Which xbox game do you think has the best replay value?

For me it's probably Borderlands, there's so many weapons and items to collect, the 4 player online co-op never gets old and the huge world is really fun. I've also gone back and gotten sucked into the game numerous times after setting it aside for a while.

id say Left 4 Dead 2 online.

Red Dead Redemption had Tonnes of Challenges and unlockables in it's multiplayer.

In general the entire Halo series...

Gears Of War and MK9

Id avoid COD Halo and Red Dead.

Crysis 2

Id avoid COD Halo and Red Dead.

wretch0101

Bethesda's games...So many possible character builds....

The general answer is RPGs or MP extensive games. I've heard you can get like 200+hours out of Oblivion but for me I got 150+ hours out of Tales of Vesperia. Borderlands is another good answer. Basically infinite replayability.

Personally I have played BFBC2 the most out of all my 360 games. Followed by Oblivion.AutoPilotOn

Probably my biggest regret selling that game after a while. I hate myself, i really do.

[QUOTE="AutoPilotOn"]Personally I have played BFBC2 the most out of all my 360 games. Followed by Oblivion.Ilovegames1992

Probably my biggest regret selling that game after a while. I hate myself, i really do.

I had a lot of fun with Red Dead long after I beat it. A lot of the achievements were fun, and I liked progressing through the multiplayer.

CoD, Reach, BC2, anything with gradeA multiplayer has a lot of replay value. MW2 especially, if you're willing to bend the rules a little ;).

It's definitely tough to argue with Borderlands. I keep telling myself I'll move on to the DLC sooner or later, but I just am having too much fun in the main world. I bet I'll be completely overpowered when it comes time for the DLC.

Mass Effect. the main story stays the same, but the way you play it and the different ways the story develops and where different characters end up can change the entire experience.

Fallout 3 and Oblivion are great games along with Borderlands. If you're looking something with some MP then I would try any of the new CoD's and I heard Crysis 2 and BFBC2 was good as well.

Recently it has been Marvel Vs Capcom 3. Its probably the only game that i own that i can play over and over doing the same thing and still get a rush.

I have wore out BFBC2, but at this point i have no desire to even play it anymore unless a friend ask me too. As far as all the other shooters that feel the same, none of them catch my attention for very long.

Recently it has been Marvel Vs Capcom 3. Its probably the only game that i own that i can play over and over doing the same thing and still get a rush.

I have wore out BFBC2, but at this point i have no desire to even play it anymore unless a friend ask me too. As far as all the other shooters that feel the same, none of them catch my attention for very long.

jjivey

[QUOTE="jjivey"]

Recently it has been Marvel Vs Capcom 3. Its probably the only game that i own that i can play over and over doing the same thing and still get a rush.

I have wore out BFBC2, but at this point i have no desire to even play it anymore unless a friend ask me too. As far as all the other shooters that feel the same, none of them catch my attention for very long.

Kojo222

You know my brother-in-law bought a guidebook as well. At first i thought that was silly cause i myself never would buy something you can find free on the internet, but wow that thing helps.

It's definitely tough to argue with Borderlands. I keep telling myself I'll move on to the DLC sooner or later, but I just am having too much fun in the main world. I bet I'll be completely overpowered when it comes time for the DLC.

IWAOlympus

[QUOTE="AutoPilotOn"]Personally I have played BFBC2 the most out of all my 360 games. Followed by Oblivion.Ilovegames1992

Probably my biggest regret selling that game after a while. I hate myself, i really do.

Single play/ Split screen: Borderlands, GTA 4, COD(zombies), assassins creed(all of them) Multiplay: Halo Reach, BFBC2, and Homefront

Single play/ Split screen: Borderlands, GTA 4, COD(zombies), assassins creed(all of them) Multiplay: Halo Reach, BFBC2, and Homefront

itsarchi

So you guys are saying that the top two casual shooters out right now out of every game ever made have the "best replay value"... srsly?

In terms of the replayability of a single player campaign, for me it would be Dragon Age: Origins.

I've replayed it several times in an attempt to get certain endings, though I can never seem to get a happy one.

So you guys are saying that the top two casual shooters out right now out of every game ever made have the "best replay value"... srsly?

wretch0101

Best replay value should probably go to something that has an extensive single and multiplayer. RPG's are long, but if they don't have access to mutiplayer, you can only go so far with it.

I'd say Red Dead Redemption and Grand Theft Auto IV take the prize. If you try to achieve and complete everything in either game just in single player, you'd definitely hit 40+ hours. Possibly 50 or 60. Then you also have the option of just running around the open world and finding yourself some of your own fun. I can't even begin to count the time I've spent taking on the cops and military in GTA, and simply trying to last as long as I could against them before dying.

Then we have the multiplayers for both, where you have specific type games like cops and robbers, or the open world with a bunch of other people, either trying to complete quests together or killing each other off.

The Assassins Creed games.

For me it'd be Fallout 3, Mass Effect 1 and 2, Red Dead Redemption, and Borderlands.

Best replay value should probably go to something that has an extensive single and multiplayer. RPG's are long, but if they don't have access to mutiplayer, you can only go so far with it.

I'd say Red Dead Redemption and Grand Theft Auto IV take the prize. If you try to achieve and complete everything in either game just in single player, you'd definitely hit 40+ hours. Possibly 50 or 60. Then you also have the option of just running around the open world and finding yourself some of your own fun. I can't even begin to count the time I've spent taking on the cops and military in GTA, and simply trying to last as long as I could against them before dying.

Then we have the multiplayers for both, where you have specific type games like cops and robbers, or the open world with a bunch of other people, either trying to complete quests together or killing each other off.

silver_kyle

[QUOTE="silver_kyle"]

Best replay value should probably go to something that has an extensive single and multiplayer. RPG's are long, but if they don't have access to mutiplayer, you can only go so far with it.

I'd say Red Dead Redemption and Grand Theft Auto IV take the prize. If you try to achieve and complete everything in either game just in single player, you'd definitely hit 40+ hours. Possibly 50 or 60. Then you also have the option of just running around the open world and finding yourself some of your own fun. I can't even begin to count the time I've spent taking on the cops and military in GTA, and simply trying to last as long as I could against them before dying.

Then we have the multiplayers for both, where you have specific type games like cops and robbers, or the open world with a bunch of other people, either trying to complete quests together or killing each other off.

wretch0101

Play online and play Hold Your Own, Grab the Bag, etc. The new Undead Campaign not only extended the single player, but also added more types of online games,Undead overrun mode and Land grab.

Borderlands definately has awesome replay value and id say Mass Effect 1 and 2

borderlands

borderlands

ESPGaluda II Black Label and Earth Defense Force 2017.