Saints row 2 the potential rival against GTA 4

Do you think SR 2 will be the main rival this year based on the previews on the game or do you think GTA 4 will smash SR 2 to bits?

Not even in the same league, Still water is dull and empty compared to any GTA city still water is nothing, and dont even get me started on the mission layout.

GTA4 will completely destroy SR2.

well i havent playd them both but i have playd saints row and gtr san andreas and there fairly similier and as good as eachother but i would put my bet on gtr 4

good luck man

Saints has the customisation and fun playability- GTA has the established brand and high expectations; it'll be a close one, but I'd say Saints has it on Gameplay, wheras GTA will probably have the better sound, voices and music.

We'll see, but for now, I'm rooting for the foul mouthed underdog, SR2.

Saints Row is garbage compared to the GTA franchise. Like comparing a Honda with a Lambo...Aaron89

Well in this instance, it'll be like comparing the Honda NSX to a Lambo Gallardo.....

Both great cars, both fun to drive, in the end it'll come down to preference, do you want clinical precision,(GTA4) or crazy fun? (NSX)

NB: I am not saying GTA is technically a great game, I'm saying that it is technically superior to SR.

Do you think SR 2 will be the main rival this year based on the previews on the game or do you think GTA 4 will smash SR 2 to bits?

sivasiva

omg these games are BOTH aweful!!! skyyfox1

Are u kidding? GTA and saints row are the blockbuster games for the 360 and you are calling it aweful. Wat a joke!!! Seriously, do you play any of these two games?

Nope, haha GTA4 is just too well recognized and will most definitely have better voice acting and story telling, not that SR2 won't be good... just the GTA series production values are through the roof.

omg these games are BOTH aweful!!! skyyfox1

Saints row success was do to it was the only next gen gta sandbox type game you could get. I will say it did some things better then gta. the only problem is it had some story you could care less about, you are some generic character with no sole. It had custom characters witch was cool. Now that gta will be out this game will suffer in sales, most of the games sales will be from second time buyers in my opnion that really liked the 1st game. I really don't think the people that didn't get it the first time will buy it, they will just get gta. I thing gta will smash this game and saints row 2 will be the last in the series, unless they do some major changes to differ it from gta. the best chance SR2 has is to release it when we are ready for gta5 lol, just before gta5 gets delayed unleash SR2 it will sell well then.

Saints row success was do to it was the only next gen gta sandbox type game you could get. I will say it did some things better then gta. the only problem is it had some story you could care less about, you are some generic character with no sole. It had custom characters witch was cool. Now that gta will be out this game will suffer in sales, most of the games sales will be from second time buyers in my opnion that really liked the 1st game. I really don't think the people that didn't get it the first time will buy it, they will just get gta. I thing gta will smash this game and saints row 2 will be the last in the series, unless they do some major changes to differ it from gta.

gagit811

Both games will be equally good but i have my money on GTA just because the sheer sense of immersion it will bring.

both man..

they will be sick...

I personally would rather play thru Saints Row than GTA... dont get me wrong I think GTA4 is gonna be awesome and probably even better then SR2 in most aspects of the game, but SR does it for me and i have my reasons...

I have personally never finished a GTA game... nothing against the game of even the story but it has alot of missions that just cause me to lose interest in trying to finish the game(especially any RC mission that seems to pop up in every GTA) and I, like alot of others, just end up playing it just to cause as much mayhem as possible.. The missions in SR (although some are repititive and thoughtless) are pretty straight forward and alot less irritating. The story isnt as compelling as the GTA story but is better then most of you are saying. Also I read something about GTA having better voice acting? Are you saying that the Hollywood voice overs were bad, because I honestly disagree. and lastly look how many installments and years have been put into GTA to get where it is now.. where SR is working on its 2nd and is a credible competitor.. SR deserves alot more respect then its getting and with more entries in the series it will gain it

mb

I personally would rather play thru Saints Row than GTA... dont get me wrong I think GTA4 is gonna be awesome and probably even better then SR2 in most aspects of the game, but SR does it for me and i have my reasons...

I have personally never finished a GTA game... nothing against the game of even the story but it has alot of missions that just cause me to lose interest in trying to finish the game(especially any RC mission that seems to pop up in every GTA) and I, like alot of others, just end up playing it just to cause as much mayhem as possible.. The missions in SR (although some are repititive and thoughtless) are pretty straight forward and alot less irritating. The story isnt as compelling as the GTA story but is better then most of you are saying. Also I read something about GTA having better voice acting? Are you saying that the Hollywood voice overs were bad, because I honestly disagree. and lastly look how many installments and years have been put into GTA to get where it is now.. where SR is working on its 2nd and is a credible competitor.. SR deserves alot more respect then its getting and with more entries in the series it will gain it

I agree with you.

mb

Myke_Brooks