Get your sarcasm detector fixed broski. I am in the Uncharted 2 closed beta and I think it's phenomenal. It's the first game I am willing to hype AAA 5 months in advance since LittleBigPlanet. colosion

Oh sorry, it's just that I've read so many stupid things today, I didn't detect the sarcasm :P How's the beta? I would love to get in.

[QUOTE="AAllxxjjnn"][QUOTE="Ego-testicle"] LOLWUT Metal Gear Solid and Metal Gear Solid 2 have sold 7 million copies EACH. /facepalm3picuri3

apparently he does. he's off to a great start in SW :) don't understand what SWAG sees in him :P

[QUOTE="Ego-testicle"]

[QUOTE="TheLordHimself"]

Uncharted is one of my top 20 favourite games of all time, and 6th favourite of this generation. Whycan't I be excited for its sequel?

colosion

Unacceptable. You cannot like games with scripted events or linear storylines. If it forces you to do your missions in a specific order, it isn't worth playing. Story is overrated, games are about gameplay. If you don't have the freedom to just walk around and not do missions, it isn't actually a game.

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]

Uncharted... Hmm:

• enemies are hyped up on PCP;
• difficulty goes from easy to crushingly difficult (rarely consistant);
• very short game (7 to 8 hours);
• singleplayer only, no replay value;
• finding treasures are pointless;
• storyline goes from good to meh at the end (anyone who resorts to *this new enemy (don't want to spoil)* for a plot twist is lame;
• puzzles are rediculously easy;
• gameplay is reminiscent of an ugly offspring between tomb raider and gears of war;
• some of the cutscenes felt needless;
• sme graphical issues, popping in textures (from low to high resolution)
• sme glitches, and graphica clipping issues;
• some of the "jump from ledge to ledge" gameplay gets repetitive and get rather tedious.

Even though Uncharted suffered from all these, it's still a great game -- and I firmly stand by Gamespot's 8.0 score. I loved Uncharted, I thought it was a great game... but by no means does it deserve some of the praise that it gets here.

JLF1

Exactly. It's called spin. I can call Lord of the Rings an overlong movie about some midgets who walk across a country and throw a ring into a pit and it doesn't sound very cool.

How can something be a great game, and you agree, yet you think it should only be mildly praised? Since when is an 8.0 game a letdown? This game was SP only and short and still managed an 8 here and higher ratings elsewhere. Take the original game, pump it full of steroids, add in a very elegant MP suite with 3 player co-op and 5v5 competitive MP and you have a winning package. Don't take my word for it though, I am perfectly comfortable waiting until this one comes out to rub it in people's faces.

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

[QUOTE="jakarai"]FF 14 was the real Megaton to me. No one knew about that. We already knew Rockstar was working on a PS3 exclusive.TREAL_Since

It's a multiplat and an MMO. Not really a megaton.

Is anyone seeing the Spyborgs demo on Gamespot? Awesome! :)

UPDATED THREAD:

1.) FAIL SECTION

2.) Edits to lists