@jakcul I'm not sure how it helps replay value, seeing as how you don't have to replay the game to access the content. The multi-player does add content and is a nice little bonus. But does not affect the single player campaign which most people buy it to experience. That's like a critic taking points off of a movie for having crappy special features.
If I were a reviewer, I wouldn't take points off for the multi-player. People don't really buy games for multi-player anyway (except for COD, Battlefield, and the such).
DiverseGamer's comments