[QUOTE="Donkey_Puncher"]If you listen to the commentary on Cartoon wars 1 and 2 they explain it pretty well.
They don't HATE family guy, they just don't like being compared to them. They feel it's nothing but slapstick gags with little relevancy to the plot, or in other words terrible writing.
They also explain that Matt Groening and the writers of other shows actually praised them for saying these things. It's not just them that feel this way.
MrGeezer
I do think that there's a valid comparism between Family Guy and South Park in one aspect though. Both shows have fairly often tried to be "edgy" or "push boundaries" for no other reason than that they can. Basically, offensiveness just for the sake of offensiveness.
It's one thing to offend people when you've got something to say. It's one thing to offend people if it's funny. But both shows have delved into the territory where they post offensive stuff and it's supposed to be funny solely because it's offensive.
And that's not smart comedy. That's the equivalent of the guy who draws a frowning face on his nuts, takes a picture with his phone, and then sends you a picture message. And yet he can't for the life of him understand how you didn't find that completely hilarious.
Of course South Park has been offensive just for the sake of being offensive. But when they do purposely offend people, it's either in the form of satire and relevant to the plot at hand, If a fart joke or poop joke is written well into a plot or somehow relevant, It could still be considered good writing regardless if it boils down to a poop joke.
Log in to comment