@LZ71 said:
@MirkoS77 said:
Also, those CGI actors. My God, amazing stuff. There were a few points where you could tell they were artificial, but really only if you'd gone in knowing they were in the first place.
Really? I mean I had no idea going in and I could tell something was off immediately when the first character came on screen, aside the fact that he's, you know, dead. It gets even worse when he's with other actual actors on screen. I'm not denying that it isn't a technical marvel that they could do it at all (though it brings up certain ethical issues that others have addressed in threads on here), but the implementation here was distracting (to say the least) for me and the others in the theater I talked to afterwards. I felt it very much was in the uncanny valley, but maybe I'm just the minority. I'd have rather they just used different actors, it's not like we as an audience don't have an imagination and an understanding that a guy who played a role thirty years ago can't reprise it now.
Not a rhetorical question nor meant to be snide, but you didn't know that they had passed before seeing this? As I said, there were a few points (noticeably the eyes) where they looked a bit off, but for the most part I thought it was a commendable job. Mannerisms, expressions, voices. It's not there 100%, but it's getting very close. It's extremely hard when we have real actor's footage to compare to, and due to how well it held up (albeit imperfect), I was left impressed.
I was more put off by Vader's voice, tbh. It wasn't nearly as baritone as it was in the OTs, but perhaps that was intentional as he was younger. Still, in RotS he sounded lower.
Log in to comment