wait, wait, wait.......so you want to use Metacritic now? Where was this argument last year when Halo ODST was AAA for X360.......oh but under your conditions it was AA. So last year X360 was even more pathetic?darthogre

correct. I personally use metacritic. good thing this is 2010 now. 2009 was terrible :P

[QUOTE="ZuneHD"]

[QUOTE="GordonRamsay23"]

If you are going to compare libraries, why do you pretend PCs dont exist?

GordonRamsay23

i admit it exists.

thread title says 360 vs ps3. stay on topic please :)

Then shouldn't the thread title be 360 vs PS3 vs PC?

??

Im made a list of all 360 "games" this year that arent on ps3. The ps3 list are "games" that arent on 360.

The thread title says 360 VS PS3.........

Seriously............there should be no problem here lol

[QUOTE="ZuneHD"]

[QUOTE="jon_cia"]

anything can be made to look in your favour if you add rediculous conditions, so please no multiplats

GordonRamsay23

lol I never said this was an exclusive comparison. Its a library comparison.

If PS3 cant play any of those games on the 360 list, it deserves to be mentioned. Plain and simple.

I NEVER said they are exclusive, im admitting they are multiplat. What I am saying is that anything on one but not the other deserves a mention.

If you are going to compare libraries, why do you pretend PCs dont exist?

i admit it exists.

thread title says 360 vs ps3. stay on topic please :)

[QUOTE="ZuneHD"]

[QUOTE="jon_cia"]

anything can be made to look in your favour if you add rediculous conditions, so please no multiplats

jon_cia

lol I never said this was an exclusive comparison. Its a library comparison.

If PS3 cant play any of those games on the 360 list, it deserves to be mentioned. Plain and simple.

I NEVER said they are exclusive, im admitting they are multiplat. What I am saying is that anything on one but not the other deserves a mention.

if someone CAN play any of those games WITHOUT a 360 then they shouldnt be on the list. plain and simple

thread title is 360 vs ps3. stay on topic please :)

anything can be made to look in your favour if you add rediculous conditions, so please no multiplats

jon_cia

lol I never said this was an exclusive comparison. Its a library comparison.

If PS3 cant play any of those games on the 360 list, it deserves to be mentioned. Plain and simple.

I NEVER said they are exclusive, im admitting they are multiplat. What I am saying is that anything on one but not the other deserves a mention.

You *will* get ripped apart for using MC and multiplats :P

Nice list though, things are very even for retail and XBLA dominates as usual

locopatho

I dont see the problem.......... logically dozens of review sources are more credible then just one.

And while some may see that only exclusives should count, I personally think that if one can play it and not the other, it deserves a mention. Besides, PS3 gamers complained about Splinter cell and ME2 not being on pS3.........they wouldnt do that if they didnt want them.

But ya, this is an unbiased list, I favour the 360 personally but as of now, this is what both have brought to the table.

Modnation racers should be added soon

I only use metacritic because it uses the average of many reviews, rather then GS that while a great site, is only one review source.

Your welcome to say that only exclusives should count but this list counts anything that is on one but not the other, regardless if its exclusive or multiplat.

EDIT: Not surprisingly...........many people, who I assume are pro-PS3, seem to be overly defensive when seeing this list.......somehow pretending that the 360 games dont exist just because they are multiplat. Meh

360 METACRITIC.COM

AAA (1) = Mass Effect 2
AA (2) = Splinter Cell Conviction, Alan Wake
A = (4) = Metro 2033, Supreme Commander 2, Tropico 3, Lips: I Love the 80's

XBLA METACRITIC.COM

AAA (0) =
AA (3) = Darwinia+, Misadventures of P. B. Winterbottom, Toy Soldiers
A (3) = Perfect Dark, Lazy Raiders, Chime

PS3 METACRITIC.COM

AAA (2) = God of War 3, MLB 10 The Show
AA (1) = Heavy Rain,
A (3) = MAG, Yakuza 3, 3D Dot Game Heroes

PSN METACRITIC.COM

AAA (0) =
AA (2) = Hustle Kings, Sam & Max: The Devil's Playhouse Episode 1 - The Penal Zone
A (0) =

well not sony. They promised gamers the best.

The best doesnt have third place marketshare :P

this game will pull a heavy rain: score high AA on metacritic.

AAA metacritic games tend to have a ton of 100's..........modnation racers has a few 90's...........all its gonna take is a 80 here and a 70 there and BAM.......AA.

cause its selling fine without it