No Prayer for the Dying (1990)
When I first heard this album, my exact words upon removing my headphones were "that honestly wasn't too bad; if this is bad then half of The Number of the Beast is condemnable." And after listening to the album a few more times I still stand by those words. From start to finish, there were no real low moments for me, only being a small notch below the aforementioned album since it had a couple tracks that were closer to being classics than anything here. No Prayer for the Dying isn't nearly as much of a return to form for the band as much as it is a merely straightforward release that's fitting for a casual listening. As for Bruce Dickinson's change in vocal style, this barely came into my mind and I didn't mind it since I've never considered him as amazing as the band's fanboys do (but he's definitely a great, if not excellent frontman).
Fear of the Dark (1992)
This was actually the first Maiden album I had ever listened to. And wouldn't you know it? The album of theirs I'm currently the most familiar with is the one I'd probably hold as my least favorite all told. Now, those who know me should already understand that this means the band's worst album in my books is still good. In fact, if this album didn't have its weaker moments then it would likely be considerably higher. Unfortunately, even with songs such as the title track, "Afraid to Shoot Strangers" and "Childhood's End," the album ultimately falls short of hitting as high as their other efforts, though not significantly. The only other note I'll make is that Fear of the Dark is far and away the most inconsistent you'll ever hear Maiden in regards to studio recordings (haven't heard anything live by them save for an occasional song). The band's entire discography has been remarkably consistent in quality and each album has been a fair representation of this…except for Fear of the Dark.
The X Factor (1995)
If there were any of Maiden's albums I had close to no idea of what to expect going in, it would likely be The X Factor. While similar could be said about their first two releases, having a different vocalist once again is something I made huge note of. After being amazed how different Judas Priest sounded with Tim Owens at the helm combined with this album's surprisingly dark album artwork and long runtime, I was very curious. To my surprise, this album had the opposite effect on me compared to what I thought of Jugulator upon an initial listening. The X Factor is definitely the band's darkest album, exploring themes that really don't feel like something out of a Maiden album. But this is something I'm especially fond of. The moody atmosphere and fittingly ambient moments really made this album a pleasure to hear in spots. Unfortunately, the one part that really hurt this album for me was Blaze Baylay: he's such a limited vocalist. While he sounds fine during the low key moments, whenever he tries to raise his volume, the music suffers. It also wasn't until after hearing him that I truly appreciated Dickinson's clearly superior vocals. But even with that said he doesn't ruin the album and ultimately, I'm glad the band chose to release this album, though it's not one I'd listen to several times.
Virtual XI (1998 )
It's tough to talk much about Virtual XI since it's the least memorable of all Maiden's albums as far as I'm concerned, yet it did a fair enough job improving upon its predecessor. Yes, the change of subject matter already turned me off but the music itself was noticeably better. A big part of this can be attributed to how Blaze Baylay managed to significantly improve his vocals this time around. He was finally able to carry his louder singing voice without being an embarrassment. Once again, the runtime did begin to take its toll but this was still a mostly enjoyable album.
Brave New World (2000)
This is an album I always looked forward to hearing. In fact, had it not been for the absurd price of new CDs at FYE, I'd have likely bought it a long time ago. But not long before deciding to embark on a discography listening of the band I found it used for $7 at the same store and took the opportunity. I've listened to most of the album a few times on my trips up to my college's main campus (it's about 21 or so miles away) and though there are enough minor flaws to hold it back from being among the band's best, it's still a great collection of well-made tracks. Something to point out is that there are three guitarists on this album, which is easy to tell when taken into account during most, if not all of the songs. "Ghost of the Navigator" has become a surprising personal favorite for me while other obvious contenders like "The Wicker Man" and "The Nomad" being standouts.
Dance of Death (2003)
It's interesting that Brave New World was an album I had always looked forward to hearing but its immediate successor, Dance of Death, is one I actually felt like skipping at first. I attribute this completely to the poor album art which, after listening to it, really doesn't do the album justice. I'd say this is about on-par with its predecessor, occasionally stepping above and then below. There's also a noticeable bit of variety here with songs such as "Rainmaker" showing a more simplistic version of the band while "Paschendale" gives an idea of what they sound like for most of their recent material. Speaking of which, the latter of the aforementioned song has become a huge favorite track of mine, simply for the guitar solo and post-guitar solo stretch; pure eargasm material.
A Matter of Life and Death (2006)
And to conclude my long journey of listening to Maiden's discography is A Matter of Life and Death, which is to be succeeded by The Final Frontier sometime this coming summer. What I have to say is that if Maiden wanted to get fans amped up for anything they'd release subsequent to this album, then A Matter of Life and Death sure did the trick for me. After first hearing it, I actually thought I had found my new favorite album by the band. So much so that I thought it would be a tie stronger than The Shawshank Redemption and Planet of the Apes for my favorite film. But after giving it several listens recently I will say it has fallen a bit short of that prestigious mark, yet it retains my superb praise regardless. Length is the only gripe I can probably hold against this album without comparing it to anything else the band have released. What's interesting is that the band decided to not master this album, which I'm quite grateful for because this gives the songs a far more natural sound and flow with the concepts and themes present. Something else I have to make note of is that though the band's best albums came out in the 80s (with this being the clear exception), I prefer the sound of their recent releases (technically The X Factor onward, but this doesn't completely apply until Brave New World).
So that about sums up my thoughts on the band's discography. This definitely won't be the last time I go through their catalogue and I very much look forward to the release of The Final Frontier. And now I'll leave you with how I'd rank their currently released albums, my favorite at the top.
1. Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
2. A Matter of Life and Death
3. Powerslave
4. Somewhere In Time
5. Brave New World
6. Dance of Death
7. Killers
8. Iron Maiden
9. Piece of Mind
10. The Number of the Beast
11. Virtual XI
12. The X Factor
13. No Prayer for the Dying
14. Fear of the Dark
I also might decide to actually do a video giving a versus of Iron Maiden versus Judas Priest. Even though I hate seeing the two debated (since they usually exhibit noticeably different genres, I'd like to get my thoughts out on-video and I think it might make an interesting video if I can do a decent enough job).
Log in to comment