The game was not nearly deserving of the high praise it receieved.
I read a bunch of reviews for the game, picked it up, and expecting something....you know, fun. I was letdown.
Ever since then, I stopped buying Nintendo games on or near release. I wait at least 6 months to pick something up. After that time, the hype from waiting from for a new Mario has died down, and many of the fanboys go away. You can actually get a honest answer if you fish through the blatent fanboyisms.
Not to just leave you with a rant, I came up with a theory of sorts, trying to figure out why such high praise.
I don't think I'm stretching anything by saying that largely, the media grew up with Mario, so it has the nostalgic feeling. Rating something highly makes it feel like thier holding on to their past more, and by somehow praising a titles newest outting, making thier past seem more valuable.
Take a look at Sonic Adventure. The DC crew loved the game. But when the port was released on GC....pretty bad scores. I know that it was a older port, and there were some flaws, but in the 5 range is pushing it. Especially when you look at some of the GBA/DS old Mario collections.
On Sonic Adventure DX there was this quote "very sloppy port of a game that has long been undeserving of its high praise".
And then they go on and give Mario unreal scores.
Flame on.
Log in to comment