This whole Too Human drama was starting to really bug me. I liked the demo, so I figured I would get it once I had the money, and after a few other games I wanted more (such as Soul Calibur 4 and Burnout Paradise). Then GameSpot released their review. They wailed on the game. A 5.5 out of 10 is worse than what Haze got. Of course, people read this review and thought that this game was dead and over with.
Then people bought it, and loved it. These were the same people that just HAPPENED to like the demo. So, who is indeed right, the people who liked the game, or the people who didn't? Neither. An opinion is an opinion. However, this just goes to show how reliable a review can be...
Games, like all other media, have different genres. Some people may like a genre, others may not. So if a person plays Soul Calibur 4 and hates it, it isn't a bad game, they just might not like fighters. Now, why they would play a fighting game if they hate fighters is beyond me, but a person who loves fighters, will love Soul Calibur 4! Simple as that. That is why, if a reviewing website is smart, they will pick a reviewer that likes the genre of a game he or she is reviewing.
Too Human is an odd game with the fact that two people could both like the action RPG genre, and one would love it while the other hated it. That's just the way the gameplay was, especially with the dualstick controls. That explains why GameSpot could have put a action RPG game reviewer there, and he hated it, while other reviewers loved it.
It is this inconsistency that causes me to not trust reviews anymore. I will use them to a certain degree. such as if I'm unsure about a game, but if I know I like a game (from a demo, or if I just love the genre or series) then I'll get it no matter what scores it gets! I wouldn't have cared if Battlefield Bad Company got a 3/10 from GameSpot, as long as it wasn't for any serious reasons anyway, I love the genre, and I love the series.
If you're unsure about a game, just play a demo or rent it. If you're still unsure, THEN go to reviews, but make sure to actually read them and use multiple reviews. If you know you like a specific series or genre, and you know you'll like it, or if you played the demo beforehand and liked it, go ahead and buy it. Don't bother with the reviews. After you find that you love it, to read that that game got a 5.5/10 from a website, you can chuckle to yourself, happy that you didn't listen to that reviewer's opinion.
Log in to comment