@AllHailTheSith I'll stand for the who-man, Carl may not deliver 100% correct reviews every time, but neither do all the other reviewer, it will always come to down to personal opinion. Personally I think this episode sucked ass and I wouldn't rate it higher than 6, literally nothing happens in this episode and the choices you make always have the same result:
(SPOILERS)
Help/don't help Christa -> Nothing changes
Kill/don't kill dog -> Nothing changes
Accept/Decline some guys apology -> Nothing changes
Give/don't give water to some dying guy -> Nothing changes
Help guy a or guy b -> end game.
"All setup, little payoff" couldn't be more right on.
Noclippin's comments