Battlefield 3.

For lasting appeal and just general greatness online free-roam I'd get GTAIV, I've racked up hundreds of hours with this game online.

This is just a rumour and a bad one at that, I cannot see any company doing this... They would lose so much money in sales on consoles, I have 3 friends and two family members who all have Xbox 360's but have never plugged them into the internet, why? they wouldn't know where to start! and for the families without internet connections... Nah, wouldn't happend, and if it did, they need to re-think their design team.

I may get the xbox 360 version of San Andreas just to have a working controller, I bought the PC version, but the 360 controller really doesn't work well with the PC version of the game, and those types of games MUST be played with a controller.

PGR3 online is still active as it isn't ran by servers, but the online challenges maybe down. Cat and Mouse is a god send and I love it to bits, only problem is the community just isn't there anymore. :(

Your Xbox Slim console will be fine.

Fable III for me.

If I'm honest, there has never been a game or movie that has affected/scared me in any way. How could a fictional character possibly be scarey?

Call of Duty 2 Vet. It's almost impossible, for me anyway.

Retailers rip people off, you would be much better off selling on ebay.