those who think its fake. Look very carefully at both the 360 version and ps3 version. Look around the edges, you shouldn't seen any overlap or peeling. When someone copies a cover it doesnt fit correctly onto the disc. These are legit because there is no overlap, the covers are machine cut and machine stuck down with no bumps.They include all the legal text and aswell as an ESRB or whatever rating. Just because the 360 version has a reflective ring that covers up are face doesnt mean its bad desgin. Its being shipped on BOTH the 360 AND the ps3, thus the disc's look the same.NOD_Grindking

no but your wrong....THERE IS overlap....look at the TOP of the 360 disc, to the right....see that? thats blank disc, because the label is not positioned correctly....it is quite obviously noticable

He's right, there's definitely a sliver of blank grey like you see on blank retail discs, that isn't visible on any genuine published game discs I have. It's like they used some sort of adhesive label that was juuuust a bit too small.

[QUOTE="RoslindaleOne"]If this is fake it's by far the best I've ever seen.whodeysay85

Here is my legit halo 3 disc, note taken at a simular angle. It looks the same.

Here is my legit halo 3 disc, note taken at a simular angle. It looks the same.

clyde46

But it doesn't though......look how yours is evenly distributed around the disc...the GTA one is not, its more of a gap at the top than it is at the bottom....by a long shot

here is wat i found... same picture but in a different position (probably another fake)

Might have to copy and paste link

http://www.gametrailers.com/player/usermovies/201745.html

here is wat i found... same picture but in a different position (probably another fake)

Might have to copy and paste link

http://www.gametrailers.com/player/usermovies/201745.html

1357

Those are fake.

Well remember the ps2 version of Gta: SA didn't have a picture of CJ on the front.

Also it has the shiny ring on the inside, xbox certificate, which i can imagine would be hard to copy

It looks legit but, the hole in the face makes it look fake,