Most video game journalism isn't very well written. A good bit of it falls into the category of "unbearably awful", too. GameSpot's writing is about average, but they also have a much larger problem on their hands:
Their review and scores don't make any sense. I'll use three examples to prove my point: the reviews for Metroid Prime 3, Super Metroid, and BioShock.
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption was scored an 8.5. It received the emblem for a Great Sequel. However, this is quite contradictory and a little confusing coupled with the fact that the game itself was criticized for being too familiar. Why would those two go hand in hand?
Super Metroid also scored an 8.5. Here's the tagline: "As 2D action adventure games go, Super Metroid does nearly everything right." Yes, you read that correctly. Such a tagline was given to a game that scored an 8.5, and with a review that's only complaint was the game wasn't new (a rather stupid complaint in itself), one has to wonder why this game was given an 8.5.
Then we come to BioShock. BioShock scored a 9.0, Editor's Choice. You may not think I have much to complain about, but just you wait. What BioShock was docked points from scoring a 9.5 is absolutely ridiculous. Most complaints were essentially nit-picking, and the biggest one was the easy difficulty level. I ask you, what kind of reasons are those to dock a game points?
Earlier, I made a comment in someone's blog about a similar topic. I said Iprefer short, poorly written journalism to long, poorly written journalism. I'm rescinding that statement. While GameSpot's reviews may not be poorly written, it's inexcusable for how much detail they go into. There's almost none. You have the good parts of the game, the bad parts of the game, but you have no idea what those would be in the context. You know nothing about the game itself, only what's good and bad about certain parts of it. And those parts aren't even gone into much detail. The shooting isn't very good? Okay, thanks. How so? If you have not read the preview for Super Smash Bros. Brawl yet, I highly recommend you do. The detail they go into is absolutely laughable.
Log in to comment