Which is scarier Silent Hill Homecoming or Condemned?

Topic. Thanks.

Ps. Is Homecoming as bad as the critics have said? I loved Silent Hill 2 but it looks a little shaky.

from what I've heard SH's spooks are predictable. I haven't started it because I've been playing PoP but I'm looking forward to it. I've only played the beginning of it.

Condemned is scary in the sence that its REALLY dark and can't see well so enemies will sneak up on you. Condemned 2 is better than Condemned 1.

I'd get Condemned 2. If you are a SH fan then you may like SH:H but be warned its not like any of the previous SH games. Alex Shepard CAN kick a**.

condemned 1 was pretty scary

condemned 2 wasnt halve as scary

silent hill homecoming wasnt scary AT ALL and as a fellow lover of silent hill 2 i dont think it does the franchise justice, if the game wasnt called "silent hill" i wouldnt have wasted my time on it

Silent Hill:HC is decent...i personally found the first half AWESOME, while the second half moved away from the scary and focused completely on action.

the original Condemned is a scarier game IMO

Well, I haven't played SH: Homecoming but I have played Condemned and I gotta say that some of my scariest video game moments are in Condemned. In short, I say get Condemned, it's too cheap and good to pass up!rattleheadxyz