Stop Screwing Up Final Fantasy: An Open Letter to Square-Enix
Hey, Square. Sit down for a second, would ya? I want to talk about a few things.
Look, I know you're going through some tough times, and I thought it would be a good idea to, you know, get some things off my chest. It might be a little rough, but it's tough love, you know? Better to get it from the people that care for you, right?
Ahem.
I wanted to talk about Final Fantasy.
Don't give me that look. You know it hurts, and I definitely know it hurts, but we need to get this stuff out in the open. I'm tired of looking at you with a feeling of disappointment, and seeing that look of "What?" on your face.
I think the problem is... well...
I think the problem is you.
Remember Final Fantasy VII? Back when I was eight years old, and a friend brought a copy of the game over to my house? When I was so happy with the way you sounded, and played, and looked? Wasn't that fun?
We laughed together as Barret spewed badly-obscured obscenities, and when you messed up with translation here and there (like, come on, Tseng wasn't really dead).
Okay, maybe a little bit more than "here and there."
And then we shared tears when Aerith died (remember when you kept calling her "Aeris"?), and we both did our best to keep going after that. There were so many wonderful plot twists, I didn't know when the excitement would end.
Just when I thought we had been through the best, Final Fantasy VIII came out. It looked fantastic, it sounded fantastic, it played wonderfully, the story still brings me to tears and gets me cheering and laughing and everything... those were the greatest days of my life.
Final Fantasy IX wasn't as good as VIII, but then again, nothing was as or had been as good as VIII, and I doubt there ever will be anything that perfect again. But IX had great music, and the characters were kind of interesting... some of them... and the use of super-deformed characters was certainly, um, new. You get points for effort, certainly.
X was a terrific experience. Some complained about how you sounded around then, but I liked the voice acting a lot. And the music was pretty good, though it wasn't as good as IX's (and certainly not VIII's). The CGs were certainly good to look at, though they were rare, and most of them involved Yuna being soaked in sweat, or water, or something. The story was a great tale, though.
Still, not as good as VIII's. But, like I said, nothing's been like that.
Well, like I was saying... things started to take a turn. Maybe it's my fault for not facing up to it when the PS2 came around and the in-game graphics hadn't improved a ton over IX. Or when the entire soundtrack wasn't done by Nobuo Uematsu.
What I really wanted to talk about was what's been going on recently. I hate to break it to you, Square, but you've been in a... well... let's call it a "phase."
The past three games you put out with the "Final Fantasy" title were X-2, XI, and XII.
I'm glad you've recovered from the drug addiction you were fighting with while making X-2, because I really hated seeing you like that. You were so self-destructive, tearing apart the world and characters of X, and undoing an ending that still moves me to this day.
I know that we started to fight around when XI came out. I'm sorry, but... it was just so terrible, on so many levels. So many levels. We're talking more levels than a World of Warcraft hacker on crack.
When I heard that you started to make some new friends with XII, I decided to take a look back. I trusted you enough to get the special edition version.
The trust is gone now, Square, and I don't know what you'll have to do to get it back.
XII was so utterly bad that it went beyond just being an insult to the series as a whole- because, Lord knows, you already fit in a good number of insults with X-2 and XI- it was just an outright bad game. The gameplay wasn't enjoyable at all, the 3D camera- while interesting- made me feel like I was playing XI and took away the interesting shots that you used to have (Have you looked over at God of War? They don't need a 3D camera, and they have beautiful landscapes). The voice acting went to hell, and the story was a complete rip-off of Star Wars... if Star Wars was boring as all get-out.
It's when I re-play the old Final Fantasies (VIII's ending always makes me cry for so many reasons... remember when you were able to do that?) that I realize how far we've drifted apart. I want to take a look at your future, you know- not just for me, but for you.
First, I want to talk about the story. All of the critics seemed to like XII's story because, in a nutshell, there was no romantic plot-line to distract the military theme.
I'm really worried about this. I don't know who you're trying to show off to, but those of us who have cared for you for the past few years... we really liked those plot-lines. And I don't know where the critics were when VIII was around, because I think being a special ops mercenary in a military academy at war with a rival nation counts as being heavily military-focused. And you managed to squeeze in a brilliant love story.
Is it that you're trying to impress new people? I hate to tell you this, but you're not going to impress anyone with XIII. I mean, honestly. The main character is named "Lightning"? That's somehow dumber than naming your main character "Tight-Ass." Yes, I know, Tidus' name is supposed to be pronounced "Tee-Dus," but we all read it the first way for a long time.
Second, I heard that you broke up with Hironobu Sakaguchi and Nobuo Uematsu. I know this is a pretty tragic time for you, because they were keeping the ship afloat. Looking at the results with XII, I can say with a great amount of certainty that the series should die right now if you can't get them back on the team.
Third, and here I refer you to the entirety of this message, stop screwing up Final Fantasy.
Let's put aside the whole "I'm talking to you like a parent" metaphor I've got going on here. Square, you're screwing everything up, and it's really starting to become a problem. XII sucked. There's no nice way around it. It sucked.
FFVII is what got me into video games in the first place, and FFVIII is what made me a gamer for life. I've been your most loyal fanboy and vehement defender for a while now, but I'm really just done. I'm sick of you messing around with this series. Stop screwing everything up.
X was a step in the wrong direction, I have to say. It was still a great game, but it seemed like you couldn't figure out where the hell were you going. The Sphere Grid thing was an apt example of this- I mean, were you leveling up or were you not leveling up? Let's see, I leveled up, which doesn't mean I can do anything, it just means I'm playing Monopoly and I can move to another space on the board. Whoo-freaking-hoo!
And what the hell is with not having Nobuo Uematsu around? I'm all for him doing his own stuff, but he said he'd be fine with doing another Final Fantasy on this new wave of consoles. Why didn't you go knocking on his door after the travesty that was the FFXII soundtrack? Did he turn you down after seeing the unbelievable suck that you could unleash without Hironobu Sakaguchi steering the ship?
Seriously, what is this load of bull about you guys ditching the romantic plot-lines? You want to know something, honestly? That's where the majority of the best moments in the series came from. Do you really think people mourned Aeris' death (You named her Aeris, I'm calling her Aeris) because she was a flower girl? No, they mourned her death because Cloud fell in love with her. Do you think people were sad when Rinoa went into a coma because it meant their power-leveling had gone to waste? No, they wanted her back because she made Squall whole. Don't tell me I'm being a pansy for wanting romance in these stories. I'm telling you the truth.
Why did you decide to make the gameplay exactly like the fighting from XI? Was XI so unbelievably good in your eyes that you had to keep going with it? I guess I couldn't see the good parts of the combat in XI around all of the other players. Oh, yeah, that's right, the servers were emptier than a library in Las Vegas, because even the idiots in the MMORPG community weren't stupid enough to play that trash.
In the end, this only angers me because I love the old Final Fantasies so much. I grew up with them, really, and now you're ripping apart my childhood memories. Thanks a ton for that.
Do you hear me, Square? Cut the crap. You know you're screwing up. So stop doing it. You can turn this series around, I know you can. But you have to stop assuming that people will like Final Fantasy because it's Final Fantasy. They won't. I'm living proof.
Sincerely,
Jack
Woo-hoo! Thought it would be a good idea to post again. I wasn't making blogs 'cause, you know, nothing interesting has been happening, and why should I waste your time with "well, today I didn't do anything..." posts? This was inspired by me going back and finally re-playing FFVIII, and suddenly coming to the realization that it's one of the greatest experiences I've ever had. Just finished it a few hours ago, in fact. Still getting myself back together.
Log in to comment