What do you think will be the best ODST or MW2?

i think im going with odst becuase of its all new firefight

That's a tough one. I'm determined that both are going to be horrible, but I think that Halo 3 ODST will reach a new level of medicority, so I say Modern Warfare 2.

MW2: 1 Disk

ODST: 2 Disks

Theres your answer..less is more!

Modern Warfare 2

hands down MW2

ONly reason im gunna get ODST is for beta and maybe the singleplayer.

I think that Modern Warfare 2 but im getting both.

MW2: 1 Disk

ODST: 2 Disks

Theres your answer..less is more!

Unknown_Hero3

2 disks? What could ODST possibly have that would warrent the use of 2 disks?

That's a tough one. I'm determined that both are going to be horrible, but I think that Halo 3 ODST will reach a new level of medicority, so I say Modern Warfare 2.

Phoenix534

Although I've never seen any footage of the new Halo game, I'm more than sure that Modern Warfare is going to be better.

odst has no chance of being better.mischa_barton

[QUOTE="Unknown_Hero3"]

MW2: 1 Disk

ODST: 2 Disks

Theres your answer..less is more!

Phoenix534

2 disks? What could ODST possibly have that would warrent the use of 2 disks?

[QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

[QUOTE="Unknown_Hero3"]

MW2: 1 Disk

ODST: 2 Disks

Theres your answer..less is more!

craigalan23

2 disks? What could ODST possibly have that would warrent the use of 2 disks?

So the second disc is like Halo 3 without the campaign? Will the second disc of ODST and Halo 3 be compatible (If I buy ODST will I be able to play a friend with Halo 3 online)?

mw2, I just hope they don't make the game impossible like cod4: mwAxlRoseIsMyDad

Probably ODST, at least Bungie is doing something different with it's campaign: Making it have open world environments which Bungie states that it will have replay value as it's non linear from what I read, go back to no health regeneration and have to find health packs, which should increase the challenge, an extra mode called Firefight that reminds me of Gears of War 2's Horde mode which will have lots of replay value and will probably be longer than MW2.

Modern Warfare 2 looks exactly like COD4, only a little better graphics wise, and if it's just like COD4, I'll wait for the price to go down, the campaign was too short(shorter than Halo 3), it wasn't as hard as the 1st 2 CODs on Veteran, and I didn't get into COD 4's multiplayer. Call of Duty hasn't been THAT great since COD 2 sadly.

[QUOTE="craigalan23"][QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

2 disks? What could ODST possibly have that would warrent the use of 2 disks?

So the second disc is like Halo 3 without the campaign? Will the second disc of ODST and Halo 3 be compatible (If I buy ODST will I be able to play a friend with Halo 3 online)?

[QUOTE="AxlRoseIsMyDad"]mw2, I just hope they don't make the game impossible like cod4: mwoscar_mateo

[QUOTE="oscar_mateo"][QUOTE="AxlRoseIsMyDad"]mw2, I just hope they don't make the game impossible like cod4: mwAxlRoseIsMyDad

Modern Warfare 2 but I can't wait for both, Halo: Reach beta for the winToriko42

[QUOTE="Toriko42"]Modern Warfare 2 but I can't wait for both, Halo: Reach beta for the wincraigalan23

[QUOTE="Toriko42"]Modern Warfare 2 but I can't wait for both, Halo: Reach beta for the wincraigalan23

[QUOTE="craigalan23"][QUOTE="Toriko42"]Modern Warfare 2 but I can't wait for both, Halo: Reach beta for the wingow117

[QUOTE="gow117"][QUOTE="craigalan23"] I can't wait for it but who knows when it will be out that is the only bummer. Hopefully it wont be TOO long.craigalan23

[QUOTE="craigalan23"][QUOTE="gow117"] 2010. But when...its a mistery..gow117

I think I will like ODST more, but most people would like Modern Warfare 2.

[QUOTE="gow117"][QUOTE="craigalan23"] I was talking about the BETA rather than the actual game :P.craigalan23

[QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

That's a tough one. I'm determined that both are going to be horrible, but I think that Halo 3 ODST will reach a new level of medicority, so I say Modern Warfare 2.

enterawesome

Not everytime. I'm highly anticipating Mass Effect 2, Crackdown 2, Splinter Cell Conviction, Fallout New Vegas, The Elder Scrolls V, Ghost Recon 4, Ace Combat 7, Command & Conquer 4, and a real next-gen Rainbow Six(Vegas doesn't count)

That's a tough one. I'm determined that both are going to be horrible, but I think that Halo 3 ODST will reach a new level of medicority, so I say Modern Warfare 2.

