My Critic's Review of Eragon, Both Book and Film (Major Critisism)
by FreakishChild on Comments
It should be no secret to anyone here I want to be a published fantasy novelist someday. Why I wait until later instead of now is because young writers, I've come to realize for myself, aren't very well-founded as older writers and haven't exactly been around the block in the fiction department. When I finally aim to be a published author, I want to be the kind "that's been around the block." I'm not there yet because I have only been reading books for five and a half years, and writing for four. (I was ADD and Dyslexic, okay?)
Christopher Poalini shows promise. His descriptions are well-worth indulging in the Inheritance trilogy for that alone. The kid has one vivid imagination. However his characters are less than to be desired for. My take on the main trio. The main protaganist of the Inheritance books is nothing short of a Gary Stue. Eragon starts as an uneducated back of the woods twit that in less than a year gets a shining blue steed and is the realm's greatest champion against the mad tyrannical king. Arya, who I view as the trilogy's second most important heroine, is hardly more than an exotic love interest. An elven princess, stunningly beautiful, and strong in magic and in swordsmanship. Most paragraphs about her concentrate more on her beauty and skill rather than her personality. And Murtagh, who was BY FAR my favorite character in the series; a complicated and conflicted young man and a controversial character (ZOMG, Zuko archetype!). Murtagh's character showed so much promise, but Poalini flushed that down toilet by the end of Eldest. I blame the faults in his writing to age and inexperience. In essence, setting: Lord of the Rings, plot: Star Wars, and underline tone: McCaffery's dragons. Poalini scores points over Caf's for making the bond between rider and dragon a heck of a lot closer and giving dragons personalities.
The film. Saphira's demographics were marvelous, the scenery gritty and true to the era, but the only parts I enjoyed. The acting was pathetic, and the plot so chopped up compared to the book I found myself wishing I'd stayed home to watch Battelestar Galactica. In fact I would have but my friend asked me to go see the movie with her and even bought me a ticket. Ya can't say no under those circumstances. What got me through the chopped up pacing were the snide and sarcastic remarks my friend and I made. Our remarks made us laugh; I'd go crazy without her.
Saphira, while I whole-heartedly loved her design her behavior confused me. When she first hatches she's so cute, my heart melted but I swear she thought she was a puppy! Then when she finally grows up literally over flight she seems to think she was a swan. Especially at Brom's funeral! Just spread her wings so elegantly in a selute.
Arya. I can understand why they made her human. After the LotR film trilogy critics would have been shouting "rip-off." But she went from warrior chick to magical, ballarina princess. The dream scene of her in a forest Eragon had I felt like I was watching a teenager's playboy fantasy.
Murtagh. The point of his character was missed completely. I got the sense he was an agent sent by Galbatorix. His attire just screamed WEASEL. And for a major charatcer his screen time was painfully small. Oh, and Murtagh seemed to like dressing in black and drag a bit. Great, in the books he behaved like an emo being a traitor's son now he dresses like an emo.
Just... Just... Brom says "magic has rules and limitations" yet he doesn't even bother explaining the rules. He also says "magic flows from the dragon to its rider" yet Arya has no problem magicking. Hmm... is she secretly hiding her own off somewhere? And the Urgles at the end came out of no where!! Just popped out of the ground and the WTF moment of the movie. At LEAST the book had build-up!!
Eragon... Still a Gary Stu, a bit flat, just fair instead of dark eyes and hair. Of course I did liked the bit where he'd played at swords with his cousin before travelling off with Brom. In the book he'd never lifted an object, not even a stick, with the intention the object was a substitute sword.
Okay, I'm done. Whoa... That was really long post.
Log in to comment