What game deserves a 10 in your opinion?

If you were to choose one game to have a 10, what would it be? Which game deserves to have a 10? I would choose the Orange Box because it has both great single player (HL and Portal) and multiplayer (TF2). It's a great deal especially now that it's 19.99 in stores.

If you were to choose one game to have a 10, what would it be? Which game deserves to have a 10? I would choose the Orange Box because it has both great single player (HL and Portal) and multiplayer (TF2). It's a great deal especially now that it's 19.99 in stores.

Blobstone

I would go with the orange box as well, also Mass Effect

Orange Box, gs 9.5

Call of Duty 4, gs9.0

games that don't deserve a 10

Grand Theft Auto 4, my score 2.0

Braid.

The Orange Box and GTAIV probably.

Call of Duty 5. definatl3y.

Call of Duty 5. definatl3y.

killthatmofo

...

*cricket*

...

Bioshock - By far the most memorable gaming experience I've had this generation.

Oh and Call of duty 4.

Orange Box, gs 9.5

Call of Duty 4, gs9.0

games that don't deserve a 10

Grand Theft Auto 4, my score 2.0

I think any game that makes hug advancements, so yer I would give GTA 4 a 10.

i guess Resident Evil 5 deserves 10 im lovin it

CoD 4 and Gears of War 2 IMO

Fallout 3

Bioshock deserves a 10.

Bioshock

YarisArchPlague22

Yaris = masterpiece

GTA IV, Halo 3, Lumines Live!, and Mega Man 9

Lumines Live!AtlanticRock

[QUOTE="AtlanticRock"] Lumines Live!vashkey

yeah i owned the original on PSP... then my PSP broke 3x... then I got a 360 and found out about Lumines Live... d/l it but haven't been able to get all the achievements, it's tough, but I like puzzle games, something to play too clear my head... And yes, the songs in Lumines Live! don't match up to L1 or L2

No game this generation for me. Maybe Oblivion comes close.GamerForca

Agreed, Although I dont think any game this gen is perfect...Gears of War 1 and Oblivion came dang close, imohaha

I don't think there exists any 'perfect' game. If I had to pick, I would say KOTOR. Superb graphics, epic story, freedom of choice in missions and side quests, terrific cast of characters, incredible voice acting, and lots of replay value with multiple endings. This was arguably the best thing from Star Wars since the old trilogy.gr8scott

Couldn't agree more! Anyway if i'm to pick games from the current generation...i go with Mass effect and Bioshock.

Metal Gear Solid 4. Best game, and series, ever made in my opinion. Silent Hill 2 is an honorable mention.

Halo 3 deserves 10 (my opinion)

GTA IV deserves 5

Gears of war 2 deserves 9.5

COD4 deserves 9.5

None.

The only way a game gets 10 is if the reviewers get paid by the companies making it, or if they are high while reviewing.

No games are perfect.

of course fallout3 and GTA4 and THE best,COD4

IMO nothing in this generation can compare to the awesomeness that was the SNES/Mega Drive generation

i dont care what you say, snes was, for me, the best console created as it had an amazing selection of games, great graphics (at the time) and still has games that i regularily replay (donkey kong country series, mario, mario kart, final fantasy, street fighter 2) and the mega drive also had a great selection of games but snes pegs it for me.

this generation i would say......... oblivion, worms 2:armeggedon, and street fighter iv deserve 10

I would pick CoD 4 to come in second though.

ASSASSINS CREED! BOOYA:D

No perfect tens, but there are a lot of games that easily warrants a 9. Mass Effect, Oblivion, COD4, Fallout 3. I'm hoping Final Fantasy XIII will be a 10 point game.

Grand Theft Auto 4, my score 2.0

munchlax99

......Riiiiiiight.

So GTA 4 should be rated lower than Bomberman: Act Zero, Vampire Rain and Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust?

:|