@DanZillaUK: I get what you mean but GS has consistently chosen against the popular opinion in recent years. Not everyone agreeing is obvious but there always is a majority for one game both critically and in general. You should know what that is this year.
I wonder what hipster choice they will go with for GOTY. That's kinda their thing lately. Either that or they will choose the wrong year to pick an overhyped game in Fallout 4.
Daian's comments