Phoenix534

[QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

That's a tough one. I'm determined that both are going to be horrible, but I think that Halo 3 ODST will reach a new level of medicority, so I say Modern Warfare 2.

vashkey

Genre defining? Neither of those franchises are genre defining. And don't bring Yahtzee into this.

Anyway, it'll probably be Modern Warfare 2 considering it's an entirely new game. But I'll probably like ODST since I've hated the competitive multiplayer for the Call of Duty series ever the original Modern Warfare came around. And Fire Fight sounds awesome. I loved Gears 2's horde mode.vashkey

Don't ignore me. What on Earth would make you think that those franchises were genre defining?

[QUOTE="vashkey"][QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

That's a tough one. I'm determined that both are going to be horrible, but I think that Halo 3 ODST will reach a new level of medicority, so I say Modern Warfare 2.

Phoenix534

Genre defining? Neither of those franchises are genre defining. And don't bring Yahtzee into this.

[QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

[QUOTE="vashkey"] Yes, of course. I mean, genre defining games certainly are mediocre. I doubt even want to hear the reason considering your avatar.vashkey

Genre defining? Neither of those franchises are genre defining. And don't bring Yahtzee into this.

Are we still talking about Halo and Call of Duty? CoD I could understand if we were talking about Call of Duty and United Offense, but the rest and the Halo franchise were all generic FPSs. Especially Halo and it's medicore protagonist, bland combat, and poor storyline. I did have respect for Call of Duty, until we got to the second one.

[QUOTE="vashkey"]Anyway, it'll probably be Modern Warfare 2 considering it's an entirely new game. But I'll probably like ODST since I've hated the competitive multiplayer for the Call of Duty series ever the original Modern Warfare came around. And Fire Fight sounds awesome. I loved Gears 2's horde mode.Phoenix534

Don't ignore me. What on Earth would make you think that those franchises were genre defining?

[QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

[QUOTE="vashkey"]Anyway, it'll probably be Modern Warfare 2 considering it's an entirely new game. But I'll probably like ODST since I've hated the competitive multiplayer for the Call of Duty series ever the original Modern Warfare came around. And Fire Fight sounds awesome. I loved Gears 2's horde mode.vashkey

Don't ignore me. What on Earth would make you think that those franchises were genre defining?

Let's see. Compare Call of Duty and Halo to Bioshock, Brothers in Arms, Ghost Recon, Rainbow Six(pre-Vegas), Lost Planet, Dark Sector, and Prey. I will admit that Call of Duty is better than most of the garbage on the market these days, such as Vampire Rain, Turning Point: Fall of Liberty, and Hour of Victory. Halo, not so sure about that.

[QUOTE="vashkey"][QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

Genre defining? Neither of those franchises are genre defining. And don't bring Yahtzee into this.

Phoenix534

Are we still talking about Halo and Call of Duty? CoD I could understand if we were talking about Call of Duty and United Offense, but the rest and the Halo franchise were all generic FPSs. Especially Halo and it's medicore protagonist, bland combat, and poor storyline. I did have respect for Call of Duty, until we got to the second one.

[QUOTE="AxlRoseIsMyDad"][QUOTE="oscar_mateo"] I completed on veteran. oscar_mateo

You sir are better than me then. There are parts in that game that make me want to punch children and small animals(not literally, but you get what im saying)

[QUOTE="Phoenix534"]

[QUOTE="vashkey"] Yes, they are. They've brought together alot of great gameplay ideas into one package and revolutionzed the genre. vashkey

Are we still talking about Halo and Call of Duty? CoD I could understand if we were talking about Call of Duty and United Offense, but the rest and the Halo franchise were all generic FPSs. Especially Halo and it's medicore protagonist, bland combat, and poor storyline. I did have respect for Call of Duty, until we got to the second one.

The combat is the same throught the whole franchise. Each weapon is identical except for the firing speed. And the story and characters can make or break a game. the Halo health system has destroyed some FPSs and Halo's multiplayer, while fun at sometimes, can be the worst experiance. I like the unlockable weapons and level up stuff in Call of Duty, I will give you that one. And Half-Life 2, while I think it's one of the best shooters on the market, does have boring combat once you've used the Gravity Gun for about 5 minutes. And no, I'm not on of those people looking for attention by bashing popular games.

Whats your ideal as the perfect shooter? is he out there? or not yet?gow117

The perfect shooter has not and will not be made. There will always be bad qualities in a game, even Mass Effect, which is the best game I've played(go ahead and bash it to try and piss me off vashkey). I can't really describe the perfect shooter, but it's definetly not like anything released yet. Although I think that Earth No More will come closer than any other game to being perfect.