Id tell you to et final fantasy 2, but considering its such an old game, and probably the worst final fantasy ever made, id say only get it if youre a die hard final fantasy fan (i am). valkyrie profile is a fun game, and its pretty cheap these days, so id go with that. im waiting for crisis core on the psp rpg front.

ps, i know how you feel about being interested in games that reviewers seem to hate, as i love the silent hill series. the only well reviewed silent hill game was 4, and that one is considered the worst among silent hill fans, so go figure