If I had to pick between the 2 I would definitely have to say the PS1 casing. Only because the cases have a shinier kind of thing goin for em and the artwork inside was always cool.

The problem with the casing, however, is that they break and crack so easy. The thing with plastic cases is that they are much mroe durable.

VIII and IX are both great games so no matter which you choose you should enjoy both of them.

IX will be easier to get into and its an overall enjoyable experience. Nothing too thought provoking here and It doesnt have anything particularly new about it but the story, music, gameplay, and characthers are all amazing and executed perfectly. If you want something simple and light hearted here it is.

VIII is a hit or miss with alot of people. If you're looking for a unique battle system this one is definitely the standout of the 3. The junction system can be fun but alot of people find it overly complicated when in reality its very easy to use and understand. VIII has a very strong story with very memorable characthers and good music. The battle system is THE BEST out of the 3 by far. The only flaw with it is the DRAW mechanic which I honestly didnt mind but some people find it a bit monotonous. Between this one and IX, VIII is far more epic and imaginitive. VIII is a much more mature fantasy then IX.

The final boss battles of the 2 games are extremely memorable but between VIII and IX, VIII has the best final boss battle between the two. Its much more epic and crazy and less predictable. Very very memorable.

Sorry, what I meant was, there opinion isnt significant or justified.

Any and everybody who has listed 10 as there favorite should consider there opinion invalid.

10 Holds your hand the entire game, its hardly FF.

No im not a fanboy, Yes I own this game. It sucks. The campaign is boring, the controls are lame, the framerate and graphics suffer from constant glitching and the online, while fun at first, got old fast.

The game sucks. Anybody denying it is a fanboy.

You just wasted your money.

Enjoy that mess of a game which you unfrotunately bought.

Picked up Lunar Silver Star Story Complete today.

Probably my rarest game as of right now.

Einhander

Lunar Silver start story Complete (Depending on which disc set you have (there are 4 different disc sets), Whether or not you have the original box/map/hardbook)

Persona 2 eternal punishment

I want einhander so bad its not even funny. Persona 2 not so much as im not a big megaten fan. I have lunar silver star story with the original case but i dont have the box/map/hardbook. I do have a copy of this game with the rarest of the 4 disc sets (magic emperor/3 female trio) but its a shame i dont own the entire set. :/